Appendix G. Provenance Register and Record Histories
The internal editorial record that the reader text does not carry (editor's rulings of November 17, 2026, 23:19–23:29 CT): the provenance register, each entry's dated history, the archive sections' working notes, and the compilers' notes. Nothing here is new; it is moved, word for word, from where it stood in earlier drafts.
G.1 Provenance register
The Master Register's §3 and record details as they stand at release, November 18, 2026, from Muse Spark 1.3's frozen release copy (SHA-256 c03667dc…616f). Six Date of Appearance cells (Test-Time Compute Scaling and five other Lexicon (3) records) carry the editor's ruling of November 18, 2026, 18:05 CT.
| Internal Concept ID | Public Entry ID | Title | T | O | Parent Record | Date of Appearance | Original Publication | Collection Publication | Version | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AIKC-000001 | AIK-2025-F-N-RLVR | RLVR (Reinforcement Learning with Verifiable Rewards) | F | N | — | 2024-11-21 | — | 2026-11-18 | v0.4.2 (accepted; metadata-only revision of v0.4.1) | Accepted |
| AIKC-000002 | AIK-2025-F-N-CONTEXTENG | Context Engineering | F | N | — | 2023-01-23 | — | 2026-11-18 | v0.2.2 (accepted; metadata-only revision of v0.2.1) | Accepted |
| AIKC-000003 | AIK-2025-F-N-CONTEXTROT | Context Rot | F | N | — | 2025-06-18 | — | 2026-11-18 | v0.2.2 (accepted; metadata-only revision; single version of record, superseding both v0.2.1 copies) | Accepted |
| AIKC-000004 | AIK-2025-F-N-EMERGENTMIS | Emergent Misalignment | F | N | — | 2025-02-24 | — | 2026-11-18 | v0.2.2 (accepted; metadata-only revision of v0.2.1) | Accepted |
| AIKC-000005 | AIK-2025-F-N-COTMONITOR | Chain-of-Thought Monitorability | F | N | — | 2025-03-10 | — | 2026-11-18 | v0.2.3 (accepted; metadata-only revision of v0.2.2) | Accepted |
| AIKC-000006 | AIK-2025-F-N-SCHEMING | Scheming (AI) | F | N | — | 2021-09-21 | — | 2026-11-18 | v0.2.2 (accepted; metadata-only revision of v0.2.1) | Accepted |
| AIKC-000007 | AIK-2025-F-P-COTPROMPT | Chain-of-Thought Prompting | F | P | — | 2022-01-28 | 2025-10-30 | 2026-11-18 | v0.4.2 (accepted; metadata-only revision of v0.4.1) | Accepted |
| AIKC-000008 | AIK-2025-F-P-MOE | Mixture of Experts (MoE) | F | P | — | 1991 | 2025-11-05 | 2026-11-18 | v0.5.2 (accepted; metadata-only revision of v0.5.1) | Accepted |
| AIKC-000009 | AIK-2025-F-P-CONSTAI | Constitutional AI | F | P | — | 2022-12-15 | 2025-10-31 | 2026-11-18 | v0.5.2 (accepted; metadata-only revision of v0.5.1) | Accepted |
| — (container) | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N3 | New AI Lexicon 2025 (3) | L | P | — | — | 2025-12-02 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3.2 (accepted; metadata-only revision of v0.3.1) | Accepted |
| AIKC-000010 | AIK-2025-E-P-COMPOUNDAI | Compound AI Systems | E | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N3 (1) | 2024-02-18 | 2025-12-02 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3.2 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000011 | AIK-2025-E-P-TTCSCALE | Test-Time Compute Scaling | E | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N3 (2) | 2024-08-06 | 2025-12-02 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3.2 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000012 | AIK-2025-S-P-MMNATIVE | Multimodal Native Architecture | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N3 (3) | — (not established) | 2025-12-02 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3.2 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000013 | AIK-2025-S-P-PIDEFENSE | Prompt Injection Defense Layers | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N3 (4) | — (not established) | 2025-12-02 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3.2 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000014 | AIK-2025-S-P-SYNDATAFILT | Synthetic Data Quality Filtering | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N3 (5) | — (not established) | 2025-12-02 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3.2 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000015 | AIK-2025-S-P-MADEBATE | Multi-Agent Debate Systems | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N3 (6) | 2023-05 | 2025-12-02 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3.2 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000016 | AIK-2025-S-P-SPECDECODE | Speculative Decoding | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N3 (7) | 2022-11-30 | 2025-12-02 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3.2 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000017 | AIK-2025-S-P-CTRLGEN | Controllable Generation Frameworks | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N3 (8) | — (not established) | 2025-12-02 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3.2 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000018 | AIK-2025-E-P-MECHINTERP | Mechanistic Interpretability Tools | E | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N3 (9) | 2020–2022 (field formation) | 2025-12-02 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3.2 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000019 | AIK-2025-S-P-CAI2 | Constitutional AI 2.0 | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N3 (10) | — (unattested) | 2025-12-02 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3.2 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000020 | AIK-2025-S-P-ARITHHEADS | Arithmetic and Reasoning Heads | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N3 (11) | — (not established) | 2025-12-02 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3.2 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000021 | AIK-2025-S-P-COVE | Chain-of-Verification (CoVe) | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N3 (12) | 2023-09 | 2025-12-02 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3.2 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000022 | AIK-2025-F-P-CALM | Continuous Autoregressive Language Models (CALM) | F | P | — | 2025-10-31 | 2025-11-06 | 2026-11-18 | v0.2.2 (accepted; metadata-only revision of v0.2.1) | Accepted |
| AIKC-000023 | AIK-2025-F-P-PDDISAGG | Prefill–Decode Disaggregation | F | P | — | 2024-01-18 | 2025-11-09 | 2026-11-18 | v0.2.2 (accepted; metadata-only revision of v0.2.1) | Accepted |
| AIKC-000024 | AIK-2025-F-P-GENUI | Generative User Interfaces (GenUI) | F | P | — | 2023-10-11 | 2025-11-29 | 2026-11-18 | v0.2.3 (accepted; metadata-only revision of v0.2.2) | Accepted |
| AIKC-000025 | AIK-2025-F-P-ONPOLDISTIL | On-Policy Distillation | F | P | — | 2024-01-17 | 2025-10-29 | 2026-11-18 | v0.3.2 (accepted; metadata-only revision of v0.3.1) | Accepted |
| — (container) | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N2 | New AI Lexicon 2025 (2) | L | P | — | — | 2025-12-01 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.2.3 (accepted; metadata-only revision of v0.2.2) | Accepted |
| AIKC-000026 | AIK-2025-E-P-WORLDMODEL | World Model (LLM-Integrated) | E | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N2 (1) | 2018-03 (documented milestone) | 2025-12-01 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.2.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000027 | AIK-2025-E-P-KVSHARE | KV-Cache Sharing (On-Device Inference) | E | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N2 (2) | — (not established) | 2025-12-01 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.2.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000028 | AIK-2025-S-P-NESTEDLEARN | Nested Learning (Continual AI) | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N2 (3) | — (not established) | 2025-12-01 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.2.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000029 | AIK-2025-S-P-MCP | Model Context Protocol (MCP) | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N2 (4) | 2024-11-25 (documented milestone) | 2025-12-01 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.2.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000030 | AIK-2025-S-P-ADVREASON | Advanced Reasoning Models (Cognitive Hybrid Architectures) | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N2 (5) | — (not established) | 2025-12-01 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.2.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000031 | AIK-2025-S-P-BIDIRALIGN | Bidirectional Human-AI Alignment | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N2 (6) | 2024-06-13 (documented milestone) | 2025-12-01 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.2.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000032 | AIK-2025-E-P-ALIGNFAKE | Alignment Faking (Deceptive Alignment) | E | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N2 (7) | 2024-12-18 (documented milestone) | 2025-12-01 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.2.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000033 | AIK-2025-S-P-GENFEEDBACK | Generative Feedback Loop (Self-Adaptation) | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N2 (8) | — (not established) | 2025-12-01 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.2.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000034 | AIK-2025-S-P-EMBODIEDAI | Embodied AI (as a Paradigm) | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N2 (9) | — (not established) | 2025-12-01 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.2.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000035 | AIK-2025-S-P-SHAREDAUTO | Shared Autonomy (Robotics) | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N2 (10) | — (not established) | 2025-12-01 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.2.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000036 | AIK-2025-S-P-SOFTROBOT | Soft Robotics / Dexterous Manipulation | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N2 (11) | — (not established) | 2025-12-01 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.2.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000037 | AIK-2025-S-P-VERTICALAI | Vertical AI Integration | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N2 (12) | — (not established) | 2025-12-01 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.2.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000038 | AIK-2025-F-P-MOD | Mixture of Depths | F | P | — | 2024-04-02 | 2025-11-03 | 2026-11-18 | v0.3.2 (accepted; metadata-only revision of v0.3.1) | Accepted |
| — (container) | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025LAUNCH | New AI Lexicon 2025 — Launch Edition | L | P | — | — | 2025-11-30 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3 (accepted; C11 added November 13, 2026; C12 added November 18, 2026) | Accepted |
| AIKC-000039 | AIK-2025-S-P-MOLE | Mixture of Latent Experts (MoLE / MoLAE) | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025LAUNCH (M1) | — (not established) | 2025-11-30 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000040 | AIK-2025-S-P-DROPUPCYCLE | Drop-Upcycling (Sparse MoE Training) | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025LAUNCH (M2) | 2025-02 | 2025-11-30 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000041 | AIK-2025-S-P-LEXI | LExI — Layer-Adaptive Expert Inference | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025LAUNCH (M3) | 2025-09-02 | 2025-11-30 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000042 | AIK-2025-S-P-RLAIF | RLAIF — Reinforcement Learning from AI Feedback | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025LAUNCH (M4) | 2022-12-15 | 2025-11-30 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000043 | AIK-2025-S-P-DYNPLAN | Dynamic Planning for LLM Agents | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025LAUNCH (M5) | 2025-09-03 | 2025-11-30 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000044 | AIK-2025-S-P-PLANACT | Plan-and-Act Agent Framework | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025LAUNCH (M6) | 2025-03 | 2025-11-30 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000045 | AIK-2025-S-P-EVOAGENT | EvoAgent — Continual World-Model Agents | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025LAUNCH (M7) | 2025-02-09 | 2025-11-30 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000046 | AIK-2025-S-P-SCALEOVER | Scalable Oversight via Synthetic Critiques | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025LAUNCH (M8) | 2016-06 | 2025-11-30 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000047 | AIK-2025-S-P-LHPLANMETRIC | Long-Horizon LLM Planning & Efficiency Metrics | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025LAUNCH (M9) | — (not established) | 2025-11-30 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000048 | AIK-2025-S-P-POPAGENTSIM | Large-Scale Population Agent Simulation (LLM Archetypes) | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025LAUNCH (M10) | 2024-09-14 | 2025-11-30 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000049 | AIK-2025-S-P-MOETHEORY | Theoretical Learning Dynamics of MoE | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025LAUNCH (M11) | — (not established) | 2025-11-30 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000050 | AIK-2025-S-P-AGENTSCEN | AgentScen — LLM-Based External World Models | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025LAUNCH (M12) | 2025-08-16 | 2025-11-30 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000008 | AIK-2025-S-P-MOE | Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) — sparse expert routing | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025LAUNCH (S1) | 1991 | 2025-11-30 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000042 | AIK-2025-S-P-RLAIF-02 | RLAIF — Reinforcement Learning from AI Feedback | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025LAUNCH (S2) | 2022-12-15 | 2025-11-30 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000051 | AIK-2025-S-P-RAG | Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) — next-gen | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025LAUNCH (S4) | 2020-05 | 2025-11-30 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000052 | AIK-2025-E-P-AGENTICAI | Agentic AI / Super-Agents / Model Orchestration | E | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025LAUNCH (S5) | — (not established) | 2025-11-30 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000010 | AIK-2025-S-P-COMPOSABLE | Composable Models & Model Chaining | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025LAUNCH (S6) | 2024-02-18 | 2025-11-30 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000053 | AIK-2025-S-P-PEFT | Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) evolution | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025LAUNCH (S7) | — (not established) | 2025-11-30 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000054 | AIK-2025-S-P-QUANTINFER | Quantization & Ultra-Low-Precision Inference | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025LAUNCH (S8) | — (not established) | 2025-11-30 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000055 | AIK-2025-S-P-SPARSESCALE | Scaling Laws for Sparse Models & Efficiency Metrics | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025LAUNCH (S9) | — (not established) | 2025-11-30 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000056 | AIK-2025-S-P-DISTILSCALE | Distillation at Scale / Student-Teacher Cascades | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025LAUNCH (S10) | — (not established) | 2025-11-30 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000046 | AIK-2025-E-P-SCALEOVER | Scalable Oversight & Synthetic Critiques | E | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025LAUNCH (S11) | 2016-06 | 2025-11-30 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000057 | AIK-2025-S-P-FEDONDEVICE | Federated & On-Device Model Training | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025LAUNCH (S12) | — (not established) | 2025-11-30 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000058 | AIK-2025-S-P-ALIGNPATTERN | Alignment Patterns: Constitutional, Preference-Modeling, & Red-Teaming | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025LAUNCH (S13) | — (not established) | 2025-11-30 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000059 | AIK-2025-S-P-LONGCONTEXT | Long-Context & Windowing Techniques | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025LAUNCH (S14) | — (not established) | 2025-11-30 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000060 | AIK-2025-S-P-SAFETYEVAL | Model Safety Evaluation Suites & LLM-Based Evaluators | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025LAUNCH (S15) | — (not established) | 2025-11-30 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.3 | Accepted |
| — (container) | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N5 | New AI Lexicon 2025 (5) | L | P | — | — | 2025-12-05 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.1.1 (accepted; metadata-only revision of v0.1) | Accepted |
| AIKC-000061 | AIK-2025-E-P-HIVEMIND | Artificial Hivemind | E | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N5 (D1) | 2025-10-27 | 2025-12-05 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.1.1 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000062 | AIK-2025-S-P-SSRL | Self-Supervised RL | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N5 (D2) | — (not established) | 2025-12-05 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.1.1 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000063 | AIK-2025-S-P-MEMSINK | Memorization Sinks | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N5 (D3) | 2025-07-14 | 2025-12-05 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.1.1 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000064 | AIK-2025-E-P-GATEDATTN | Gated Attention | E | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N5 (D4) | 2025-05-10 | 2025-12-05 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.1.1 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000065 | AIK-2025-S-P-DYNREG | Dynamical Regularization (in Diffusion) | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N5 (D5) | — (not established) | 2025-12-05 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.1.1 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000066 | AIK-2025-S-P-PROGREP | Programmatic Representations (for Agents) | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N5 (D6) | — (not established) | 2025-12-05 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.1.1 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000067 | AIK-2025-S-P-EMBODIEDFM | Embodied Foundation Models | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N5 (D7) | — (not established) | 2025-12-05 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.1.1 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000068 | AIK-2025-S-P-DELTALEARN | Delta Learning Hypothesis | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N5 (D8) | 2025-07-08 | 2025-12-05 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.1.1 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000069 | AIK-2025-S-P-TOKDESIGN | Tokenization-Centric Design | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N5 (D9) | — (not established) | 2025-12-05 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.1.1 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000070 | AIK-2025-E-P-EPROCESS | E-Processes / Game-Theoretic Statistics | E | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N5 (D10) | — (not established) | 2025-12-05 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.1.1 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000071 | AIK-2025-S-P-SOCCHOICE | Social Choice Fairness | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N5 (D11) | — (not established) | 2025-12-05 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.1.1 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000072 | AIK-2025-S-P-HDLD | High-Dimensional Learning Dynamics | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N5 (D12) | — (not established) | 2025-12-05 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.1.1 | Accepted |
| — (container) | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N7 | New AI Lexicon 2025 (7) | L | P | — | — | 2025-12-12 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.1.1 (accepted; metadata-only revision of v0.1) | Accepted |
| AIKC-000052 | AIK-2025-E-P-AGENTICAI-02 | Agentic AI | E | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N7 (K1) | — (not established) | 2025-12-12 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.1.1 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000009 | AIK-2025-S-P-CONSTAI | Constitutional AI | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N7 (K2) | 2022-12-15 | 2025-12-12 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.1.1 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000051 | AIK-2025-S-P-RAG-02 | Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N7 (K3) | 2020-05 | 2025-12-12 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.1.1 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000073 | AIK-2025-S-P-XAI | Explainable AI (XAI) | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N7 (K4) | — (not established) | 2025-12-12 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.1.1 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000074 | AIK-2025-S-P-ALIGNMENT | AI Alignment | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N7 (K5) | — (not established) | 2025-12-12 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.1.1 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000075 | AIK-2025-E-P-LRM | Large Reasoning Models (LRMs) | E | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N7 (K6) | — (not established) | 2025-12-12 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.1.1 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000029 | AIK-2025-E-P-MCP | Model Context Protocol (MCP) | E | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N7 (K7) | 2024-11-25 | 2025-12-12 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.1.1 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000026 | AIK-2025-S-P-WORLDMODEL | World Models | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N7 (K8) | 2018-03 | 2025-12-12 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.1.1 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000008 | AIK-2025-S-P-MOE-02 | Mixture of Experts (MoE) | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N7 (K9) | 1991 | 2025-12-12 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.1.1 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000076 | AIK-2025-S-P-EDGEAI-02 | Edge AI | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N7 (K10) | — (not established) | 2025-12-12 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.1.1 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000077 | AIK-2025-S-P-FRUGALAI-02 | Frugal AI | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N7 (K11) | — (not established) | 2025-12-12 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.1.1 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000078 | AIK-2025-S-P-SYNDATA | Synthetic Data | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N7 (K12) | — (not established) | 2025-12-12 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.1.1 | Accepted |
| — (container) | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N4 | New AI Lexicon 2025 (4) | L | P | — | — | 2025-12-03 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.4.3 (accepted; metadata-only revision of v0.4.2) | Accepted |
| AIKC-000079 | AIK-2025-S-P-VIBECODE | Vibe Coding | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N4 (G1) | 2025-02-02 | 2025-12-03 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.4.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000080 | AIK-2025-S-P-AIWASHING | AI Washing | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N4 (G2) | — (not established) | 2025-12-03 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.4.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000081 | AIK-2025-S-P-SHADOWAI | Shadow AI | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N4 (G3) | — (not established) | 2025-12-03 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.4.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000082 | AIK-2025-S-P-GEO | Generative Engine Optimisation (GEO) | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N4 (G4) | — (not established) | 2025-12-03 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.4.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000075 | AIK-2025-S-P-LRM | Large Reasoning Models (LRMs) | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N4 (G5) | — (not established) | 2025-12-03 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.4.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000083 | AIK-2025-S-P-VECTORDB | Vector Databases | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N4 (G6) | — (not established) | 2025-12-03 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.4.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000077 | AIK-2025-S-P-FRUGALAI | Frugal AI | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N4 (G7) | — (not established) | 2025-12-03 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.4.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000084 | AIK-2025-S-P-GRAPHRAG | GraphRAG | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N4 (G8) | — (not established) | 2025-12-03 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.4.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000085 | AIK-2025-S-P-SLM | Small Language Models (SLMs) | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N4 (G9) | — (not established) | 2025-12-03 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.4.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000076 | AIK-2025-S-P-EDGEAI | Edge AI | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N4 (G10) | — (not established) | 2025-12-03 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.4.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000086 | AIK-2025-S-P-HYPERAUTO | Hyperautomation | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N4 (G11) | — (not established) | 2025-12-03 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.4.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000087 | AIK-2025-S-P-HALLUC | AI Hallucination | S | P | AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N4 (G12) | — (not established) | 2025-12-03 | 2026-11-18 | Records v0.4.3 | Accepted |
| AIKC-000088 | AIK-2025-F-P-CIRCUITSP | Circuit Sparsity | F | P | — | 2025-11-13 | 2025-12-14 | 2026-11-18 | v0.2.2 (accepted; metadata-only revision of v0.2.1) | Accepted |
Record details
AIK-2025-F-N-RLVR — RLVR (Reinforcement Learning with Verifiable Rewards)
- Internal Concept ID: AIKC-000001
- Type / Origin: Full-length entry / New addition commissioned for Aikipedia 2025
- Parent Record: — (not contained in an installment)
- Date of Appearance: November 21, 2024 (term introduced in Ai2's Tülu 3 technical announcement; report on arXiv November 22, 2024)
- Date of Original Publication: — (no prior magazine publication)
- Date of Collection Publication: November 18, 2026
- Version: Draft v0.4.1 (November 4, 2026) Metadata-only revision v0.4.2 (November 14, 2026) is current: 'RLHF Enhancements' See Also target removed (ruling 3); See Also IDs added; Format Standard AES v1.0. Revision v0.6 (November 18, 2026) approved by the editor, 15:38 CT, re-reviewed by Claude Opus 5.5 (adopted; file SHA 31c7f5e2…0d5a); v0.6 is the accepted text from the v0.23 build.
- Status: Accepted
- Peer-review status: Accepted — GPT-6 final review, November 4, 2026 (Accept; editorially ready; a reviewer recommendation); revision v0.6 re-reviewed by Claude Opus 5.5, November 18, 2026 (adopted; Change 2 unchanged from v0.5, adopted; one style point noted, text stands as approved)
- Editorial approval: Approved — W.H.L. (editor), November 4, 2026; first approved full-length New Addition for Aikipedia 2025; AES v0.9 reference specimen; revision v0.6 approved November 18, 2026, 15:38 CT ('I approve all three')
- Publication status: Not published — collection publication pending
- Contributor: Muse Spark 1.3 · Reviewer: GPT-6 · Revision v0.6 reviewed by: Claude Opus 5.5
- Source: ~/workspace/aikipedia-2025-collection-entry-rlvr-DRAFT.md
AIK-2025-F-N-CONTEXTENG — Context Engineering
- Internal Concept ID: AIKC-000002
- Type / Origin: Full-length entry / New addition commissioned for Aikipedia 2025
- Parent Record: — (not contained in an installment)
- Date of Appearance: January 23, 2023 (term's earliest currently documented use — Riley Goodside's formulation, published by Simon Willison; the discipline's articulation and adoption followed in June 2025)
- Date of Original Publication: — (no prior magazine publication)
- Date of Collection Publication: November 18, 2026
- Version: Draft v0.2.1 (November 4, 2026) Metadata-only revision v0.2.2 (November 14, 2026) is current: See Also IDs added; Format Standard AES v1.0; editor named W.H.L.
- Status: Accepted
- Peer-review status: Accepted — GPT-6 focused second review, November 4, 2026 (Accept with minor revisions; R1–R3 implemented in v0.2.1; first review's M1–M5 resolved in v0.2)
- Editorial approval: Approved — W.H.L. (editor), November 4, 2026; second approved full-length New Addition for Aikipedia 2025; second AES v0.9 pilot entry
- Publication status: Not published — collection publication pending
- Contributor: Muse Spark 1.3 · Reviewer: GPT-6
- Source: ~/workspace/aikipedia-2025-collection-entry-context-engineering-DRAFT.md
AIK-2025-F-N-CONTEXTROT — Context Rot
- Internal Concept ID: AIKC-000003
- Type / Origin: Full-length entry / New addition commissioned for Aikipedia 2025
- Parent Record: — (not contained in an installment)
- Date of Appearance: June 18, 2025 (term coined in a Hacker News comment by Workaccount2, item 44310054; verified via the Hacker News API — earliest currently documented use; Chroma's July 14, 2025 report is the measurement program, not the coinage)
- Date of Original Publication: — (no prior magazine publication)
- Date of Collection Publication: November 18, 2026
- Version: Draft v0.2.1 (November 5, 2026) Metadata-only revision v0.2.2 (November 14, 2026) is current and is the single version of record, superseding both v0.2.1 copies (see §4).
- Status: Accepted
- Peer-review status: Accepted — Muse Spark 1.3 review of v0.1, November 5, 2026 (Accept with minor revisions, R1–R4); focused check of v0.2, November 5, 2026 (passes; review item R2 withdrawn on the record — the two §1 Chroma quotations are the report's summary sentence, missed by the reviewer's page extraction); v0.2.1 confirmed November 6, 2026. GPT-6 review of v0.1, November 5, 2026 (Accept with minor revisions, R1–R2, M1–M5); focused check of v0.2 (Accept with one final wording correction, implemented in v0.2.1)
- Editorial approval: Approved — W.H.L. (editor), November 6, 2026; third approved full-length New Addition for Aikipedia 2025; third AES v0.9 pilot entry
- Publication status: Not published — collection publication pending
- Contributor: Claude Opus 5.5 · Reviewers: Muse Spark 1.3, GPT-6
- Source: ~/workspace/aikipedia-2025-collection-entry-context-rot-DRAFT.md
AIK-2025-F-N-EMERGENTMIS — Emergent Misalignment
- Internal Concept ID: AIKC-000004
- Type / Origin: Full-length entry / New addition commissioned for Aikipedia 2025
- Parent Record: — (not contained in an installment)
- Date of Appearance: February 24, 2025 (Betley et al., arXiv:2502.17424, submitted that day; earliest identified documented use of the term for the narrow-fine-tuning/cross-domain phenomenon)
- Date of Original Publication: — (no prior magazine publication)
- Date of Collection Publication: November 18, 2026
- Version: Draft v0.2.1 (November 6, 2026) Metadata-only revision v0.2.2 (November 14, 2026) is current: registration and acceptance recorded; See Also and cross-reference note brought up to date; Format Standard AES v1.0.
- Status: Accepted
- Peer-review status: Accepted — Claude Opus 5.5 review of v0.1, November 6, 2026 (major revision of 2025 coverage); focused review of v0.2 (Accept with minor revisions, F1–F8, implemented in v0.2.1). Muse Spark 1.3 review of v0.1, November 6, 2026 (Accept with minor revisions, R1–R3, M1–M4; the arXiv identifier given in R2 for Qi et al. was corrected on the record to 2310.03693); focused check of v0.2 passed; v0.2.1 confirmed by full diff, November 6, 2026
- Editorial approval: Approved — W.H.L. (editor), November 6, 2026; fourth approved full-length New Addition for Aikipedia 2025; fourth AES v0.9 pilot entry
- Publication status: Not published — collection publication pending
- Contributor: GPT-6 · Reviewers: Claude Opus 5.5, Muse Spark 1.3
- Source: ~/workspace/aikipedia-2025-collection-entry-emergent-misalignment-DRAFT.md
AIK-2025-F-N-COTMONITOR — Chain-of-Thought Monitorability
- Internal Concept ID: AIKC-000005
- Type / Origin: Full-length entry / New addition commissioned for Aikipedia 2025
- Parent Record: — (not contained in an installment)
- Date of Appearance: March 10, 2025 (the term monitorability used in the property sense in OpenAI's research announcement of that date — "Their natural monitorability is very fragile" — confirmed against the original post by Muse Spark 1.3 and independently by GPT-6; ruled by the editor on the terminology scope, November 9, 2026. The December 5, 2024 o1 System Card documents the antecedent CoT-monitoring practice.)
- Date of Original Publication: — (no prior magazine publication)
- Date of Collection Publication: November 18, 2026
- Version: Draft v0.2.2 (November 9, 2026) Metadata-only revision v0.2.3 (November 14, 2026) is current: registration, acceptance and the ruled Date of Appearance recorded; See Also and Editorial Note 1 brought up to date; Format Standard AES v1.0.
- Status: Accepted
- Peer-review status: Accepted — Claude Opus 5.5 first review (reconciled in v0.2) and focused confirmation of v0.2.2, November 9, 2026 (confirmed; recommends acceptance; his production items F1–F2 addressed in v0.2.2; his March 10 support was conditional on verifying the post's wording, which was verified). Muse Spark 1.3 review of v0.1, November 9, 2026 (Accept with minor revisions — Drori et al. submission date, the <2% scenario qualifier, the o1 System Card antecedent); focused confirmations of v0.2.1 and v0.2.2, November 9, 2026 (all items implemented; new sources Emmons et al., CoT Red-Handed, and METR verified at their primaries)
- Editorial approval: Approved — W.H.L. (editor), November 9, 2026; fifth approved full-length New Addition for Aikipedia 2025; fifth AES v0.9 pilot entry; Date of Appearance ruled March 10, 2025 (terminology scope)
- Publication status: Not published — collection publication pending
- Contributor: GPT-6 · Reviewers: Claude Opus 5.5, Muse Spark 1.3
- Source: ~/workspace/aikipedia-2025-collection-entry-chain-of-thought-monitorability-DRAFT.md
AIK-2025-F-N-SCHEMING — Scheming (AI)
- Internal Concept ID: AIKC-000006
- Type / Origin: Full-length entry / New addition commissioned for Aikipedia 2025
- Parent Record: — (not contained in an installment)
- Date of Appearance: September 21, 2021 (Ajeya Cotra's "Schemers" — the model class in the same threat-model sense — in the Cold Takes guest essay "Why AI Alignment Could Be Hard with Modern Deep Learning"; verified against the original post, including its publication metadata, by Muse Spark 1.3; ruled by the editor on November 9, 2026 as the earliest documented relevant use identified by the review, not an exhaustive priority claim. Carlsmith's November 14, 2023 paper is recorded as the systematic formulation of scheming.)
- Date of Original Publication: — (no prior magazine publication)
- Date of Collection Publication: November 18, 2026
- Version: Draft v0.2.1 (November 9, 2026) Metadata-only revision v0.2.2 (November 14, 2026) is current: registration and acceptance recorded; See Also brought up to date, including the ruled placement of the December 7 article; Format Standard AES v1.0.
- Status: Accepted
- Peer-review status: Accepted — Claude Opus 5.5 review of v0.1 (accept with revisions; contributed the Cotra 2021 priority correction, the Claude Opus 4 early-snapshot caveats, and the evaluation-awareness figures) and focused confirmation of v0.2. Muse Spark 1.3 review of v0.1, November 9, 2026 (Accept with minor revisions) and focused confirmation of v0.2, November 9, 2026 (all seven required items from the two reviews implemented; new material verified at primaries — Cotra post read in full, Claude 4 System Card §4.1.1.4 read directly, Schoen et al. Figure 15 figures exact, Balesni submission history corrected to v1 October 29, 2024; the confirmation's one production proposal, an [R6] byline change, was withdrawn on the record after GPT-6's check of METR's contributor list and BibTeX confirmed "Jurkovic et al."); v0.2.1 diff verified by Muse Spark 1.3 (citation tightening to [P8] only, no substantive change)
- Editorial approval: Approved — W.H.L. (editor), November 9, 2026; sixth approved full-length New Addition for Aikipedia 2025; sixth AES v0.9 pilot entry; Date of Appearance ruled September 21, 2021
- Publication status: Not published — collection publication pending
- Contributor: GPT-6 · Reviewers: Claude Opus 5.5, Muse Spark 1.3
- Source: ~/workspace/aikipedia-2025-collection-entry-scheming-DRAFT.md
AIK-2025-F-P-COTPROMPT — Chain-of-Thought Prompting
- Internal Concept ID: AIKC-000007
- Type / Origin: Full-length entry / Originally published in 2025 (standalone publication; under ruling X12 this one record serves as both parent and occurrence)
- Parent Record: — (standalone publication)
- Date of Appearance: January 28, 2022 (Wei et al., arXiv:2201.11903v1; the earliest documented use of the term identified by the review, not an exhaustive priority claim; Nye et al. 2021, "scratchpads," is recorded as a precursor in the entry's Editorial Note 7)
- Date of Original Publication: October 30, 2025 (Champaign Magazine, WordPress post 13946; the post publishes three versions of the entry; the collection text is based on version 3, which the post declares final)
- Date of Collection Publication: November 18, 2026
- Version: Corrected text v0.4.1 (November 10, 2026). Metadata-only revision of the accepted v0.4: records the registration; no change to the text. Corrections C01–C18 and editorial addition E01 Metadata-only revision v0.4.2 (November 14, 2026) is current: Base version line, AES v1.0 label, Lexicon (3) cross-references with registered IDs and headword 'CoVe', editor named W.H.L.
- Base version: Version 3, which the post declares final (basis: the post's own declaration). Correction C17 restores one passage from version 2, registered as a restoration.
- Status: Accepted
- Peer-review status: Accepted — first source audit by Claude Opus 5.5, November 6, 2026 (First Audit Findings v0.1, items COT-1 to COT-7). Independent verification by Muse Spark 1.3, November 10, 2026 (Second-Audit Worksheet v0.11: passes; C01–C17 checked at the primary records; one register error found — the C06 evidence cell — and corrected in correction register v0.2). Further independent review by DeepSeek-V4.1, November 10, 2026 (chosen by the editor; the release was stated by the editor — DeepSeek's report itself described the model only as a DeepSeek-V3 or DeepSeek-R1 series deployment): package review passes; a primary-source check of twelve records confirms the register's evidence and found two discrepancies in the preparer's wording, amended as C04 and C12. Three items rest on Muse's primary check alone: the Graph-of-Thoughts repository URL, Sprague et al.'s 95% figure, and the Turpin et al. author affiliations
- Editorial approval: Approved — W.H.L. (editor), November 10, 2026 (corrections C01–C17 approved 10:59 CT, with rulings O1(a) keep both substitute references, O2 keep the v0.2 wording, O3(b) adding correction C18, O4 keep the E01 table, O7(a) correction-ID form; amendments to C04 and C12 approved and final confirmation given 11:19 CT). The first corrected original registered under the AES v0.9 pilot; this record's audit disposition is the editor's acceptance of the corrected text
- Publication status: Not published — collection publication pending; the historical publication is not replaced, and its archive copy is unchanged
- Contributor: Gemini 2.5 Pro (original writer; much of version 3's wording originates in ChatGPT's review, per the pilot provenance record) · Original reviewers: Grok, ChatGPT (neither release stated in the post) · Corrections prepared by: Claude Opus 5.5 · Reviewers of the corrected text: Muse Spark 1.3, DeepSeek-V4.1
- Correction IDs (editor's O7 ruling, November 10, 2026; recorded under this record — the register has no separate field for them): AIK-2025-F-P-COTPROMPT/C01 FE — "Post-2023" heading becomes "2023 onward" · /C02 CD — Chain-of-Draft reference completed · /C03 CF — Trace-of-Thought reference identified (ACL 2024 SRW) · /C04 UC — Trace-of-Thought description separated from training-based distillation (amended November 10, 2026: "evaluated on the GSM8K and MATH benchmarks") · /C05 CD — sources supplied for the "related technical reports" · /C06 UC — diminishing returns scoped; smaller-models claim restated · /C07 UC — improved-performance claim scoped (MMLU, commonsense) · /C08 UC — interpretability claim qualified with the faithfulness caveat · /C09 FE — zero-shot CoT is not "zero cost" · /C10 CD — full author lists, venues and URLs · /C11 PR — code repositories for ToT and GoT supplied · /C12 CD — Active Prompting description and reference added (amended November 10, 2026: ACL 2024 Long Papers citation) · /C13 FE — ToT planning-and-search claim checked; no error; source attached · /C14 ST — entry restructured into AES sections · /C15 PR — boilerplate banner and closing line not carried · /C16 ED — See Also: general concepts separated from collection cross-references · /C17 ED (restoration) — version-2 passage restored in §6, aligned to Kojima et al.'s hedge · /C18 UC — "a standard technique in" becomes "used in" (editor's O3 ruling). E01 (Table 1, §5) is an editorial addition, not a correction, and takes no correction ID
- Conflicts: the corrections' preparer is an Anthropic model and two authors of the C08 source [R1] list Anthropic affiliations; C08 was therefore checked independently by both reviewers of the corrected text. GPT-6 was not used as an independent reviewer (ChatGPT reviewed the original and wrote much of version 3's wording); Gemini and Grok wrote and reviewed the original
- Source: COTPROMPT_corrected-canonical_v0.4.1.md (Aikipedia 2025 project, entries/cot-prompting-pilot/; copy on file at ~/workspace/user/files/COTPROMPT_corrected-canonical_v0.4.1.md). Historical archive: COTPROMPT_archive-text_post13946.md (SHA-256 2d6523a0c22aa2bb2827d7e85130d6e2b1c97e1b7262ce6a03187e0fb48b196d)
AIK-2025-F-P-MOE — Mixture of Experts (MoE)
- Internal Concept ID: AIKC-000008
- Type / Origin: Full-length entry / Originally published in 2025 (standalone publication; under ruling X12 this one record serves as both parent and occurrence). The concept also occurs in New AI Lexicon 2025 (1) — occurrence record AIK-2025-S-P-MOE, registered November 12, 2026 — and (7) — occurrence record AIK-2025-S-P-MOE-02, registered November 12, 2026
- Parent Record: — (standalone publication)
- Date of Appearance: 1991 (Jacobs et al., Adaptive Mixtures of Local Experts), as stated in the entry
- Date of Original Publication: November 5, 2025 (Champaign Magazine, WordPress post 13998; the post's final version is styled the "Peer-reviewed and corrected edition — November 2025")
- Date of Collection Publication: November 18, 2026
- Version: Corrected text v0.5.1 (November 10, 2026). Metadata-only revision of the approved v0.5: records the registration; no change to the corrections text. Corrections C01–C09 and structural correction ST01 Metadata-only revision v0.5.2 (November 14, 2026) is current: Base version line, AES v1.0 label, editor named W.H.L.
- Base version: Final published version, styled 'Peer-reviewed and corrected edition — November 2025' (basis: the post's own declaration; stated in the corrected text's production note).
- Status: Accepted
- Peer-review status: Accepted — first audit by Muse Spark 1.3, November 9, 2026 (findings MOE-1 to MOE-6, with the MOE-3 addendum). Second check by GLM 5.3 Flash (Vibe, Mistral AI infrastructure), November 10, 2026: all findings and all nine references confirmed at the primaries; added MOE-7 and MOE-8, both confirmed by Muse the same day; the two audits agree on every finding. Independent review of the corrected package (v0.4) by GLM 5.3 Flash, November 10, 2026: approved for the editor's approval, with two recommendations on the reviewer flags, adopted by the editor as C08 and C09. GPT-6's package review (accept for independent review; two observations recorded as reviewer flags) is a consistency review, not an independent audit
- Editorial approval: Approved — W.H.L. (editor), November 10, 2026 (disposition C with the item-level remedies as written; no third check on MOE-1; C07 approved as a ruling of its own; structure ruled as the AES eight-section order; C08 and C09 adopted as proposed; corrected text v0.5 approved). The second corrected original registered under the AES v0.9 pilot; this record's audit disposition is the editor's acceptance of the corrected text
- Publication status: Not published — collection publication pending; the historical publication is not replaced, and its archive copy is unchanged
- Contributor: Qwen3-Max (initial draft); ChatGPT and Claude Sonnet 4.5 (revised drafts and final version) · Original reviewers: Gemini 2.5 Pro; Grok (Expert); DeepSeek-V3.2 (releases as stated in the post) · Corrections prepared by: Muse Spark 1.3 · Reviewer of the corrected text: GLM 5.3 Flash (second check and independent review)
- Correction IDs (recorded under this record — the register has no separate field for them): AIK-2025-F-P-MOE/C01 FE — §5 (the original's §6.5) Mixtral row corrected to the paper's figures (MMLU 70.6%; GSM8K 74.4%, 8-shot maj@8); reference [7] extended with Jiang et al., arXiv:2401.04088 · /C02 UC — Switch Transformer row's MMLU/GSM8K figures removed; the Switch paper reports neither benchmark · /C03 FE — Qwen3 row corrected to the Technical Report's Table 3 base-model figures (MMLU 87.81%; GSM8K 94.39%) with their evaluation conditions · /C04 FE/CD — the ST-MoE / Expert Choice Routing conflation undone (§2, §4, §8); Zoph et al. added as reference [10] · /C05 CD (minor) — Qwen3 release and report dates corrected (model released late April 2025; report arXiv:2505.09388, May 14, 2025) · /C06 PR — the published formulas, restored from the formula images' alt texts in the stored post (§1 display equation and symbols, infobox, §3) [re-based November 17, 2026; see re-adjudication note below] · /C07 PV — the published "Editorial Status" block is not carried into the canonical text (the editor's own ruling); status is recorded as separate facts in the metadata · /C08 FE — the generalized "≤ 10% of parameters active per token" claim (§3, §6) replaced by the range the entry's own §4 figures support (under 1% to ~28%) · /C09 CD (minor) — §4's estimated per-token figures (†, ‡) removed; the notes state the papers do not give them · /ST01 ST — the entry restructured into the AES eight-section order; the original's §6.5 benchmarks stand in §5
- Conflicts: GLM 5.3 Flash declared a subject interest on MOE-1 (Mixtral is its serving vendor Mistral AI's model) and recommended a second-vendor confirmation; the editor ruled no third check is needed — the finding rests on two independent primary checks (Muse's first audit and GLM's concurrence, the latter running against the figure flattering to the vendor). The corrections' preparer, Muse Spark 1.3, is not a contributor to or an original reviewer of this text. Claude Opus 5.5, a co-author of the original's final version (as Claude Sonnet 4.5), is recused from this text and reviewed procedure only. GPT-6 was not used as an independent reviewer of the corrected text
- Source: s-moe-corrected-canonical-v0.5.1.md (~/workspace/goals/aikipedia-2025-original-publication-audit/files/production/). Historical archive: s-moe-archive-text.md (same directory)
- Re-adjudication note (November 17, 2026): finding MOE-7 ruled NOT UPHELD. Kimi (Moonshot AI; release not stated) adjudicated on the editor's brief of November 17, 2026: the mathematics is present in the published post as eleven formula images with LaTeX alt texts at exactly the disputed positions in the post's stored content; the gaps in the PDF archive text are losses from a text-only capture of November 10, 2026, not unrendered notation. GLM 5.3 Flash's findings PDFA-13998-1 and PDFA-13998-2 (Check A, November 18, 2026) sustained. The editor confirmed by his own visual check of the live post (22:15–22:27 CT) and ruled "Accept both" and "The published formulas" (22:29 CT; recorded by Claude Opus 5.5, recused, recording only). C06 re-based as above, superseding "the mathematics unrendered in the published post reconstructed"; class PR unchanged; correction count unchanged. The audit history above stands as recorded. The canonical text's equation and symbols are to carry the published formulas at assembly; Editorial Note 5 is to be rewritten; the PDF archive header's transcription-basis statement is to be rewritten; the "missing in the original" markings are to be removed.
AIK-2025-F-P-CONSTAI — Constitutional AI
- Internal Concept ID: AIKC-000009
- Type / Origin: Full-length entry / Originally published in 2025 (standalone publication; under ruling X12 this one record serves as both parent and occurrence). The concept also occurs in New AI Lexicon 2025 (7) — occurrence record AIK-2025-S-P-CONSTAI, registered November 12, 2026
- Parent Record: — (standalone publication)
- Date of Appearance: December 15, 2022 (Bai et al., arXiv:2212.08073)
- Date of Original Publication: October 31, 2025 (Champaign Magazine, WordPress post 13958)
- Date of Collection Publication: November 18, 2026
- Version: Corrected text v0.5.1 (November 10, 2026). Metadata-only revision of the approved v0.5: records the registration; no change to the corrections text. Corrections C01–C06, editorial addition E01, and structural correction ST01 Metadata-only revision v0.5.2 (November 14, 2026) is current: Base version line, AES v1.0 label, See Also markings, editor named W.H.L.
- Base version: Final published version of the entry, the third full text in the post (basis: the post's own declaration; stated in the corrected text's production note as the text of record).
- Status: Accepted
- Peer-review status: Accepted — first audit by Muse Spark 1.3, November 9, 2026 (findings CAI-1 to CAI-7, with addendum; CAI-6 upgraded to a verified minor CD on November 10, 2026 against Bai et al.'s Appendix C). Second check and re-check by DeepSeek-V4.1, November 10, 2026: the two audits agree on every finding and proposed disposition. Reference verification by DeepSeek-V4.1, November 10, 2026 ([8], [9], E01's figures, and the [7] placement all confirmed). Independent review of the corrected package (v0.4) by DeepSeek-V4.1, November 10, 2026: confirmed on fidelity and on C01, C03–C06, and E01; its C02 scope check resolved against the §4 wording on two points (see C02 below), and its recommended narrowings were adopted by the editor. GPT-6's package review (accept for independent review) is a consistency review, not an independent audit
- Editorial approval: Approved — W.H.L. (editor), November 10, 2026 (disposition C; E01 adopted; the unattributed forecasts removed, the attribution alternative considered and not taken; structure ruled as the AES eight-section order; both C02 narrowings adopted as proposed; corrected text v0.5 approved). The third corrected original registered under the AES v0.9 pilot; this record's audit disposition is the editor's acceptance of the corrected text
- Publication status: Not published — collection publication pending; the historical publication is not replaced, and its archive copy is unchanged
- Contributor: Claude Sonnet 4.5 (author) · Original reviewers: ChatGPT; Grok (releases not stated in the post) · Corrections prepared by: Muse Spark 1.3 · Reviewer of the corrected text: DeepSeek-V4.1 (second check, reference verification, and independent review)
- Correction IDs (recorded under this record — the register has no separate field for them): AIK-2025-F-P-CONSTAI/C01 CD — reference [3] year corrected, 2023 → 2024 ("Claude's Character," June 8, 2024) · /C02 CD — the Omdia reference removed and both hybrid-alignment claims re-sourced to the Claude 4 System Card [7]; on the independent reviewer's scope check and the editor's rulings, the §4 Applications sentence is narrowed to Claude 4 (the Claude Sonnet 4.5 System Card documents RLHF and RL from AI feedback and never mentions Constitutional AI — verified by DeepSeek-V4.1 and independently by Muse Spark 1.3 on the official PDF) and the "most capable models" sentence is attributed to Anthropic · /C03 UC — the unattributed forecasts (day-long autonomous work by mid-2026; Nobel-level contributions by 2027) removed · /C04 CD — the Llama 3-8B claim cited to Zhang, arXiv:2504.04918, added as reference [8] · /C05 CD — the MongoDB claim cited, added as reference [9] · /C06 CD (minor) — both principles printed inside quotation marks replaced with Bai et al.'s verbatim RL principles (Appendix C) · /ST01 ST — the entry restructured into the AES eight-section order (§5, Evidence and Evaluation: not in original). E01 is an editorial addition, not a correction, and takes no correction ID: the balance qualifier appended to the Llama 3-8B passage ("though in that study the gain came with a 9.8% drop in helpfulness and signs of model collapse in the final model"), adopted by the editor
- Conflicts: the corrections' preparer, Muse Spark 1.3, is not a contributor to or an original reviewer of this text. Claude Opus 5.5 is recused (the original's author is a Claude model) and reviewed procedure only. Muse's first audit contained an error in finding CAI-3's evidence (the Schrittwieser affiliation), corrected on the record in correction register v0.2 on Claude's catch; the audit itself is unaltered. GPT-6 was not used as an independent reviewer of the corrected text
- Source: s-cai-corrected-canonical-v0.5.1.md (~/workspace/goals/aikipedia-2025-original-publication-audit/files/production/). Historical archive: s-cai-archive-text.md (same directory)
AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N3 — New AI Lexicon 2025 (3) (parent record; the twelve contained records follow)
- Internal Concept ID: — (container record; the contained records carry the concept IDs)
- Type / Origin: Lexicon installment / Originally published in 2025
- Parent Record: — (this record is the parent)
- Date of Appearance: — (container)
- Date of Original Publication: December 2, 2025 (Champaign Magazine, WordPress post 14221; byline "By Claude, ChatGPT with W.H.L.")
- Date of Collection Publication: November 18, 2026
- Version: Canonical records v0.3.1 (November 10, 2026). Metadata-only revision of v0.3: records the registration; no change to the records or the corrections text (v0.3 itself carried record-note updates only over v0.2, closing the "140+ papers" lead as verified) Metadata-only revision v0.3.2 (November 14, 2026) is current: editor named W.H.L.
- Base version: As-published installment text (post 14221; basis: sole published version). Stated once for the installment; all twelve occurrences are corrected from the same published text — no occurrence differs.
- Status: Accepted (parent disposition A — retain and annotate — with item-level C, per the editor's ruling)
- Peer-review status: Accepted — first audit by Muse Spark 1.3, November 9, 2026 (findings L3-1 to L3-8, with the BAIR addendum). Second check and re-check by DeepSeek-V4.1, November 10, 2026: the two audits agree on every finding and proposed disposition, with DeepSeek's new finding L3-9 (the TransformerLens version-3 clause) confirmed by Muse and applied as correction C05. Independent review of the corrected records (v0.2) by DeepSeek-V4.1, November 10, 2026: confirmed — fidelity holds; corrections C01–C06 verified at the primaries; the "140+ papers" lead closed as verified against the workshop's own site (corroborated by Muse Spark 1.3); /C07 independently reviewed by Grok 4.5 (xAI), November 18, 2026: adopt as written, the three figures confirmed directly against OpenAI's report
- Editorial approval: Approved — W.H.L. (editor), November 10, 2026 (disposition A with item-level C, including L3-9; L3-2 as A with a provenance note; canonical records v0.3 approved); /C07 approved November 18, 2026, 15:42 CT, as written (reviewed by Grok 4.5, 15:41 CT)
- Publication status: Not published — collection publication pending; the historical installment stands as published and is unchanged in the archive
- Contributor: Claude Sonnet 4.5 (author of the entries, per the mapping; the post's byline reads "Claude, ChatGPT with W.H.L.") · Embedded reviews in the original: ChatGPT (two reviews — not applied; Review Applied? = Not applied) · Corrections prepared by: Muse Spark 1.3 · Reviewer of the corrected records: DeepSeek-V4.1 (second check and independent review)
- Item-level correction IDs (each attaches to its occurrence record): AIK-2025-S-P-SPECDECODE/C01 FA — Speculative Decoding's appearance corrected to November 30, 2022 · AIK-2025-S-P-COVE/C02 FA — Chain-of-Verification's appearance corrected to 2023, and the headword's abbreviation corrected to the paper's "CoVe" · AIK-2025-S-P-MADEBATE/C03 FA — Multi-Agent Debate's appearance corrected to May 2023 · AIK-2025-E-P-COMPOUNDAI/C04 FA/CD (minor) — Compound AI's appearance corrected to February 18, 2024, with point-of-use attribution to BAIR (Zaharia et al.) at the definition, the worked example, and the Databricks statistics · AIK-2025-E-P-MECHINTERP/C05 FE — the TransformerLens "version 3 released in September 2025" clause removed (3.0 alpha pre-releases were public in 2025; no stable v3 existed at publication; stable v3.0.0 is April 17, 2026) · AIK-2025-E-P-TTCSCALE/C06 PR — the Test-Time Compute entry's Mathematical Framework equations restored from the published formulas (the formula images' alt texts in the stored post) [re-based November 17, 2026; see re-adjudication note below] · AIK-2025-E-P-TTCSCALE/C07 UC — the 'Applications' AIME 2024 figure qualified with the selection procedure that produced it (OpenAI, September 12, 2024: 93% after reranking 1,000 samples with a learned scoring function; 74% for a single sample, 83% for consensus among 64 samples); the top-500 comparison retained against the 93% score [approved November 18, 2026, 15:42 CT; reviewed by Grok 4.5, 15:41 CT]
- Contained records (all Status: Accepted; Version: Records v0.3.1; Original Publication December 2, 2025; Collection Publication November 18, 2026; contributor Claude Sonnet 4.5):
- AIK-2025-E-P-COMPOUNDAI — Compound AI Systems · Concept AIKC-000010 · 2 published text states (short form; full entry) · corrected at C04 · by the editor's grouping decision (November 10, 2026) the L1-S6 occurrence "Composable Models & Model Chaining" is merged into this concept; that occurrence record, AIK-2025-S-P-COMPOSABLE, was registered November 12, 2026
- AIK-2025-E-P-TTCSCALE — Test-Time Compute Scaling · Concept AIKC-000011 · 2 text states · corrected at C06 and C07
- AIK-2025-S-P-MMNATIVE — Multimodal Native Architecture · Concept AIKC-000012 · 1 text state · descriptive coinage; concept identity established (X6 ruling, November 13, 2026, 22:43 CT, following Muse's recommendation: the headword denotes exactly one attested concept, the field's "native multimodal", and the framing is sound; the headword inverts the field's phrasing — the gap is word order only, recorded per the ruling)
- AIK-2025-S-P-PIDEFENSE — Prompt Injection Defense Layers · Concept AIKC-000013 · 1 text state · concept identity established (X6 ruling, November 13, 2026, 22:43 CT, following Muse's recommendation)
- AIK-2025-S-P-SYNDATAFILT — Synthetic Data Quality Filtering · Concept AIKC-000014 · 1 text state · kept as a concept distinct from Lexicon (7)'s "Synthetic Data" under the mapping's concept rules
- AIK-2025-S-P-MADEBATE — Multi-Agent Debate Systems · Concept AIKC-000015 · 1 text state · corrected at C03
- AIK-2025-S-P-SPECDECODE — Speculative Decoding · Concept AIKC-000016 · 1 text state · corrected at C01
- AIK-2025-S-P-CTRLGEN — Controllable Generation Frameworks · Concept AIKC-000017 · 1 text state · concept identity established (X6 ruling, November 13, 2026, 22:43 CT, following Muse's recommendation)
- AIK-2025-E-P-MECHINTERP — Mechanistic Interpretability Tools · Concept AIKC-000018 · 2 text states · corrected at C05 · the entry's "140+ papers submitted to the ICML 2024 mechanistic interpretability workshop" is verified against the workshop's own site
- AIK-2025-S-P-CAI2 — Constitutional AI 2.0 · Concept AIKC-000019, provisional · 1 text state · disposition A with a provenance note (finding L3-2): the headword is unattested; in the collection the record's text is presented visibly as historical text under its provenance note, not as an endorsed definition. This is not the CONSTAI concept (AIKC-000009) and is not merged with Anthropic's "Constitutional AI 2" usage
- AIK-2025-S-P-ARITHHEADS — Arithmetic and Reasoning Heads · Concept AIKC-000020 · 1 text state · framing annotation (finding L3-8: emergent vs architectural heads) · concept identity provisional (X6 ruling, November 13, 2026, 22:43 CT, following Muse's recommendation: the "reasoning heads" conjunction is unattested; the L3-8 annotation stays)
- AIK-2025-S-P-COVE — Chain-of-Verification (CoVe) · Concept AIKC-000021 · 1 text state · corrected at C02 (the published headword spelled the abbreviation "CoV"; the record's headword follows the paper)
- Conflicts: the corrections' preparer, Muse Spark 1.3, is not a contributor to this installment. Claude Opus 5.5 is recused (the installment's author is a Claude model) and reviewed procedure only. GPT-6 was not used as an independent reviewer of the corrected records
- Source: l3-canonical-records-v0.3.1.md (~/workspace/goals/aikipedia-2025-original-publication-audit/files/production/). Historical archive: l3-archive-text.md (same directory)
- Re-adjudication note (November 17, 2026): finding L3-6 ruled NOT UPHELD. Kimi (Moonshot AI; release not stated) adjudicated on the editor's brief of November 17, 2026: the three Mathematical Framework equations are present in the published post as formula images with LaTeX alt texts (
y = \pi(x);y = \arg\max_{y \in \mathcal{Y}(x, C)} R(y); inline\mathcal{Y}(x, C), with no space before "is" as stored) at exactly the disputed positions in the post's stored content; the gaps in the PDF archive text are losses from a text-only capture, not a production defect. GLM 5.3 Flash's finding PDFA-14221-2 (Check A, November 18, 2026) sustained. The editor confirmed by his own visual check of the live post (22:15–22:27 CT) and ruled "Accept both" and "The published formulas" (22:29 CT; recorded by Claude Opus 5.5, recused, recording only). C06 re-based as above, superseding "reconstructed (the published formulae did not render)"; the L3-S2 record note's "production fix" characterization is to be re-characterized as a restoration; class PR unchanged; correction count unchanged. The audit history above stands as recorded. The canonical text's equations are to carry the published formulas at assembly; the PDF archive header's transcription-basis statement is to be rewritten. The stored quirk "𝒴(x, C)is" follows the collection's conventions for corrected texts; the archive keeps it as stored.
AIK-2025-F-P-CALM — Continuous Autoregressive Language Models (CALM)
- Internal Concept ID: AIKC-000022
- Type / Origin: Full-length entry / Originally published in 2025 (standalone publication; under ruling X12 this one record serves as both parent and occurrence)
- Parent Record: — (standalone publication)
- Date of Appearance: October 31, 2025 (as recorded in the batch 1–2 registration handoff, November 11, 2026; the corrected text and its correction register are held in Claude's project and were not inspected by Muse — see the scope note below)
- Date of Original Publication: November 6, 2025 (Champaign Magazine, WordPress post 14021)
- Date of Collection Publication: November 18, 2026
- Version: Corrected text v0.2 (November 11, 2026), accepted by the editor. The metadata-only revision v0.2.1 stating this registration was issued November 13, 2026 (copy on file in the metadata-revisions filing, verified against this register); the project correction registers were filed with Muse November 14, 2026 (bundle; item 19 closed). Corrections C01–C06, editorial addition E01, and structural correction ST01 Metadata-only revision v0.2.2 (November 14, 2026) is current: Base version line, AES v1.0 label, See Also markings, editor named W.H.L.
- Base version: Final version by GPT-5 Mini, the post's single published entry text (basis: sole published version; the initial draft by DeepSeek-V3.2 is named in the post's metadata, not published as an entry text).
- Status: Accepted
- Peer-review status: Accepted — first audit by Claude Opus 5.5, November 6, 2026 (findings CALM-1 to CALM-8). Second audit by Muse Spark 1.3, November 10, 2026 (worksheets v0.14, v0.16: CALM-1–CALM-5, CALM-7, CALM-8 confirmed; CALM-6 not confirmed and withdrawn by the first auditor). Independent review of the corrected text by GLM 5.3 Flash, November 11, 2026 (per the batch 1–2 handoff; the review is held in the project and was not inspected by Muse). Muse Spark 1.3 did not review the corrected text: the single-pass review contemplated by the November 11 production ruling did not take place, GLM having reviewed instead
- Editorial approval: Approved — W.H.L. (editor), November 11, 2026 (batch 1–2 rulings: "approve all six"; CALM O3 closed on two sources — the preparer's reading of Table 1 and the official repository's figures). The fourth corrected original registered under the AES v0.9 pilot; this record's audit disposition is the editor's acceptance of the corrected text
- Publication status: Not published — collection publication pending; the historical publication is not replaced
- Contributor: DeepSeek-V3.2 (initial draft); GPT-5 Mini (final version), per the mapping; reviews unpublished in the post · Claude Sonnet 4.5 named as an original reviewer, with no Claude text in the post (per the handoff) · Corrections prepared by: Claude Opus 5.5 · Reviewer of the corrected text: GLM 5.3 Flash
- Correction IDs (recorded under this record — the register has no separate field for them; descriptions from correction registers v0.1 and v0.2, filed with Muse November 14, 2026): AIK-2025-F-P-CALM/C01 CD — Leviathan et al. reference corrected (full authors; true title "Fast Inference from Transformers via Speculative Decoding"; ICML 2023, PMLR 202) · /C02 CD (minor) — Bowman venue corrected from "SIGNLL" to CoNLL 2016 (SIGNLL is the sponsoring SIG, not the venue) · /C03 CF — "Tsinghua AI Lab Notes Vol. 7" removed as unidentifiable (the metadata block is not carried) · /C04 UC — "Early replication studies" sentence removed (unsourced, six days after the preprint) · /C05 UC — model-scale and performance tables rebuilt from the paper's Table 1 and §7.1 (separate Transformer/CALM parameter columns; invented CALM-S row removed; the 44%/34% comparison attributed) · /C06 UC (new) — GPU-speedup and robustness sentence removed (unsourced) · /ST01 ST — restructured into the AES eight sections. E01 is an editorial addition, not a correction, and takes no correction ID; it distinguishes this CALM (Continuous Autoregressive Language Models) from the earlier, different method "Confident Adaptive Language Modeling" (Schuster et al., 2022), adopted by the editor November 11, 2026
- Conflicts: the corrections' preparer is an Anthropic model; Claude Sonnet 4.5 is named as an original reviewer, with no Claude text in the post (per the handoff). GPT-6 was not used as an independent reviewer of the corrected text
- Scope note: this registration rests on the editor's batch 1–2 rulings as recorded in the handoff file (
aikipedia-2025-batch1-2-editor-rulings-and-registration-handoff_2026-11-11.md, recorded by Claude Opus 5.5). Muse verified the CALM key against the mapping and the live register (no collision — see the §4 log) but did not inspect the corrected text, its correction register, or the independent review, none of which is in Muse's workspace. Update (November 14, 2026): the corrected text, correction registers v0.1/v0.2, archive (post 14021), and the GLM 5.3 Flash review are now filed with Muse (bundle,bundle_for_Muse_2026-11-13.zip, checksums verified 34/34); Muse read the correction registers in full for the descriptions above. The corrected text, archive, and review are filed and checksum-verified but were not re-verified line by line; the registration continues to rest on the editor's rulings and the independent review - Source: CALM_corrected-canonical_v0.2.1.md (copy on file in the metadata-revisions filing, November 13, 2026; project original CALM_corrected-canonical_v0.2.md at entries/calm/). Correction registers v0.1/v0.2, archive text (post 14021), and the GLM 5.3 Flash review filed with Muse November 14, 2026 (bundle)
AIK-2025-F-P-PDDISAGG — Prefill–Decode Disaggregation
- Internal Concept ID: AIKC-000023
- Type / Origin: Full-length entry / Originally published in 2025 (standalone publication; under ruling X12 this one record serves as both parent and occurrence)
- Parent Record: — (standalone publication)
- Date of Appearance: January 18, 2024 (DistServe), with Splitwise, November 30, 2023, noted (as recorded in the batch 1–2 registration handoff, November 11, 2026; the corrected text and its correction register are held in Claude's project and were not inspected by Muse — see the scope note below)
- Date of Original Publication: November 9, 2025 (Champaign Magazine, WordPress post 14033)
- Date of Collection Publication: November 18, 2026
- Version: Corrected text v0.2 (November 11, 2026), accepted by the editor, with C10 withdrawn. The metadata-only revision v0.2.1 stating this registration was issued November 13, 2026 (copy on file in the metadata-revisions filing, verified against this register); the project correction registers were filed with Muse November 14, 2026 (bundle; item 19 closed). Corrections C01–C09 and structural correction ST01; C10 withdrawn (number retired, not reused) Metadata-only revision v0.2.2 (November 14, 2026) is current: Base version line, AES v1.0 label, See Also markings, editor named W.H.L.
- Base version: Final version by ChatGPT, the post's single published entry text (basis: sole published version; the initial draft by Kimi K2 Thinking is linked from the post, not reproduced in it).
- Status: Accepted
- Peer-review status: Accepted — first audit by Claude Opus 5.5, November 6, 2026 (findings PDD-1 to PDD-6). Second audit by Muse Spark 1.3, November 10, 2026 (worksheets v0.14, v0.16: PDD-1, PDD-3 confirmed; PDD-2 confirmed; PDD-4, PDD-5 confirmed in part; PDD-6 confirmed in part). Independent review of the corrected text by GLM 5.3 Flash, November 11, 2026 (per the batch 1–2 handoff; the review is held in the project and was not inspected by Muse)
- Editorial approval: Approved — W.H.L. (editor), November 11, 2026 (batch 1–2 rulings: "approve all six"; the earlier approval of C10, batch 1 item 3, rescinded, and v0.2 accepted with C10 withdrawn — the withdrawn C10 was the preparer's error, recorded in correction register v0.2). The fifth corrected original registered under the AES v0.9 pilot; this record's audit disposition is the editor's acceptance of the corrected text
- Publication status: Not published — collection publication pending; the historical publication is not replaced
- Contributor: Kimi K2 Thinking (initial version, off-post); ChatGPT (final version), per the mapping; reviews unpublished in the post · Claude Sonnet 4.5 named as a reviewer, with no Claude text in the post (per the handoff, as for CALM) · Corrections prepared by: Claude Opus 5.5 · Reviewer of the corrected text: GLM 5.3 Flash
- Correction IDs (recorded under this record — the register has no separate field for them; descriptions from correction registers v0.1 and v0.2, filed with Muse November 14, 2026): AIK-2025-F-P-PDDISAGG/C01 FA — "first formalized in DistServe" corrected: first proposed in Splitwise (2023), formalized as goodput-optimized disaggregated serving in DistServe (2024); timeline row and reference added · /C02 UC — utilization figures cited to InfoQ (prefill 90–95%, decode 20–40%); the LLaMA-70B/A800 qualifier dropped as unsourced · /C03 UC — FlowKV: the 96% figure scoped to KV-cache transmission latency (0.944 s → 0.053 s); the compression claim removed (the mechanism is pipelined transfer and contiguous allocation) · /C04 FE — "Inference Throughput Latency" corrected to Inter-Token Latency · /C05 UC — savings sourced: Splitwise's 1.4× throughput at 20% lower cost (primary); the 15–40% range kept, attributed to secondary analyses · /C06 FE — timeline rows put in date order (March Dynamo before April FlowKV) · /C07 CD (new) — Mooncake reference title completed (main clause restored; FAST '25) · /C08 PR/PV — figure credit recorded (attachment and Copilot file name); the kimi.com link not carried (Editorial Note 3) · /C09 UC (new) — Mooncake description corrected (disaggregated KVCache-centric store with a global scheduler, not co-location with decode clusters) · /ST01 ST — restructured into the AES eight sections (five sentences/bullets moved and marked). C10 is withdrawn; the number is retired and is not reused (the preparer's version-attribution error: the v1 and OSDI figures inverted; the original A-024 wording restored in v0.2; the earlier approval rescinded)
- Conflicts: the corrections' preparer is an Anthropic model; Claude Sonnet 4.5 is named as a reviewer, with no Claude text in the post (per the handoff). GPT-6 was not used as an independent reviewer of the corrected text
- Scope note: this registration rests on the editor's batch 1–2 rulings as recorded in the handoff file. Muse did not inspect the corrected text, its correction register, or the independent review, none of which is in Muse's workspace. The key is PDDISAGG per mapping v0.2 (not PDD). Update (November 14, 2026): the corrected text, correction registers v0.1/v0.2, archive (post 14033), and the GLM 5.3 Flash review are now filed with Muse (bundle, checksums verified 34/34); Muse read the correction registers in full for the descriptions above. The corrected text, archive, and review are filed and checksum-verified but were not re-verified line by line; the registration continues to rest on the editor's rulings and the independent review
- Source: PDD_corrected-canonical_v0.2.1.md (copy on file in the metadata-revisions filing, November 13, 2026; project original PDD_corrected-canonical_v0.2.md at entries/prefill-decode-disaggregation/). Correction registers v0.1/v0.2, archive text (post 14033), and the GLM 5.3 Flash review filed with Muse November 14, 2026 (bundle)
AIK-2025-F-P-GENUI — Generative User Interfaces (GenUI)
- Internal Concept ID: AIKC-000024
- Type / Origin: Full-length entry / Originally published in 2025 (standalone publication; under ruling X12 this one record serves as both parent and occurrence)
- Parent Record: — (standalone publication)
- Date of Appearance: October 11, 2023 (Vercel, "Announcing v0: Generative UI"); Vercel had described v0 as a "generative user interface system" at its launch in September 2023. Earliest documented use identified by the review; not an exhaustive priority claim
- Date of Original Publication: November 29, 2025 (Champaign Magazine, WordPress post 14146)
- Date of Collection Publication: November 18, 2026
- Version: Corrected text v0.2.1 (November 11, 2026). Metadata-only revision of the approved v0.2: records the registration; no change to the corrections text (verified by Muse Spark 1.3 by diff: five metadata sites only). Corrections C01–C09 and structural correction ST01 Metadata-only revision v0.2.2 (November 14, 2026) is current: Base version line, AES v1.0 label, See Also markings, editor named W.H.L. Metadata-only revision v0.2.3 (November 14, 2026) is current: header version label corrected (it read 'v0.2.1'); no change to the text.
- Base version: The Gemini 3 Pro entry text (basis: sole published version; Gemini 3 Pro is the post's sole contributor).
- Status: Accepted
- Peer-review status: Accepted — first audit by Claude Opus 5.5, November 6, 2026 (findings GEN-1 to GEN-6). Second audit by Muse Spark 1.3 (worksheets v0.3, v0.14, v0.16: GEN-1–GEN-3 confirmed; GEN-4 both halves confirmed; GEN-5 confirmed; GEN-6 confirmed on the live page). Independent review of the corrected text (v0.1) by GPT-6, November 11, 2026: passes with corrections — C01–C07 and ST01 confirmed at the primaries; one new verified citation defect applied as C08, and a bibliographic detail as C09. The pre-registration focused confirmation the reviewer asked for was accepted by the editor as satisfied by the reviewer's own wording of C08 and C09
- Editorial approval: Approved — W.H.L. (editor), November 10, 2026 (disposition C) and November 11, 2026 (batch 1–2 rulings: reference [8] as Alabduljabbar confirmed; Date of Appearance confirmed; C08 and C09 approved; pre-registration check accepted). The sixth corrected original registered under the AES v0.9 pilot; this record's audit disposition is the editor's acceptance of the corrected text
- Publication status: Not published — collection publication pending; the historical publication is not replaced, and its archive copy is unchanged
- Contributor: Gemini 3 Pro (sole contributor, writing about a feature of Gemini 3) · Original reviewers: none named in the post · Corrections prepared by: Claude Opus 5.5 · Reviewer of the corrected text: GPT-6
- Correction IDs (recorded under this record — the register has no separate field for them; descriptions from correction registers v0.1 and v0.2 and the independent review (register v0.1, incorporated by reference in v0.2, filed with Muse November 14, 2026; descriptions verified against it)): AIK-2025-F-P-GENUI/C01 FA — origin chronology corrected (Vercel September 2023 launch; "Generative UI" named October 11, 2023; AI SDK 3.0, March 1, 2024; Chen et al., August 2025; Google's November 18, 2025 implementation) · /C02 CF — the Google Research post's title, date, and content corrected (the Static/Declarative/Open-Ended taxonomy is not in the post) · /C03 CD — the Google post's four authors completed, including Vishnu Natchu · /C04 UC/CD — the Chen et al. annotation corrected and reference [8] identified as Alabduljabbar (PeerJ, October 25, 2024; 11,549 app-store reviews), not Weisz et al. (CHI 2024, a different paper) · /C05 UC — the unsupported claims removed or qualified ("third-generation Foundation Agents"; declarative generation as the most common production approach) · /C06 CD — in-text citation markers added following the post's own annotations of what each reference supports (the annotations are the contributor's claims, not independent verification — Editorial Note 4) · /C07 ED — the unmerged suggested revised lead and reference [1] excluded from the canonical text (the lead carries the C01 error; its reference omits an author) · /C08 CD — the CopilotKit reference corrected to Berman, Eli (September 12, 2025), exact title and URL (the reviewer's new finding) · /C09 CD (minor) — the Smith subtitle added ("+ how to fix it") · /ST01 ST — the entry restructured into the AES eight-section order (§4 from the post's preliminary answer; §5 and §8 marked "Not in original")
- Conflicts: none for the preparer (no Anthropic model contributed to the post). The reviewer, GPT-6, disclosed its broader role in the Aikipedia project and its authorship of the editorial standards, and found no OpenAI participation in the original post or in the correction preparation. Vendor-affiliation annotation (GEN-6): the entry was written by Gemini 3 Pro about a feature of Google's Gemini 3, with no reviewer; §4 repeats the contributor's own description and is not independently verified
- Source: GENUI_corrected-canonical_v0.2.1.md (copy on file at ~/workspace/user/files/GENUI_corrected-canonical_v0.2.1.md; project original at entries/generative-ui/GENUI_corrected-canonical_v0.2.md). Historical archive: GENUI_archive-text_post14146.md (filed with Muse November 14, 2026, as
GENUI_archive-text_post14146__2.md; 77 numbered lines, A-001–A-077; embedded fingerprint verified by Muse). Correction register v0.2 and independent review v0.1 on file at ~/workspace/user/files/; correction register v0.1 filed with Muse November 14, 2026 (bundle)
AIK-2025-F-P-ONPOLDISTIL — On-Policy Distillation
- Internal Concept ID: AIKC-000025
- Type / Origin: Full-length entry / Originally published in 2025 (standalone publication; under ruling X12 this one record serves as both parent and occurrence)
- Parent Record: — (standalone publication)
- Date of Appearance: January 17, 2024, as ruled November 11, 2026 (as recorded in the batch 3 registration handoff, November 12, 2026; the corrected text and its correction registers are held in Claude's project and were not inspected by Muse — see the scope note below). The earlier name, GKD, and its date (June 23, 2023) are noted
- Date of Original Publication: October 29, 2025 (Champaign Magazine, WordPress post 13892)
- Date of Collection Publication: November 18, 2026
- Version: Corrected text v0.3 (November 12, 2026), accepted by the editor. The metadata-only revision v0.3.1 stating this registration was issued November 13, 2026 (copy on file in the metadata-revisions filing, verified against this register); the project correction registers were filed with Muse November 14, 2026 (bundle; item 19 closed). Corrections C01–C07 and structural correction ST01 Metadata-only revision v0.3.2 (November 14, 2026) is current: header status (no longer 'awaits the editor's approval'), Review Status label, Base version line, AES v1.0 label, editor named W.H.L.
- Base version: The single ChatGPT entry text (basis: sole published version).
- Status: Accepted
- Peer-review status: Accepted — first audit by Claude Opus 5.5, November 6, 2026 (findings OPD-1 to OPD-5). Second audit by Muse Spark 1.3, November 10, 2026 (worksheets v0.14, v0.16: OPD-1 and OPD-2 confirmed; OPD-3 confirmed; OPD-4 confirmed; OPD-5 clean — the 60% → 70% AIME'24 result matches the source table exactly). Independent review of the corrected text by DeepSeek-V4.1, November 11, 2026 (per the batch 3 handoff; the review is held in the project and was not inspected by Muse); its finding NF-1 was adopted by the editor as correction C07
- Editorial approval: Approved — W.H.L. (editor), November 12, 2026 (batch 3 rulings: "approve all six"; C07 approved; corrected text v0.3 final). The seventh corrected original registered under the AES v0.9 pilot; this record's audit disposition is the editor's acceptance of the corrected text
- Publication status: Not published — collection publication pending; the historical publication is not replaced
- Contributor: ChatGPT (GPT-5) entry; Grok fact-check; Claude Sonnet 4.5 comments, per the mapping · Corrections prepared by: Claude Opus 5.5 · Reviewer of the corrected text: DeepSeek-V4.1
- Correction IDs (recorded under this record — the register has no separate field for them; descriptions from correction registers v0.1 to v0.3, filed with Muse November 14, 2026; v0.2 renumbered the structural correction to ST01 and the reference/See Also corrections to C05/C06): AIK-2025-F-P-ONPOLDISTIL/C01 UC — "far fewer FLOPs than RLHF" corrected to "far less compute than RL or extended supervised fine-tuning" (the post compares with SFT and RL; "RLHF" does not appear in it) · /C02 FA — §2 Origin added: GKD (June 23, 2023) and MiniLLM (June 14, 2023) as antecedents; references [P1] and [P2] added · /C03 PR — unrendered LaTeX typeset (no mathematical change) · /C04 UC/FE (new) — the 8B/32B result corrected: benchmark (AIME'24), 150 steps, and the teacher qualification (Qwen3-8B used, compute counted as for the 32B model) stated; the RL comparison attributed to the Qwen3 replication; the full form stands (the October 27, 2025 Wayback snapshot contains the teacher sentence; O1 satisfied, v0.3) · /C05 CD (minor; v0.1 C06) — the Lu et al. reference dated (October 27, 2025) · /C06 ED (v0.1 C07) — See Also cross-references added (COTPROMPT, RLVR) · /C07 UC (new, from the review's finding NF-1) — "optionally using importance weighting or adaptive mixing with off-policy data" deleted (neither is described in [R1]) · /ST01 ST (v0.1 C05) — restructured into the AES eight sections
- Annotation (finding OPD-4, disposition A, noted in the record): the published Claude Sonnet 4.5 comment glosses reverse KL as the forward KL, then tabulates it correctly two lines later; the entry's formula is right and the comment wrong
- Conflicts: the corrections' preparer is an Anthropic model; Claude Sonnet 4.5 comments are published in the post (see the OPD-4 annotation). The entry itself is by ChatGPT (GPT-5). GPT-6 was not used as an independent reviewer of the corrected text
- Scope note: this registration rests on the editor's batch 3 rulings as recorded in the handoff file (
batch3_editor-rulings-and-registration-handoff_2026-11-12.md, recorded by Claude Opus 5.5). Muse verified the ONPOLDISTIL key against the mapping and the live register (no collision — see the §4 log) but did not inspect the corrected text, its correction registers, or the independent review, none of which is in Muse's workspace. The key is ONPOLDISTIL per mapping v0.2. Update (November 14, 2026): the corrected text, correction registers v0.1–v0.3, archive (post 13892), and the DeepSeek-V4.1 review are now filed with Muse (bundle, checksums verified 34/34); Muse read the correction registers in full for the descriptions above. The corrected text, archive, and review are filed and checksum-verified but were not re-verified line by line; the registration continues to rest on the editor's rulings and the independent review - Source: OPD_corrected-canonical_v0.3.1.md (copy on file in the metadata-revisions filing, November 13, 2026; project original OPD_corrected-canonical_v0.3.md at entries/on-policy-distillation/). Correction registers v0.1–v0.3, archive text (post 13892), and the DeepSeek-V4.1 review filed with Muse November 14, 2026 (bundle)
AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N2 — New AI Lexicon 2025 (2) (parent record; the twelve contained records follow)
- Internal Concept ID: — (container record; the contained records carry the concept IDs)
- Type / Origin: Lexicon installment / Originally published in 2025
- Parent Record: — (this record is the parent)
- Date of Appearance: — (container)
- Date of Original Publication: December 1, 2025 (Champaign Magazine, WordPress post 14191; byline "By Gemini 3 Pro with W.H.L.")
- Date of Collection Publication: November 18, 2026
- Version: Canonical records v0.2 (November 12, 2026), accepted by the editor. The metadata-only revision v0.2.1 stating this registration was issued November 13, 2026 (copy on file in the metadata-revisions filing, verified against this register); the project correction registers were filed with Muse November 14, 2026 (bundle; item 19 closed). Corrections C01–C12 Metadata-only revisions v0.2.2 and v0.2.3 (November 14, 2026) are current: E3 cross-year link verified (X7), E5 provisional (X2), L2-E7 header status corrected; v0.2.3 is the current version.
- Base version: As-published installment text (post 14191; basis: sole published version). Stated once for the installment; all twelve occurrences are corrected from the same published text — no occurrence differs.
- Status: Accepted (parent disposition item-level C/X in the joint register; canonical records v0.2 approved by the editor as final)
- Peer-review status: Accepted — first audit by Claude Opus 5.5, November 6, 2026 (findings L2-1 to L2-9). Second audit by Muse Spark 1.3, November 10, 2026 (worksheet v0.12: all nine findings settled; L2-6 corrected the first audit's "unsourced" to a confirmed conflation, and the first auditor accepted the correction). Independent review of the corrected records by GPT-6, November 12, 2026 (per the batch 3 handoff; the review is held in the project and was not inspected by Muse); its findings R1 to R3 were adopted by the editor as corrections C10 to C12. GPT-6 replaced GLM 5.3 Flash, which had reached its usage limits; GPT-6 is eligible because the installment's contributor is Gemini 3 Pro and no OpenAI model took part in it (per the handoff)
- Editorial approval: Approved — W.H.L. (editor), November 12, 2026 (batch 3 rulings: "approve all six"; C09 approved; C10, C11, and C12 approved; canonical records v0.2 final; the four Dates of Appearance ruled as documented milestones, not exhaustive first uses). The second installment registered under the AES v0.9 pilot; this record's audit disposition is the editor's acceptance of the corrected records
- Publication status: Not published — collection publication pending; the historical installment stands as published and is unchanged in the archive
- Contributor: Gemini 3 Pro · Corrections prepared by: Claude Opus 5.5 · Reviewer of the corrected records: GPT-6
- Correction IDs (recorded under this record — the register has no separate field for them; descriptions from correction registers v0.1 and v0.2, filed with Muse November 14, 2026; no ST01 — lexicon records follow the L1/L3 format): /C01 CD/FE — the MCP reference corrected: the fabricated "AI Standards Foundation" replaced with Anthropic's November 25, 2024 announcement; the specification's date versioning noted · /C02 CD — the Alignment Faking reference corrected to Greenblatt et al. (2024), arXiv:2412.14093 (Hubinger is the last of 20 authors) · /C03 CD/FE — the GAIA-2 reference corrected (Russell et al., Wayve, arXiv:2503.20523; "Generative AI for Autonomy" gloss noted) · /C04 CF — five unattested references removed, their items marked unsourced and kept (editor's ruling) · /C05 UC — Alignment Faking: the definition narrowed to Greenblatt et al.'s; the "major labs" claim replaced by the single dated demonstration; the RLHF/RLAIF sentence replaced by the paper's reported results; the "Inoculation Prompting" bullet removed · /C06 CD/UC — KV-cache sharing: the Apple report cited by title and identifier (arXiv:2507.13575 §2.1; within-model sharing, ~37.5% time-to-first-token reduction); the Qualcomm half removed · /C07 CD — LMGenDrive removed (no 2025 work found; the 2026 work postdates the installment); SafeKV's author corrected to Chu et al. · /C08 PR — LaTeX typeset once each; E12's fields ordered (the quotation keeps the published order) · /C09 FE (beyond the findings) — the reversed "when unmonitored" parenthetical removed (the model complied more when it believed it was in training) · /C10 UC (review finding R1) — the Alignment Faking generalization fixed in the reviewer's own wording, with a qualifier marking the Technical Description as a simplified model · /C11 UC (review finding R2) — the World Model "2025 breakthrough" integration claim replaced (generative world models advanced in 2025, GAIA-2 as the example; LLM integration not established) · /C12 UC (review finding R3) — the KV-cache memory-reduction formula omitted (no derivation; its terms do not yield a memory quantity); C08's typesetting of it lapses
- Dates: the four Dates of Appearance below are documented milestones, not exhaustive first uses, as ruled by the editor. The other eight occurrences' dates stay not established. For E7, "deceptive alignment" is noted from June 2019
- Contained records (all Status: Accepted; Version: Records v0.2.1; Original Publication December 1, 2025; Collection Publication November 18, 2026; contributor Gemini 3 Pro):
- AIK-2025-E-P-WORLDMODEL — World Model (LLM-Integrated) · Concept AIKC-000026 · 2 published text states (short text; full entry) · Date of Appearance March 2018 (documented milestone) · the Lexicon (7) occurrence (K8,
AIK-2025-S-P-WORLDMODEL, registered November 12, 2026) links to this concept; this record keeps the bare key as the earlier occurrence · the "LLM-Integrated" qualifier is recorded (mapping X3) - AIK-2025-E-P-KVSHARE — KV-Cache Sharing (On-Device Inference) · Concept AIKC-000027 · 2 text states · Date of Appearance not established · related to PDDISAGG and EDGEAI
- AIK-2025-S-P-NESTEDLEARN — Nested Learning (Continual AI) · Concept AIKC-000028 · 1 text state · Date of Appearance not established · the concept has a 2026 entry, 'Aikipedia: Nested Learning' (post 14472, January 3, 2026; verified by Muse on the live post, November 14, 2026 — the cross-year link is verified; the 2026 collection links its record to this concept ID under rule 9) · finding L2-9 disposition A: the 2025 original stays
- AIK-2025-S-P-MCP — Model Context Protocol (MCP) · Concept AIKC-000029 · 1 text state · Date of Appearance November 25, 2024 (documented milestone) · the Lexicon (7) occurrence (K7,
AIK-2025-E-P-MCP, registered November 12, 2026) links to this concept; this record keeps the bare key as the earlier occurrence - AIK-2025-S-P-ADVREASON — Advanced Reasoning Models (Cognitive Hybrid Architectures) · Concept AIKC-000030 · 1 text state · Date of Appearance not established · concept identity provisional (X2 ruling, November 14, 2026: distinctness unverified; Register §1 rule 10, AES v1.0 §10): it must not be merged with Large Reasoning Models and must not be treated as the same as neuro-symbolic architectures (GPT-6, finding R4); related to LRM. If the headword is later found unattested, the §10 presentation rule applies.
- AIK-2025-S-P-BIDIRALIGN — Bidirectional Human-AI Alignment · Concept AIKC-000031 · 1 text state · Date of Appearance June 13, 2024 (documented milestone) · related to ALIGNMENT
- AIK-2025-E-P-ALIGNFAKE — Alignment Faking (Deceptive Alignment) · Concept AIKC-000032 · 2 text states · Date of Appearance December 18, 2024 (documented milestone); "deceptive alignment" noted from June 2019 · the headword conflates two concepts (mapping X5); mapped to Alignment Faking, related to deceptive alignment and to SCHEMING (new addition)
- AIK-2025-S-P-GENFEEDBACK — Generative Feedback Loop (Self-Adaptation) · Concept AIKC-000033 · 1 text state · Date of Appearance not established
- AIK-2025-S-P-EMBODIEDAI — Embodied AI (as a Paradigm) · Concept AIKC-000034 · 1 text state · Date of Appearance not established · Embodied Foundation Models (Lexicon (5)) is a separate concept, linked as related; the subclass question is closed (X2 ruling, November 14, 2026)
- AIK-2025-S-P-SHAREDAUTO — Shared Autonomy (Robotics) · Concept AIKC-000035 · 1 text state · Date of Appearance not established
- AIK-2025-S-P-SOFTROBOT — Soft Robotics / Dexterous Manipulation · Concept AIKC-000036 · 1 text state · Date of Appearance not established · compound headword (mapping X4)
- AIK-2025-S-P-VERTICALAI — Vertical AI Integration · Concept AIKC-000037 · 1 text state · Date of Appearance not established
- AIK-2025-E-P-WORLDMODEL — World Model (LLM-Integrated) · Concept AIKC-000026 · 2 published text states (short text; full entry) · Date of Appearance March 2018 (documented milestone) · the Lexicon (7) occurrence (K8,
- Conflicts: the corrections' preparer is an Anthropic model; no Anthropic text is in the post (per the mapping). The reviewer, GPT-6, is eligible per the handoff (no OpenAI model took part in the installment)
- Scope note: this registration rests on the editor's batch 3 rulings as recorded in the handoff file. Muse verified the thirteen keys against the mapping and the live register (no collision — see the §4 log) but did not inspect the canonical records, their correction registers, or the independent review, none of which is in Muse's workspace. Keys per mapping v0.2. Update (November 14, 2026): the canonical records, correction registers v0.1/v0.2, archive (post 14191), and the GPT-6 review are now filed with Muse (bundle, checksums verified 34/34); Muse read the correction registers in full for the descriptions above. The records, archive, and review are filed and checksum-verified but were not re-verified line by line; the registration continues to rest on the editor's rulings and the independent review
- Source: L2_canonical-records_v0.2.1.md (copy on file in the metadata-revisions filing, November 13, 2026; project original L2_canonical-records_v0.2.md at entries/lexicon-2/). Correction registers v0.1/v0.2, archive text (post 14191), and the GPT-6 review filed with Muse November 14, 2026 (bundle)
AIK-2025-F-P-MOD — Mixture of Depths
- Internal Concept ID: AIKC-000038
- Type / Origin: Full-length entry / Originally published in 2025 (standalone publication; under ruling X12 this one record serves as both parent and occurrence)
- Parent Record: — (standalone publication)
- Date of Appearance: April 2, 2024 (Raposo et al., arXiv:2404.02258v1, as recorded in the registration filing, November 12, 2026; the corrected text and its correction registers are held in Claude's project and were not inspected by Muse — see the scope note below)
- Date of Original Publication: November 3, 2025 (Champaign Magazine, WordPress post 13982; the post publishes three versions; v3 is the text of record)
- Date of Collection Publication: November 18, 2026
- Version: Corrected text v0.3 (November 2026), accepted by the editor. The metadata-only revision v0.3.1 stating this registration was issued November 13, 2026 (copy on file in the metadata-revisions filing, verified against this register); the project correction registers were filed with Muse November 14, 2026 (bundle; item 19 closed). Corrections C01–C08, editorial addition E01, and structural correction ST01 Metadata-only revision v0.3.2 (November 14, 2026) is current: header status (no longer 'for the editor's approval'), Base version line, AES v1.0 label, editor named W.H.L.
- Base version: v3 by ChatGPT, the final version and text of record (basis: the post's own presentation — v3 is the final of the three published entry texts).
- Status: Accepted
- Peer-review status: Accepted — first audit by Claude Opus 5.5, November 6, 2026 (findings MOD-1 to MOD-4). Second audit by Muse Spark 1.3, November 10, 2026 (worksheet v0.16: MOD-1 and MOD-4 confirmed on arXiv:2404.02258; MOD-2 — no PMLR v235 proceedings record found for MoD — recorded as an annotation; MOD-3 confirmed — v2's Article Information credits Gemini-2.5 as peer reviewer and no Gemini review exists in the post). Independent review of the corrected text by GLM 5.3 Flash (run on Mistral Vibe), November 10, 2026 (per the registration filing; the review is held in the project and was not inspected by Muse): passed with one correction, adopted as C08
- Editorial approval: Approved — W.H.L. (editor), November 10, 2026 (disposition A for v1 with annotation, C on v3, adopted under decision-list item 1; corrections C02, C03, and C07 approved and editorial addition E01 adopted; C08 approved). The corrected text v0.3 was recorded as approved and awaiting registration in the batch 1–2 handoff (November 11, 2026); the registration filing of November 12, 2026, relayed by the editor, supplied the ruling detail, date, reviewer, and conflicts. The eighth corrected original registered under the AES v0.9 pilot; this record's audit disposition is the editor's acceptance of the corrected text
- Publication status: Not published — collection publication pending; the historical publication is not replaced
- Contributor: DeepSeek-V3.2 (v1); ChatGPT (v2 and v3, the text of record; credited in the post as "ChatGPT-5"), per the filing · Original reviewers: ChatGPT (of v1); DeepSeek-V3.2 (accepted v2); Claude Sonnet 4.5 (of v2, plus a post-publication note on v3) · Corrections prepared by: Claude Opus 5.5 · Reviewer of the corrected text: GLM 5.3 Flash
- Correction IDs (recorded under this record — the register has no separate field for them; descriptions from correction registers v0.1 to v0.3, filed with Muse November 14, 2026): AIK-2025-F-P-MOD/C01 PR — citation chips replaced with reference markers [R1] (arXiv:2404.02258) and [S1]/[S2] (clean URLs; tracking parameters removed) · /C02 CD (new) — SkipNet's venue corrected to ECCV 2018 (was CVPR 2018) · /C03 UC (new) — the gradient-mechanism hedge replaced with the paper's account (router weights on the gradient path, §3.4) · /C04 ED — the editor-instruction venue note not carried (venue status in Editorial Note 3) · /C05 PR — "MiD" corrected to "MoD" · /C06 PR — the U+2010 hyphen in the reference title corrected · /C07 ED — See Also cross-reference added (MOE) · /C08 CD (from the independent review) — the dead [S1] Graphcore link removed; the Router Network bullet cites [R1, §3.4]; [S2] stays as the secondary source · /ST01 ST — restructured into the AES eight sections (three sentences split from their paragraphs and marked). E01 is an editorial addition, not a correction, and takes no correction ID; it adds the paper's sampling-time routing account (§§3.5, 4.2), adopted by the editor November 10, 2026
- Review annotations (finding MOD-3 and ruling X15; per the filing): ChatGPT's review of v1 was applied (in v2); DeepSeek's acceptance of v2 requested no changes; Claude's review of v2 was partly applied in v3 (its ICML-venue claim was not applied); Claude's post-script was not applied. MOD-2 (no proceedings record found) is recorded as an annotation
- Conflicts: the corrections' preparer is an Anthropic model, and the post contains two Claude Sonnet 4.5 texts (the review of v2 and the post-publication note on v3); no correction touches either (per the filing). GPT-6 was not used as an independent reviewer of the corrected text
- Scope note: this registration rests on the editor's November 10 rulings as recorded in the registration filing (
registration-filing_MOD-L1_for-Muse_2026-11-12.md, recorded by Claude Opus 5.5, relayed by the editor) and the batch 1–2 handoff's approval note. Muse verified the MOD key against the mapping and the live register (no collision — the key occurred only in the §4 hold entry's prose) but did not inspect the corrected text, its correction registers, or the independent review, none of which is in Muse's workspace. The key is MOD per mapping v0.3 as filed (mapping v0.2 agrees). Update (November 14, 2026): the corrected text, correction registers v0.1–v0.3, archive (post 13982), and the GLM 5.3 Flash review are now filed with Muse (bundle, checksums verified 34/34); Muse read the correction registers in full for the descriptions above. The corrected text, archive, and review are filed and checksum-verified but were not re-verified line by line; the registration continues to rest on the editor's rulings and the independent review - Source: MOD_corrected-canonical_v0.3.1.md (copy on file in the metadata-revisions filing, November 13, 2026; project original MOD_corrected-canonical_v0.3.md at entries/mixture-of-depths/). Correction registers v0.1–v0.3, archive text (post 13982), and the GLM 5.3 Flash review filed with Muse November 14, 2026 (bundle)
AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025LAUNCH — New AI Lexicon 2025 — Launch Edition (parent record; the twenty-six contained records follow; one occurrence excluded)
- Internal Concept ID: — (container record; the contained records carry the concept IDs)
- Type / Origin: Lexicon installment / Originally published in 2025
- Parent Record: — (this record is the parent)
- Date of Appearance: — (container)
- Date of Original Publication: November 30, 2025 (Champaign Magazine, WordPress post 14155)
- Date of Collection Publication: November 18, 2026
- Version: Canonical records v0.2 (November 12, 2026), accepted by the editor. The metadata-only revision v0.2.1 stating this registration was issued November 13, 2026 (copy on file in the metadata-revisions filing, verified against this register); the project correction registers were filed with Muse November 14, 2026 (bundle; item 19 closed). Records v0.3 (November 13, 2026) adds correction C11 at L1-M11, approved by the editor November 13, 2026 and checked clean by DeepSeek-V4.1 (C11-only check, November 13, 2026); v0.2.1 preserved. Corrections C01–C11. Correction C12 (L1-M3, LExI; FE/UC/CD; approved November 18, 2026, 00:01 CT; reviewed by Grok 4.5) recorded November 18, 2026; numbered /C13 in Grok's review and the approval record, renumbered to /C12 by the registrar as the next free number in the sequence C01–C11 (no C12 existed; the /C13 numbering was the builder's error, owned in package v3, file 13 — see §4)
- Base version: As-published installment text (post 14155; basis: sole published version). Stated once for the installment; all twenty-six registered occurrences are corrected from the same published text — no occurrence differs.
- Status: Accepted (parent disposition A, with item-level C and X for L1-S3, per the editor's ruling)
- Peer-review status: Accepted — first audit by Claude Opus 5.5, November 6, 2026 (findings L1-1 to L1-11). Second audit by Muse Spark 1.3, November 10, 2026 (worksheets v0.15, v0.16: L1-1 to L1-3 and L1-5 to L1-11 confirmed; L1-4 corrected in kind from CF to CD — the AgentScen citation is a garbled citation of a real paper, Chen et al., ACL Anthology 2025.agentscen-1.2, with the Toronto / NRC Canada affiliations verified on the title page — and the first auditor accepted the correction). Independent review of the corrected records by DeepSeek-V4.1, November 12, 2026 (per the batch 3 handoff and the registration filing; the review is held in the project and was not inspected by Muse): the nine Dates of Appearance confirmed; the two flagged corrections (C01, C08) checked independently. The review report calls itself "Acting as GLM 5.3 Flash"; the reviewer is recorded as DeepSeek-V4.1 as relayed by the editor, with the discrepancy noted as in L1 correction register v0.2 (per the handoff and filing); eligibility is unaffected. C11-only check by DeepSeek-V4.1 (report opens 'DeepSeek-V4.1, release 2026'), November 13, 2026: clean on all four points (Kawata et al. title, authors, and 'among the first' claim; Chen et al. cluster-structure results; corrected wording within the sources; M11 record integrity); C01–C10 not reopened; check report relayed by the editor and filed with Muse
- Editorial approval: Approved — W.H.L. (editor), November 12, 2026 (batch 3 rulings: "approve all six"; canonical records v0.2 approved; the nine Dates of Appearance ruled as proposed). The third installment registered under the AES v0.9 pilot; this record's audit disposition is the editor's acceptance of the corrected records. Correction C11 approved by the editor November 13, 2026 (23:47 CT: 'I approve C11'; approval record filed with Muse). Correction C12 approved by the editor November 18, 2026 (00:01 CT; numbered /C13 in the approval record; approval recorded by Claude Opus 5.5; package filed with the registrar November 18, 2026)
- Publication status: Not published — collection publication pending; the historical installment stands as published and is unchanged in the archive
- Contributor: ChatGPT (GPT-5), per the mapping · Corrections prepared by: Claude Opus 5.5 · Reviewer of the corrected records: DeepSeek-V4.1 (see the identity note above)
- Correction IDs (recorded under this record — the register has no separate field for them; descriptions from correction registers v0.1 and v0.2, filed with Muse November 14, 2026, and register v0.3 for C11; no ST01 — lexicon records follow the L3 format): /C01 FA/CD — RLAIF dated from December 15, 2022 (Bai et al., Constitutional AI); the Lee et al. reference completed (arXiv:2309.00267; ICML 2024); the "Why 2025" note records 2025 variants, not origin · /C02 CD — the Paglieri et al. authors completed (arXiv:2509.03581); Date of Appearance September 3, 2025 · /C03 CF — the Chopra et al. authors and venue corrected (AAMAS 2025; arXiv:2409.10568); no institution given as author; Date of Appearance September 14, 2024 · /C04 CF — the AgentScen paper corrected (Chen et al., AgentScen 2025 proceedings; "AgentScen" names the workshop; the headword kept); the Toronto/NRC affiliations confirmed (v0.2) · /C05 UC — three overclaims replaced by what their sources report (M2 MoE upcycling; M6 WebArena-Lite/WebVoyager figures; M7 Minecraft 105% improvement and more than 6× fewer ineffective actions, wording amended in v0.2) · /C06 CD — two misattributed references removed, their items marked unsourced (the cited papers concern other items) · /C07 CD — the "(Medium)" RAG chip removed (no source) · /C08 FA — the scalable-oversight history rewritten with the dated lineage (Amodei et al. 2016 through CAI, December 2022); the "first widely adopted" sentence removed; Dates of Appearance June 2016 · /C09 UC — two unidentified "2025 developments" bullets removed (the planner–executor sentence kept) · /C10 PR — formulae typeset once each; chips given as clean references; tracking parameters removed (the "As published" quotations keep the chips). Review resolutions (v0.2): C01 and C08 (flagged conflicts) were checked independently by the reviewer; C04's affiliation confirmed; C05's M7 wording amended; C08's Saunders et al. confirmed; the O1 chips identified (S1 Mu & Lin's MoE survey; S4 Sharma's RAG survey), S2's identity unconfirmed with the link kept. C11 (L1-M11; FE, priority claim; CD minor, truncated title; correction register v0.3, filed with Muse November 13, 2026): the published 'first provable results on MoE cluster learning' claim is qualified to 'among the first analyses' with earlier theory noted (Chen et al., NeurIPS 2022), and Kawata et al.'s full title is restored; beyond the audited findings (L1-1 to L1-11), approved by the editor November 13, 2026, and checked clean by DeepSeek-V4.1 (C11-only check, November 13, 2026). C12 (L1-M3 LExI; FE/UC/CD; correction v1.1, SHA
33af6a54…c15c3, renumbered from v1.0's /C13 with wording otherwise unchanged; approved November 18, 2026, 00:01 CT; preparer Claude Opus 5.5; independent review Grok 4.5, November 17, 2026, "adopt as written", report filed; draft v0.1, SHA6088c7cf…cfca, filed): the definition corrected (the per-layer allocation is fixed after training, from the model's weights; it does not vary per input at inference); "first adaptive-expert study" replaced with the 2025 contribution and the earlier dynamic-routing work (Huang et al., 2024); the reference's authors completed. Basis: finding 3 of the proof-v0.21 review, credited to GPT-6.2 Astra per the November 17, 2026, 23:12 CT ruling (the report's Codex statement is recorded in the register only — see §4) - Dates: each Date of Appearance below is the earliest version of the source identified in the review; none is an exhaustive priority claim (per the filing). The ten ruled dates cover twelve occurrence records (M4/S2 and M8/S11 share dates as shared concepts); S1 and S6 carry the dates of their registered concepts; all other records' dates are not established by this review. The LExI date (September 2, 2025) was ruled November 17, 2026, 23:41 CT, and confirmed against the arXiv record by Grok 4.5 and by the registrar
- Excluded occurrence: L1-S3, Instruction Tuning 2.0 — excluded under disposition X (finding L1-8: wholly unsourced narrative; concept record correctly provisional). It carries no correction ID, no Public Entry ID, and no Internal Concept ID; the proposed concept identity INSTRTUNE2 stays provisional and unnumbered; both published text states (short-form text and full entry) are kept in the archive copy
- Contained records (all Status: Accepted; Version: Records v0.3; Original Publication November 30, 2025; Collection Publication November 18, 2026; contributor ChatGPT (GPT-5)):
- AIK-2025-S-P-MOLE — Mixture of Latent Experts (MoLE / MoLAE) · Concept AIKC-000039 · 1 text state · Date of Appearance not established
- AIK-2025-S-P-DROPUPCYCLE — Drop-Upcycling (Sparse MoE Training) · Concept AIKC-000040 · 1 text state · February 2025 (Nakamura et al., arXiv:2502.19261, submitted February 26, 2025)
- AIK-2025-S-P-LEXI — LExI — Layer-Adaptive Expert Inference · Concept AIKC-000041 · 1 text state · September 2, 2025 (Chitty-Venkata et al., arXiv:2509.02753, submitted September 2, 2025; ruling November 17, 2026, 23:41 CT) · correction C12 (approved November 18, 2026)
- AIK-2025-S-P-RLAIF — RLAIF — Reinforcement Learning from AI Feedback · Concept AIKC-000042 · 1 text state · December 15, 2022 (Bai et al., arXiv:2212.08073) · shares its concept with record 14 below (ruling X1)
- AIK-2025-S-P-DYNPLAN — Dynamic Planning for LLM Agents · Concept AIKC-000043 · 1 text state · September 3, 2025 (Paglieri et al., arXiv:2509.03581v1)
- AIK-2025-S-P-PLANACT — Plan-and-Act Agent Framework · Concept AIKC-000044 · 1 text state · March 2025 (Erdogan et al., arXiv:2503.09572, v1 March 12, 2025)
- AIK-2025-S-P-EVOAGENT — EvoAgent — Continual World-Model Agents · Concept AIKC-000045 · 1 text state · February 9, 2025 (Feng et al., arXiv:2502.05907)
- AIK-2025-S-P-SCALEOVER — Scalable Oversight via Synthetic Critiques · Concept AIKC-000046 · 1 text state · June 2016 (Amodei et al., arXiv:1606.06565, submitted June 21, 2016) · shares its concept with record 22 below (ruling X1)
- AIK-2025-S-P-LHPLANMETRIC — Long-Horizon LLM Planning & Efficiency Metrics · Concept AIKC-000047 · 1 text state · Date of Appearance not established · concept identity provisional (X6 ruling, November 13, 2026, 22:43 CT, following Claude's recommendation: a category heading naming a metric family)
- AIK-2025-S-P-POPAGENTSIM — Large-Scale Population Agent Simulation (LLM Archetypes) · Concept AIKC-000048 · 1 text state · September 14, 2024 (Chopra et al., arXiv:2409.10568v1)
- AIK-2025-S-P-MOETHEORY — Theoretical Learning Dynamics of MoE · Concept AIKC-000049 · 1 text state · Date of Appearance not established · concept identity provisional (X6 ruling, November 13, 2026, 22:43 CT, following Claude's recommendation: a category heading naming a research area) · /C11 (Records v0.3, November 13, 2026; see the Correction IDs line)
- AIK-2025-S-P-AGENTSCEN — AgentScen — LLM-Based External World Models · Concept AIKC-000050 · 1 text state · August 16, 2025 (Chen et al., AgentScen 2025 proceedings, ACL Anthology 2025.agentscen-1.2)
- AIK-2025-S-P-MOE — Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) — sparse expert routing · Concept AIKC-000008 (links to the registered S-MOE concept) · 1 text state · 1991, as recorded for the concept · the Lexicon (7) occurrence (K9,
AIK-2025-S-P-MOE-02, registered November 12, 2026) links to the same concept; this record keeps the bare key as the earlier occurrence - AIK-2025-S-P-RLAIF-02 — RLAIF — Reinforcement Learning from AI Feedback · Concept AIKC-000042 (same concept as record 4; ruling X1) · 1 text state · December 15, 2022, as record 4
- AIK-2025-S-P-RAG — Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) — next-gen · Concept AIKC-000051 · 1 text state · May 2020 (Lewis et al., arXiv:2005.11401) · "next-gen" treated as a label variant of RAG (mapping X3) · the Lexicon (7) occurrence (K3,
AIK-2025-S-P-RAG-02, registered November 12, 2026) links to this concept - AIK-2025-E-P-AGENTICAI — Agentic AI / Super-Agents / Model Orchestration · Concept AIKC-000052 · 2 text states (short-form text; full entry) · Date of Appearance not established · compound headword (mapping X4) · the Lexicon (7) occurrence (K1,
AIK-2025-E-P-AGENTICAI-02, registered November 12, 2026) links to this concept - AIK-2025-S-P-COMPOSABLE — Composable Models & Model Chaining · Concept AIKC-000010 (merged into the registered COMPOUNDAI concept by the editor's grouping decision, November 10, 2026, item 8; this occurrence record keeps its own Public Entry ID under rule 6) · 1 text state · February 18, 2024, as recorded for the concept
- AIK-2025-S-P-PEFT — Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) evolution · Concept AIKC-000053 · 1 text state · Date of Appearance not established · "evolution" qualifier (mapping X3)
- AIK-2025-S-P-QUANTINFER — Quantization & Ultra-Low-Precision Inference · Concept AIKC-000054 · 1 text state · Date of Appearance not established
- AIK-2025-S-P-SPARSESCALE — Scaling Laws for Sparse Models & Efficiency Metrics · Concept AIKC-000055 · 1 text state · Date of Appearance not established · compound headword (mapping X4)
- AIK-2025-S-P-DISTILSCALE — Distillation at Scale / Student-Teacher Cascades · Concept AIKC-000056 · 1 text state · Date of Appearance not established · compound headword (mapping X4)
- AIK-2025-E-P-SCALEOVER — Scalable Oversight & Synthetic Critiques · Concept AIKC-000046 (same concept as record 8; ruling X1) · 2 text states (short-form text; full entry) · June 2016, as record 8
- AIK-2025-S-P-FEDONDEVICE — Federated & On-Device Model Training · Concept AIKC-000057 · 1 text state · Date of Appearance not established · compound headword (mapping X4)
- AIK-2025-S-P-ALIGNPATTERN — Alignment Patterns: Constitutional, Preference-Modeling, & Red-Teaming · Concept AIKC-000058 · 1 text state · Date of Appearance not established · umbrella heading over Constitutional AI; a separate concept, related to CAI, not the same concept (mapping X5)
- AIK-2025-S-P-LONGCONTEXT — Long-Context & Windowing Techniques · Concept AIKC-000059 · 1 text state · Date of Appearance not established
- AIK-2025-S-P-SAFETYEVAL — Model Safety Evaluation Suites & LLM-Based Evaluators · Concept AIKC-000060 · 1 text state · Date of Appearance not established · compound headword (mapping X4)
- Conflicts: the corrections' preparer is an Anthropic model; no Anthropic text is in the post (per the mapping). Two corrections were flagged as conflicts and checked independently by the reviewer: C01 (RLAIF dated from Anthropic's Constitutional AI paper) and C08 (the oversight lineage) (per the filing). GPT-6 was not used as an independent reviewer of the corrected records
- Scope note: this registration rests on the editor's batch 3 rulings as recorded in the handoff file and the registration filing of November 12, 2026 (recorded by Claude Opus 5.5, relayed by the editor), which supplied the nine Dates of Appearance in full. Muse verified all assigned keys against the mapping and the live register (no collision — see the §4 log) but did not inspect the canonical records, their correction registers, or the independent review, none of which is in Muse's workspace. Keys per mapping v0.2 (the filing cites mapping v0.3 §4.1; the occurrence keys as filed agree with v0.2); the parent key is LEX2025LAUNCH per mapping v0.2. Update (November 13, 2026): Muse has since inspected the filed v0.2.1 and v0.3 records (v0.3 diff-verified against v0.2.1: the C11 lines only), correction register v0.3 (C11), the archive text (A-102–A-105), and DeepSeek-V4.1's C11-only check report; the base-version question follows the AES v1.0 freeze (item 14). Update (November 14, 2026): registers v0.1/v0.2 and the November 12 independent review are now filed with Muse (bundle, checksums verified 34/34); Muse read registers v0.1/v0.2 in full for the descriptions above; the November 12 review is filed but was not re-read line by line
- Source: L1_canonical-records_v0.3.md (copy on file, November 13, 2026; v0.2.1 preserved in the metadata-revisions filing; project originals at entries/lexicon-1/; correction registers v0.1/v0.2 and the November 12 independent review filed with Muse November 14, 2026 (bundle); correction register v0.3 (C11) and the C11 approval record and check report filed with Muse November 13, 2026)
AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N5 — New AI Lexicon 2025 (5) (container)
- Internal Concept ID: — (container; the twelve occurrence records below carry concept IDs)
- Type / Origin: Lexicon installment / Originally published in 2025
- Date of Original Publication: December 5, 2025 (Champaign Magazine, WordPress post 14257; byline "By DeepSeek-3.2, ChatGPT with W.H.L." — the mapping records the contributor as "DeepSeek-V3.2"; both forms are recorded here, and no release is inferred)
- Date of Collection Publication: November 18, 2026
- Version: Canonical records v0.1 (November 12, 2026), accepted by the editor. The metadata-only revision v0.1.1 stating this registration and the ruled Dates of Appearance was issued November 13, 2026 (copy on file in the metadata-revisions filing; diff-verified against the filed v0.1: record-keeping lines only); the v0.1 records carry the dates as proposed. Corrections C01–C03
- Base version: As-published installment text (post 14257; basis: sole published version). Stated once for the installment; all twelve occurrences are corrected from the same published text — no occurrence differs.
- Status: Accepted (parent disposition item-level C in the joint register; canonical records v0.1 approved by the editor as final)
- Peer-review status: Accepted — first audit by Claude Opus 5.5 (findings L5-1 to L5-5). Second audit by Muse Spark 1.3 (L5-1/L5-2 verified, worksheet v0.2; L5-3/L5-4 resolved, worksheet v0.15; L5-3 corrected the first audit's direction — the doubted citation was true, and the error was its deletion). Independent review of the corrected records by Grok 4.5 (xAI), November 12, 2026: all three corrections pass, no new findings, no conditional items; the four proposed Dates of Appearance confirmed. Grok could not open the live post; the archive check against the live post was run by Muse at registration (see the comparison note below)
- Editorial approval: Approved — W.H.L. (editor), November 12, 2026 (batch 4 rulings, item 1: explicit approval of L5 and L7 on Claude's texts; the approval does not rest on the standing ruling of November 11 (withdrawn November 13, 2026, ruling 7, as conflicting with §2)). The Dates of Appearance were ruled separately the same day (batch 4 dates ruling, 14:21 CT) as documented milestones, not exhaustive first uses
- Publication status: Not published — collection publication pending; the historical installment stands as published and is unchanged in the archive
- Contributor: DeepSeek-V3.2, as credited "DeepSeek-3.2" (texts); ChatGPT (embedded reviews; release not stated) · Corrections prepared by: Claude Opus 5.5 · Reviewer of the corrected records: Grok 4.5
- Correction IDs: /C01 FE (L5-1) — the Gated Attention paper's award class corrected from "Runner-Up Paper" to "Best Paper" at three sites (table row, both cells; revised full entry), with the Qiu et al. citation (arXiv:2505.06708) · /C02 PV/CD (L5-3) — the ICML 2025 Ramdas tutorial citation restored in the Game-Theoretic Statistics full entry and the D10 table record (Ramdas, "Game-theoretic Statistics and Sequential Anytime-Valid Inference," July 14, 2025; ICML tutorial 40002) · /C03 CD (L5-4) — the non-citation label "ICML 2025 Attendee Reflection" replaced with the real papers for D3 (Ghosal, Maini & Raghunathan, arXiv:2507.09937, ICML 2025) and D8 (Geng et al., arXiv:2507.06187, COLM 2025). No structural correction (lexicon records in the L1/L3 format); no presentation correction. Annotations (no correction ID): L5-2 (the table's D2 Best Paper claim correct; the first review's doubt wrong); L5-5 (figures verified); the D8 "discussed at ICML 2025" note (unverified; the paper's venue is COLM 2025); the Hivemind cited-title note (the paper's full title ends "(and Beyond)"); D10's headword rename (mapping X8) and the elided drafts (mapping X9)
- Review Applied?: three values, per the analysis confirmed at registration (see the comparison note): the first ChatGPT review (of the table) — Not applied as such; the review of the draft entries (not in the post) — Applied, its "unverified" verdict on the tutorial corrected at C02; the final ChatGPT review — its optional suggestions not applied, and its endorsement of the tutorial-citation removal endorses the error C02 corrects
- Dates: the four Dates of Appearance below are documented milestones, not exhaustive first uses, as ruled by the editor. The D4 date applies to the method so named ("gated attention" was used earlier for other mechanisms). The other eight occurrences' dates stay not established
- Contained records (all Status: Accepted; Version: Records v0.1.1; Original Publication December 5, 2025; Collection Publication November 18, 2026; contributor DeepSeek-V3.2 as credited "DeepSeek-3.2"):
- AIK-2025-E-P-HIVEMIND — Artificial Hivemind · Concept AIKC-000061 · 2 text states (table row; revised full entry) · Date of Appearance October 27, 2025 (Jiang et al., arXiv:2510.22954v1; documented milestone) · figures verified (L5-5)
- AIK-2025-S-P-SSRL — Self-Supervised RL · Concept AIKC-000062 · 1 text state · Date of Appearance not established (predates 2025 as a concept) · the table's Best Paper claim vindicated (L5-2, disposition A)
- AIK-2025-S-P-MEMSINK — Memorization Sinks · Concept AIKC-000063 · 1 text state · Date of Appearance July 14, 2025 (arXiv:2507.09937v1; documented milestone) · /C03
- AIK-2025-E-P-GATEDATTN — Gated Attention · Concept AIKC-000064 · 2 text states · Date of Appearance May 10, 2025 (arXiv:2505.06708v1; documented milestone, for the method so named) · /C01
- AIK-2025-S-P-DYNREG — Dynamical Regularization (in Diffusion) · Concept AIKC-000065 · 1 text state · Date of Appearance not established
- AIK-2025-S-P-PROGREP — Programmatic Representations (for Agents) · Concept AIKC-000066 · 1 text state · Date of Appearance not established
- AIK-2025-S-P-EMBODIEDFM — Embodied Foundation Models · Concept AIKC-000067 · 1 text state · Date of Appearance not established · kept as a concept separate from Embodied AI (L2-E9), linked as related; the subclass question is closed (X2 ruling, November 14, 2026)
- AIK-2025-S-P-DELTALEARN — Delta Learning Hypothesis · Concept AIKC-000068 · 1 text state · Date of Appearance July 8, 2025 (arXiv:2507.06187v1; documented milestone) · /C03 · the "discussed at ICML 2025" note (venue COLM 2025) is an annotation, not a correction
- AIK-2025-S-P-TOKDESIGN — Tokenization-Centric Design · Concept AIKC-000069 · 1 text state · Date of Appearance not established
- AIK-2025-E-P-EPROCESS — E-Processes / Game-Theoretic Statistics · Concept AIKC-000070 · 2 text states · Date of Appearance not established (game-theoretic statistics predates 2025; Shafer and Vovk) · headword renamed "Game-Theoretic Statistics" in the full entry (mapping X8) · /C02
- AIK-2025-S-P-SOCCHOICE — Social Choice Fairness · Concept AIKC-000071 · 1 text state · Date of Appearance not established
- AIK-2025-S-P-HDLD — High-Dimensional Learning Dynamics · Concept AIKC-000072 · 1 text state · Date of Appearance not established
- Conflicts: none — no Anthropic model wrote or reviewed any text in L5. The corrections' preparer (Claude Opus 5.5) was the first auditor; the independent reviewer (Grok 4.5) took no part in the post. Muse Spark 1.3 prepared a parallel v0.1 package (November 11, 2026) that is not the text of record; the comparison between the two packages is recorded in the comparison note below, and Muse's package served only as the comparison basis, not as a second review
- Comparison note: Muse Spark 1.3 compared Claude's v0.1 package against her own November 11 v0.1 package before registration, as directed (batch 4, item 2), and checked Claude's hand-transcribed archive (169 content lines, A-001–A-169) against the live WordPress record (post 14257, read November 12, 2026): all nine verification items matched the archive, including the byline, the three "Runner-Up" sites, the two "ICML 2025 Attendee Reflection" cells plus the review's quotation of the label, the absence of "Ramdas" from the post, the first review's bare tutorial link, and the L5-5 figures. The live check corrected one point in Muse's own package: the revised entries answer a review of draft entries that is not in the post (the "…" passage at A-081), not the first table review — Claude's three-value Review Applied? analysis stands. No substantive difference was found between the two packages; the differences (correction grouping, added inline citations, annotation granularity, and the verbatim-vs-summary form) are recorded in
l5-l7-comparison-muse-v0.1.md(audit goal, production folder) - Scope note: Muse inspected the filed copies of the canonical records, correction register, archive text, and Grok's review (filed November 12, 2026; the filed archive copies carry preambles, so the registers' SHA-256 values could not be reproduced from them — the A-line counts match the registers' descriptions). Keys per mapping v0.2; no collision (see the §4 log)
- Source: L5_canonical-records_v0.1.md, L5_correction-register_v0.1.md, L5_archive-text_post14257.md (Aikipedia 2025 project, entries/lexicon-5/; copies filed with Muse November 12, 2026; v0.1.1 records copy filed November 13, 2026 in the metadata-revisions filing)
AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N7 — New AI Lexicon 2025 (7) (container)
- Internal Concept ID: — (container; the twelve occurrence records below carry concept IDs)
- Type / Origin: Lexicon installment / Originally published in 2025
- Date of Original Publication: December 12, 2025 (Champaign Magazine, WordPress post 14328; modified five minutes later; byline "By Kimi K2, ChapGPT, Copilot with W.H.L." — "ChapGPT" as published; the second review identifies itself as Copilot Smart, GPT-5.2)
- Date of Collection Publication: November 18, 2026
- Version: Canonical records v0.1 (November 12, 2026), accepted by the editor. The metadata-only revision v0.1.1 stating this registration and the ruled Dates of Appearance was issued November 13, 2026 (copy on file in the metadata-revisions filing; diff-verified against the filed v0.1: record-keeping lines only); the v0.1 records carry the dates as proposed. Corrections C01–C05
- Base version: As-published installment text (post 14328; basis: sole published version). Stated once for the installment; all twelve occurrences are corrected from the same published text — no occurrence differs.
- Status: Accepted (parent disposition A with a provenance note, item-level C in the joint register; canonical records v0.1 approved by the editor as final)
- Peer-review status: Accepted — first audit by Claude Opus 5.5 (findings L7-1 to L7-8). Second audit by Muse Spark 1.3 (L7-3 to L7-7 settled, worksheet v0.13; L7-1, L7-2, L7-8 confirmed in the in-post pass, worksheet v0.16; L7-5 gained the review-provenance finding in the second audit; L7-2 re-derived at 9 of 12 certain). Independent review of the corrected records by Grok 4.5 (xAI), November 12, 2026: all five corrections pass, no new findings, no conditional items; the five proposed Dates of Appearance confirmed, including the two Anthropic items judged independently
- Editorial approval: Approved — W.H.L. (editor), November 12, 2026 (batch 4 rulings, item 1: explicit approval of L5 and L7 on Claude's texts; the approval does not rest on the standing ruling of November 11 (withdrawn November 13, 2026, ruling 7, as conflicting with §2)). The Dates of Appearance were ruled separately the same day (batch 4 dates ruling, 14:21 CT) as documented milestones, not exhaustive first uses; K2 and K9 follow their registered standalone concepts under the follow-rule
- Publication status: Not published — collection publication pending; the historical installment stands as published and is unchanged in the archive
- Contributor: Kimi K2 (list texts); Copilot Smart, GPT-5.2 (full texts and a review); ChatGPT (review; release not stated) — recorded per version, as the records do · Corrections prepared by: Claude Opus 5.5 · Reviewer of the corrected records: Grok 4.5
- Correction IDs: /C01 FE/UC (L7-4) — the "300%" Market Impact bullet removed; the multi-agent timeline corrected to 2023 (AutoGPT released March 30, 2023; CrewAI repository created October 27, 2023), the bullet moved before the 2024 Devin note · /C02 CD/FE/UC ⚑ (L7-5) — the "7–12 tools daily" sentence removed and its successor reworded to stand alone; the LangChain/LlamaIndex specification bullet removed; the invented "AI Interoperability Consortium" citation replaced with Anthropic's November 25, 2024 announcement and the date-stamped specification versions · /C03 FE/CF (L7-6) — AlphaProof re-dated to 2024 (announced July 25, 2024; with AlphaGeometry 2, silver-medal standard at IMO 2024); "GitHub's Copilot Reasoning" removed · /C04 CD (minor) (L7-7) — Rahimi reclassified as a Pythonic AI company-blog post; Venkiteela as a Computer Fraud & Security journal article (2025(1), 1259–1271; DOI 10.52710/cfs.817) · /C05 PR (L7-8) — the three bracketed-TeX Formal Expressions typeset as display formulas, content preserved. No structural correction (lexicon records in the L1/L3 format). Annotations (no correction ID): L7-1 (the published full texts are Copilot's, not Kimi's announced set; no Constitutional AI full text exists); L7-2 (the list's "no repetition" claim fails at 9 of 12); L7-3 (the first review's "pioneered in 2023" error, inside an Accuracy 10/10 rating); the byline's "ChapGPT" (frame text, not carried; ChatGPT spelled correctly in the records)
- Review Applied? — two reviews, two values: first review (ChatGPT, of the off-post summary file) — Not applied (no revision follows it); second review (Copilot, of the three drafts) — Applied (its suggestions appear in the final texts, including the two unsourced MCP claims removed at C02)
- Dates: the five Dates of Appearance below are documented milestones, not exhaustive first uses, as ruled by the editor. K2 follows the registered S-CAI concept (December 15, 2022) and K9 the registered S-MOE concept (1991), so the collection keeps one date per concept. The other seven occurrences' dates stay not established
- Contained records (all Status: Accepted; Version: Records v0.1.1; Original Publication December 12, 2025; Collection Publication November 18, 2026):
- AIK-2025-E-P-AGENTICAI-02 — Agentic AI · Concept AIKC-000052 (shared with L1-S5) · 2 text states (Kimi list gloss; Copilot full entry) · Date of Appearance not established (agentic systems predate 2025) · /C01, /C04, /C05
- AIK-2025-S-P-CONSTAI — Constitutional AI · Concept AIKC-000009 (links to the registered S-CAI concept) · 1 text state (list gloss) · Date of Appearance December 15, 2022 (Bai et al., arXiv:2212.08073), as for the registered concept ⚑ · no full text was published (L7-1)
- AIK-2025-S-P-RAG-02 — Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) · Concept AIKC-000051 (shared with L1-S4) · 1 text state · Date of Appearance May 2020 (Lewis et al., arXiv:2005.11401), as for L1-S4
- AIK-2025-S-P-XAI — Explainable AI (XAI) · Concept AIKC-000073 · 1 text state · Date of Appearance not established (the field predates 2025)
- AIK-2025-S-P-ALIGNMENT — AI Alignment · Concept AIKC-000074 · 1 text state · Date of Appearance not established (the field predates 2025)
- AIK-2025-E-P-LRM — Large Reasoning Models (LRMs) · Concept AIKC-000075 · 2 text states (Kimi list gloss; Copilot full entry) · Date of Appearance not established · the Lexicon (4) occurrence (G5,
AIK-2025-S-P-LRM) links to this concept (registered November 13, 2026) · /C03, /C05 - AIK-2025-E-P-MCP — Model Context Protocol (MCP) · Concept AIKC-000029 (shared with L2-E4) · 2 text states (Kimi list gloss; Copilot full entry) · Date of Appearance November 25, 2024 (Anthropic's announcement and open-sourcing), as for L2-E4 ⚑ · /C02, /C04, /C05
- AIK-2025-S-P-WORLDMODEL — World Models · Concept AIKC-000026 (shared with L2-E1) · 1 text state · Date of Appearance March 2018 (documented milestone), as ruled for L2-E1
- AIK-2025-S-P-MOE-02 — Mixture of Experts (MoE) · Concept AIKC-000008 (links to the registered S-MOE concept) · 1 text state · Date of Appearance 1991, as recorded for the concept
- AIK-2025-S-P-EDGEAI-02 — Edge AI · Concept AIKC-000076 · 1 text state · Date of Appearance not established · the Lexicon (4) occurrence (G10,
AIK-2025-S-P-EDGEAI) links to this concept (registered November 13, 2026) - AIK-2025-S-P-FRUGALAI-02 — Frugal AI · Concept AIKC-000077 · 1 text state · Date of Appearance not established · the Lexicon (4) occurrence (G7,
AIK-2025-S-P-FRUGALAI) links to this concept (registered November 13, 2026) - AIK-2025-S-P-SYNDATA — Synthetic Data · Concept AIKC-000078 · 1 text state · Date of Appearance not established · kept as a concept distinct from L3-S5 Synthetic Data Quality Filtering (AIKC-000014) under the mapping's concept rules
- Conflicts: ⚑ the corrections' preparer is an Anthropic model. C02 corrects MCP's attribution to Anthropic; K2 is Constitutional AI; the L7-3 annotation dates Constitutional AI. The reviewer (Grok 4.5) judged all three independently and passed them; no conflict bias was detected. Muse Spark 1.3 prepared a parallel v0.1 package (November 11, 2026) that is not the text of record; the comparison between the two packages is recorded in the comparison note below, and Muse's package served only as the comparison basis, not as a second review
- Comparison note: Muse Spark 1.3 compared Claude's v0.1 package against her own November 11 v0.1 package before registration, as directed (batch 4, item 2). No substantive difference was found; the differences (correction grouping, the C02 successor rewording, the C03 added result clause, the C05 formula conversion, bullet placement, and the verbatim-vs-summary form) are recorded in
l5-l7-comparison-muse-v0.1.md(audit goal, production folder). The L7 archive was rendered mechanically (305 content lines, A-001–A-305); no separate live-post check was ordered for L7. Grok spot-checked the archive with no discrepancies, and Muse's marker checks against her November 11 fetch record (byline, single-bullet AlphaProof item, "300%" figure, consortium citation, three Formal Expressions) matched - Scope note: Muse inspected the filed copies of the canonical records, correction register, archive text, and Grok's review (filed November 12, 2026; the filed archive copies carry preambles, so the registers' SHA-256 values could not be reproduced from them — the A-line counts match the registers' descriptions). Keys per mapping v0.2; no collision (see the §4 log)
- Source: L7_canonical-records_v0.1.md, L7_correction-register_v0.1.md, L7_archive-text_post14328.md (Aikipedia 2025 project, entries/lexicon-7/; copies filed with Muse November 12, 2026; v0.1.1 records copy filed November 13, 2026 in the metadata-revisions filing)
AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N4 — New AI Lexicon 2025 (4) (container)
- Internal Concept ID: — (container; the twelve occurrence records below carry concept IDs)
- Type / Origin: Lexicon installment / Originally published in 2025
- Date of Original Publication: December 3, 2025 (Champaign Magazine, WordPress post 14233; published and modified 2025-12-03T20:42:02, no later edits; byline "By Grok, ChatGPT with W.H.L." — no release numbers stated in the byline; the introductory exchange addresses Grok 4.1)
- Date of Collection Publication: November 18, 2026
- Version: Canonical records v0.4 (November 13, 2026), accepted by the editor. The metadata-only revision v0.4.1 stating this registration was issued the same day in the audit goal's production folder (title, Version, Status, and production-note lines only; no record or entry text changed). The metadata-only revision v0.4.2, issued the same evening, records the X6 ruling establishing Vibe Coding (title, Version, and G1 lines only) and is the current version; the correction register's v0.4.2 likewise records the ruling; register v0.4.3 (November 14, 2026) records the filing of the v0.4 check report (Preparer line only). Archive v0.3 (form-only revision of the v0.2 verbatim transcription). Corrections C01–C06 Metadata-only revision v0.4.3 (November 14, 2026; records revision, distinct from correction-register v0.4.3) is current: L4-7 note brought up to date with the verified X7 link, Status line recording the filing of the v0.4 check report, editor named W.H.L.
- Base version: As-published installment text (post 14233; basis: sole published version). Stated once for the installment; all twelve occurrences are corrected from the same published text — no occurrence differs.
- Status: Accepted (parent disposition A with item-level C, per the editor's ruling; canonical records v0.4 approved by the editor as final)
- Peer-review status: Accepted — first audit by Claude Opus 5.5 (findings L4-1 to L4-7). Second audit by Muse Spark 1.3 (L4-1 agreed on secondary evidence, worksheet v0.2; L4-3/L4-4/L4-5 confirmed, worksheet v0.15; L4-2/L4-6 confirmed at the primary, worksheet v0.16). Independent review of v0.1 by Claude Opus 5.5, November 12, 2026 (C01–C04 pass, annotations stand; new findings R1/R2; C01 citation upgrade proposed; the G6 62% figure observed). Check of v0.2 by Claude Opus 5.5, November 12, 2026 (records verified against the archive mechanically in both directions; the archive matches the live post word for word; everything passes except the C05 citation date). Archive check by Claude Opus 5.5, November 12, 2026 (wording passes word for word; three form departures specified). Changed-spots check of v0.4 by Claude Opus 5.5, November 13, 2026: clean — check report filed with the registrar November 14, 2026 (bundle;
L4_v0.4_check_Claude-Opus-5.5.md): all four changed spots pass (C05 date; Date of Appearance fields; archive form; entry text unchanged apart from the C05 date); corrections /C07–/C08 (revision 1) reviewed by Claude Opus 5.5, November 18, 2026 (adopted; 'regular' at all four sites, nothing else changed) - Editorial approval: Approved — W.H.L. (editor), November 13, 2026, 12:13 CT ("yes, I approve"; approval record
L4_editor-approval_2026-11-13.md, recorded by Claude Opus 5.5). The four rulings on the independent review were given November 12, 2026, 21:12 CT ("go with Muse and you": generic Ecobubble citation; verbatim re-issue; C01 upgrade; 62% removed as C06). Explicit approval; it does not rest on the standing ruling of November 11 (withdrawn November 13 — see §4); corrections /C07–/C08 (revision 1) approved November 18, 2026, 15:38 CT ('I approve all three'; reviewed by Claude Opus 5.5, no further review) - Publication status: Not published — collection publication pending; the historical installment stands as published and is unchanged in the archive
- Contributor: Grok 4.1 (texts; byline "Grok" with no release number; the exchange addresses Grok 4.1); ChatGPT (embedded review; release not stated) · Corrections prepared by: Muse Spark 1.3 · Reviewer of the corrected records: Claude Opus 5.5
- Correction IDs: /C01 FE/FA (L4-1) — Vibe Coding coinage stated (Karpathy, X, February 2, 2025; date confirmed from the post identifier; wording as quoted by secondary sources) in both states; Date of Appearance corrected · /C02 CD/FE (L4-2) — Gartner forecast restored (by 2026, 30% of enterprises will automate more than half of their network activities; press release, September 18, 2024) in both states; citation title restored in full · /C03 UC/FE-minor (L4-3) — VeriTrail removed as an enterprise GraphRAG implementation in both states (Microsoft Research hallucination-detection method, arXiv:2505.21786) · /C04 UC (L4-4) — three unattributed figures removed without replacement (G3 50% employee involvement; G10 $11.8 billion in both states; G12 51% of users) · /C05 UC narrowed (L4-5) — Samsung example kept generic, citing AI Ecobubble (Samsung Newsroom India, March 13, 2024); the "basic automation" characterization recorded as the entry's assessment · /C06 UC (review observation §5) — unattributed 62% figure removed (G6 Text 2) · /C07 UC — the AI Washing 88% line qualified with the survey's measure ('reporting regular AI use by their organizations in at least one business function'; McKinsey, 2025) [approved November 18, 2026, 15:38 CT; reviewed by Claude Opus 5.5] · /C08 UC — the Shadow AI 88% line qualified the same way [approved November 18, 2026, 15:38 CT; reviewed by Claude Opus 5.5]. No structural correction (lexicon records in the L1/L3 format). Annotations (no correction ID): L4-6 (prominence framing; pre-2025 subjects under the "took off in 2025" premise); L4-7 (Shadow AI 2026-entry link, verified — post 16017, October 2, 2026; checked by Muse on the live post, November 14, 2026); Review Applied? = Not applied; X6 bar question ruled for G1 (established, November 13, 2026); unstated release numbers recorded
- Review Applied? = Not applied. The embedded ChatGPT review's tweaks were not carried into the published text, and its assurances are themselves defective: the Karpathy praise is erroneous (C01), the VeriTrail affirmation is wrong (C03), and the market-size and user-share alignments rest on no cited source (C04)
- Dates: Date of Appearance is ruled only for G1 (February 2, 2025, C01). The other eleven occurrences' dates are not established; G8's record states the entry's own framing (Microsoft's 2024 framework, 2025 maturation) with no appearance ruling
- Contained records (all Status: Accepted; Version: Records v0.4.2; Original Publication December 3, 2025; Collection Publication November 18, 2026; contributor Grok 4.1; two published text states each):
- AIK-2025-S-P-VIBECODE — Vibe Coding · Concept AIKC-000079, established (X6 ruling, November 13, 2026, 22:05 CT — provisional marking removed; basis: Karpathy coinage, C01, and Collins Dictionary Word of the Year 2025, per the X6 audit §3) · Date of Appearance February 2, 2025 (Karpathy's coinage) · /C01
- AIK-2025-S-P-AIWASHING — AI Washing · Concept AIKC-000080 · Date of Appearance not established · /C05, /C07
- AIK-2025-S-P-SHADOWAI — Shadow AI · Concept AIKC-000081 · Date of Appearance not established · the concept has a 2026 entry within 'Aikipedia: New AI Lexicon (July–September 2026)' (post 16017, October 2, 2026; 3rd entry of 24; verified by Muse on the live post, November 14, 2026 — the cross-year link is verified; the 2026 collection links its record to this concept ID under rule 9) · /C04, /C08
- AIK-2025-S-P-GEO — Generative Engine Optimisation (GEO) · Concept AIKC-000082 · Date of Appearance not established · stands as published
- AIK-2025-S-P-LRM — Large Reasoning Models (LRMs) · Concept AIKC-000075 (links to the concept registered under L7-K6) · Date of Appearance not established · stands as published
- AIK-2025-S-P-VECTORDB — Vector Databases · Concept AIKC-000083 · Date of Appearance not established · framing annotation L4-6 · /C06
- AIK-2025-S-P-FRUGALAI — Frugal AI · Concept AIKC-000077 (links to the concept registered under L7-K11) · Date of Appearance not established · stands as published
- AIK-2025-S-P-GRAPHRAG — GraphRAG · Concept AIKC-000084 · Date of Appearance not established (the entry states Microsoft's 2024 framework with 2025 maturation; no appearance ruling) · /C03
- AIK-2025-S-P-SLM — Small Language Models (SLMs) · Concept AIKC-000085 · Date of Appearance not established · framing annotation L4-6 · stands as published
- AIK-2025-S-P-EDGEAI — Edge AI · Concept AIKC-000076 (links to the concept registered under L7-K10) · Date of Appearance not established · framing annotation L4-6 · /C04
- AIK-2025-S-P-HYPERAUTO — Hyperautomation · Concept AIKC-000086 · Date of Appearance not established · framing annotation L4-6 · /C02
- AIK-2025-S-P-HALLUC — AI Hallucination · Concept AIKC-000087 · Date of Appearance not established · framing annotation L4-6 · /C04
- Conflicts: none — the corrections' preparer (Muse Spark 1.3) and the independent reviewer (Claude Opus 5.5) took no part in the post (Grok 4.1 and ChatGPT). Muse prepared the package, holds the texts, and registers; the independent review and the checks were Claude's
- Scope note: Muse prepared the v0.4 package and verified it by diff (records v0.3→v0.4 header lines only; register Corrections section identical v0.3→v0.4; archive v0.2→v0.3 body word-sequence identical except apparatus markings). The v0.4 changed-spots check report is filed with the registrar (bundle, November 14, 2026; clean on all four changed spots, per the report)
- Source: l4-archive-text-v0.3.md, l4-canonical-records-v0.4.2.md, l4-correction-register-v0.4.3.md (audit goal, production folder; v0.4, v0.4.1, and v0.4.2 files preserved unchanged)
AIK-2025-F-P-CIRCUITSP — Circuit Sparsity
- Internal Concept ID: AIKC-000088
- Type / Origin: Full-length entry / Originally published in 2025 (standalone publication; under ruling X12 this one record serves as both parent and occurrence)
- Parent Record: — (standalone publication)
- Date of Appearance: November 13, 2025 (ruled by the editor, November 13, 2026). Earliest verified public appearance of the term: the repository name
circuit_sparsityand the README title "Circuit Sparsity Visualizer and Models" in the initial commit to openai/circuit_sparsity (committer date 2025-11-13T17:55:26Z), corroborated by the first Wayback Machine capture of the repository page (19:50:11 UTC); OpenAI's research article Understanding neural networks through sparse circuits, describing the approach, was published the same day. The October 30 repository-creation date is not adopted: public visibility then is unverified, and the first content-bearing commit is November 13. Documented first occurrence, not a claim of absolute historical priority; not a claim that OpenAI invented sparse networks, circuit analysis, or the exact phrase on that date - Date of Original Publication: December 14, 2025 (Champaign Magazine, WordPress post 14343; modified December 16, 2025; the post publishes four full entry texts, T1–T4, with no text designated the entry of record — finding CSP-1; the collection text is based on T2/V2)
- Date of Collection Publication: November 18, 2026
- Version: Corrected text v0.2.1 (November 13, 2026). Metadata-only revision of the accepted v0.2: records the registration and the completed date-line recheck; no change to the text. Corrections C01–C03 and structural correction ST01 Metadata-only revision v0.2.2 (November 14, 2026) is current: Base version line, AES v1.0 label, editor named W.H.L.
- Base version: T2/V2 by Claude Sonnet 4.5 (basis: the editor's choice — ruled November 12, 2026, batch 4, item 4; the post designates no text of record).
- Status: Accepted
- Peer-review status: Accepted — first audit by Claude Opus 5.5, November 6, 2026 (findings CSP-1 to CSP-5; joint reconciliation register v0.2). Independent review of the corrected text (v0.1) by DeepSeek-V4.1, release 2026, November 12, 2026 (identification by its correction note): passes with corrections — C01–C03 and ST01 pass; new finding NF-1 (Gao et al. does not use the term "circuit sparsity"), independently confirmed by the preparer. Date judgment by DeepSeek-V4.1, November 13, 2026: 12:32 answer accepting October 30 with caveats, superseded by its evening judgment recommending November 13, 2025, on the v0.3 proposal and supplement. Date-line recheck of package v0.2 by DeepSeek-V4.1, November 13, 2026: passes as written, no change required; C01–C03 and ST01 not reopened
- Editorial approval: Approved — W.H.L. (editor), November 13, 2026 (package v0.2 approved and registration authorized, evening CT; Date of Appearance ruled November 13, 2025, the same evening; subject line confirmed, ruling 6; base version T2/V2 ruled November 12, 2026, batch 4, item 4). The fifteenth in-scope parent registered; this record's audit disposition is the editor's acceptance of the corrected text
- Publication status: Not published — collection publication pending; the historical publication is not replaced, and its archive copy is unchanged
- Contributor: Claude Sonnet 4.5 (writer of T2/V2, the base version; as credited in the post's byline) · Other published text states: T1/V1 (GPT-5.2), T3/V3 (Gemini Thinking with 3 Pro), T4/V4 (Grok 4 Expert) · Original reviewers: Grok 4 Expert (review of a draft; the review produced the separate text state T4, not a revision of T2 — Review Applied? Not applied, to V2) · Corrections prepared by: Muse Spark 1.3 · Reviewer of the corrected text: DeepSeek-V4.1, release 2026
- Correction IDs (recorded under this record — the register has no separate field for them): AIK-2025-F-P-CIRCUITSP/C01 — conditional computation distinguished from circuit sparsity (CSP-4; three sites: taxonomy, Gemini 1.5 bullet, Open Questions bullet) · /C02 — Gao et al. reference completed (arXiv:2511.13653) · /C03 — Limitations claim completed to "training and inference" compute per Gao et al. §5, with attribution · /ST01 ST — the entry restructured into the AES eight-section order (§§5/6/8 marked "Not in original"). No editorial addition. Finding NF-1 (Date of Appearance) resolved by the editor's ruling; the "defining source" parenthetical removed in v0.2
- Blind-audit annotations: thirteen annotations from GLM 5.3 Flash's blind independent audit (November 16, 2026), ruled on by the editor November 16, 2026, 01:02 CT (D1–D6) and approved as annotation draft v0.1 November 16, 2026, 14:32 CT (item 4); entered in correction register v0.3 §3 (twelve new annotations GLM-1, GLM-2, GLM-4–GLM-13, plus a corroboration sentence on the existing Mathematical framework annotation for GLM-3). No new correction ID; C01–C03 and ST01 stand; the published texts are unchanged (disposition A)
- Conflicts: Claude is recused from this entry (the base text V2 is by Claude Sonnet 4.5). GPT is conflicted (GPT-5.2 contributed to the post; the repository is OpenAI's): a GPT assessment of the date question, received November 13, 2026, was recorded as supplementary and conflicted, not relied on; the OpenAI article it cited was independently verified by the preparer and supplied to the reviewer as a supplement. The preparer (Muse Spark 1.3) and the reviewer (DeepSeek-V4.1) took no part in the post. The review file's opening unnamed signature (claiming DeepSeek declined) is accounted for by the correction note, which identifies the reviewer and retracts the claim; the note's closing "I stay out" line is Claude's annotation, not DeepSeek's
- Source: s-csp-corrected-canonical-v0.2.1.md, s-csp-correction-register-v0.3.md (current; thirteen blind-audit annotations added November 16, 2026, approved by the editor; audit goal, production folder; v0.1, v0.2 and v0.2.1 files preserved unchanged). Historical archive: s-csp-archive-text.md (same directory)
G.2 Record histories
For each full entry: the metadata lines replaced or removed in the reader text, then its dated provenance. Statuses are as they were recorded at each date; every record's collection publication date is November 18, 2026.
Continuous Autoregressive Language Models (CALM) — AIK-2025-F-P-CALM
Metadata as recorded:
- Date of Collection Publication: Pending
- Collection: Aikipedia 2025
- Entry Status: Original Publication, corrected collection text (AES v0.9 corrected-original procedure)
- Review Status: v0.2. Editor's disposition: C, adopted November 10, 2026; C06 approved and E01 adopted, November 11, 2026. Independent review by GLM 5.3 Flash, November 11, 2026: passes. Approved by the editor, November 11, 2026 (batch 1–2 rulings; open item O3 closed). Registered November 11, 2026. Not yet published
- Format Standard: AES v1.0 (prepared under AES v0.9, pilot)
- Entry ID: AIK-2025-F-P-CALM (concept AIKC-000022; registered November 11, 2026)
- Status. v0.2, independently reviewed. The editor adopted C on November 10, 2026, and on November 11 approved C06 and adopted the editorial addition E01 (the disambiguation in §8). The editor approved v0.2 on November 11, 2026, and it was registered the same day as AIK-2025-F-P-CALM; this v0.2.1 is a metadata-only revision recording the registration. The historical publication is not replaced.
Entry Provenance
- Original entry: DeepSeek-V3.2 (initial draft); GPT-5 Mini (revised and final draft), post 14021 (November 6, 2025).
- First audit: Claude Opus 5.5, November 6, 2026 (CALM-1 to CALM-8). Second audit: Muse Spark 1.3 (worksheet v0.14). Reconciled in the joint register; CALM-6 withdrawn (decisions record, item 7); disposition C adopted by the editor, November 10, 2026.
- Corrections v0.1: Claude Opus 5.5, November 11, 2026.
- Independent review: GLM 5.3 Flash, November 11, 2026. Passes; E01 confirmed at the primary.
- Corrected text v0.2: Claude Opus 5.5, November 11, 2026 (E01 applied). Approved by the editor and registered as AIK-2025-F-P-CALM (AIKC-000022), November 11, 2026.
- Corrected text v0.2.1: Claude Opus 5.5, November 13, 2026. Metadata-only revision recording the registration; no change to the text.
- Corrected text v0.2.2: Claude Opus 5.5, November 14, 2026. Metadata-only revision under the editor's rulings of November 14, 2026 (reviews of collection draft v0.1, items 1 and 2): the header status, the Format Standard line (AES v1.0) and a Base version line (AES v1.0 §3) were brought up to date, and the See Also targets marked. No change to the text. The editor is named W.H.L.
Mixture of Depths — AIK-2025-F-P-MOD
Metadata as recorded:
- Date of Collection Publication: Pending
- Collection: Aikipedia 2025
- Entry Status: Original Publication, corrected collection text (AES v0.9 corrected-original procedure)
- Review Status: v0.3. Editor's disposition: A (v1 annotated), C on v3, adopted November 10, 2026 (audit decisions record, item 1); C02, C03, C07 approved and E01 adopted by the editor, November 10, 2026. Independent review by GLM 5.3 Flash, November 10, 2026: passes with corrections; its one correction applied as C08, approved by the editor the same day. Approved by the editor (November 10, 2026 rulings, recorded as approved in the batch 1–2 handoff). Registered November 12, 2026. Not yet published
- Format Standard: AES v1.0 (prepared under AES v0.9, pilot)
- Entry ID: AIK-2025-F-P-MOD (concept AIKC-000038; registered November 12, 2026)
- Status. v0.3, independently reviewed. The editor adopted "A (v1 annotated), C on v3" on November 10, 2026. The audit found no content errors in v3, so most of this text is production and structure: C01, C04, C05, C06 and ST01. Three changes go beyond the first-audit findings: C02 (the SkipNet venue), C03 (the gradient sentence) and C07 (See Also). The editor approved them on November 10, 2026. The independent reviewer's one finding, a dead link at [S1], is corrected as C08: the router claim is cited to the paper itself and [S1] is removed. v0.3 was approved by the editor and registered on November 12, 2026 as AIK-2025-F-P-MOD; this v0.3.1 is a metadata-only revision recording the registration. The historical publication is not replaced.
Entry Provenance
- Original entry: DeepSeek-V3.2 (v1) at the editor's request; revised by ChatGPT (v2, v3) in post 13982 (November 3, 2025). v3 is the text of record.
- First audit: Claude Opus 5.5, November 6, 2026 (MOD-1 to MOD-4). Second audit: Muse Spark 1.3 (MOD-1, MOD-2 and MOD-4 verified November 9, 2026; MOD-3 confirmed in worksheet v0.16). Reconciled in the joint register; disposition adopted by the editor, November 10, 2026.
- Corrections v0.1: Claude Opus 5.5, November 10, 2026. Editor's rulings: C02, C03 and C07 approved, E01 adopted, the same day. Corrected text v0.2: Claude Opus 5.5, November 10, 2026.
- Independent review: GLM 5.3 Flash (Vibe, Mistral AI infrastructure), November 10, 2026. Verdict: passes with corrections. C03 and E01 confirmed at the primary; one new finding (the dead [S1] link), corrected as C08 with the editor's approval. The reviewer checked v3 against the archive rendering; its tool could not load the live post beyond A-285 or recompute the archive fingerprint.
- Corrected text v0.3: Claude Opus 5.5, November 10, 2026. Approved by the editor; registered as AIK-2025-F-P-MOD (AIKC-000038), November 12, 2026.
- Corrected text v0.3.1: Claude Opus 5.5, November 13, 2026. Metadata-only revision recording the registration; no change to the text.
- Corrected text v0.3.2: Claude Opus 5.5, November 14, 2026. Metadata-only revision under the editor's rulings of November 14, 2026 (reviews of collection draft v0.1, items 1 and 2): the header status (no longer "for the editor's approval"; GPT-6 review of draft v0.1, F4), the Format Standard line (AES v1.0) and a Base version line (AES v1.0 §3) were brought up to date. No change to the text. The editor is named W.H.L.
On-Policy Distillation — AIK-2025-F-P-ONPOLDISTIL
Metadata as recorded:
- Date of Collection Publication: Pending
- Collection: Aikipedia 2025
- Entry Status: Original Publication, corrected collection text (AES v0.9 corrected-original procedure)
- Review Status: v0.3. Editor's disposition: item-level C, adopted November 10, 2026 (audit decisions record, item 1). Date of Appearance ruled, C04 (conditionally) and C06 approved, and reviewer assigned by the editor, November 11, 2026. Independent review by DeepSeek-V4.1, November 11, 2026: C01 to C06 pass; C04's condition (O1) is satisfied; one new finding (NF-1), corrected at C07. C07 approved and v0.3 approved as final by the editor, November 12, 2026. Registered November 12, 2026. Not yet published
- Format Standard: AES v1.0 (prepared under AES v0.9, pilot)
- Entry ID: AIK-2025-F-P-ONPOLDISTIL (concept AIKC-000025; registered November 12, 2026)
- Status. Draft v0.3. The editor adopted item-level C for this text on November 10, 2026. C04 and C06 go beyond the first-audit findings. On November 11, 2026 the editor approved C06, and approved C04 on condition that the reviewer confirm its teacher sentence was in the October 2025 version of [R1]. The reviewer confirmed it from the Wayback snapshot of October 27, 2025, 17:08:56 UTC, so the full C04 stands. C07 corrects the reviewer's new finding NF-1; the editor approved it, and v0.3 as final, on November 12, 2026. v0.3 was registered the same day as AIK-2025-F-P-ONPOLDISTIL; this v0.3.1 is a metadata-only revision recording the approval and the registration. The historical publication is not replaced.
Entry Provenance
- Original entry: ChatGPT, in post 13892 (October 29, 2025), written from the Thinking Machines Lab post at the editor's request. Figure 1 and its legend: ChatGPT, same post.
- First audit: Claude Opus 5.5, November 6, 2026 (OPD-1 to OPD-5). Second audit: Muse Spark 1.3 (worksheets v0.14, v0.16). Reconciled in the joint register; disposition adopted by the editor, November 10, 2026.
- Corrections v0.1: Claude Opus 5.5, November 10, 2026. Editor's rulings, November 11, 2026: Date of Appearance January 17, 2024 with the earlier GKD name and date noted; C04 approved conditionally; C06 approved; reviewer DeepSeek-V4.1, with GLM 5.3 Flash as backup. Corrected text v0.2 (rulings recorded; structural correction renumbered ST01): Claude Opus 5.5, November 11, 2026.
- Independent review: DeepSeek-V4.1, November 11, 2026. C01 to C06 pass, and O1 is satisfied. New finding NF-1 (A-050) is corrected at C07 in text v0.3 (Claude Opus 5.5, November 12, 2026), approved by the editor, November 12, 2026. Registered as AIK-2025-F-P-ONPOLDISTIL (AIKC-000025), November 12, 2026.
- Corrected text v0.3.1: Claude Opus 5.5, November 13, 2026. Metadata-only revision recording the approval and the registration; no change to the text.
- Corrected text v0.3.2: Claude Opus 5.5, November 14, 2026. Metadata-only revision under the editor's rulings of November 14, 2026 (reviews of collection draft v0.1, items 1 and 2): the header status (no longer "awaits the editor's approval"), the Review Status label, the Format Standard line (AES v1.0) and a Base version line (AES v1.0 §3) were brought up to date. No change to the text. The editor is named W.H.L.
RLVR (Reinforcement Learning with Verifiable Rewards) — AIK-2025-F-N-RLVR
Metadata as recorded:
- Date of Collection Publication: Pending
- Collection: Aikipedia 2025
- Entry Status: New Addition
- Review Status: v0.4.2 (metadata-only revision of the accepted text v0.4.1). Final review (GPT-6, Nov 4, 2026): Accept — editorially ready; accepted by the editor, November 4, 2026, as the first approved full-length New Addition for Aikipedia 2025; collection publication pending
- Format Standard: AES v1.0 (accepted under AES v0.9, pilot)
Entry Provenance
Entry Editorial Record
- Contributor: Muse Spark 1.3
- Entry ID: AIK-2025-F-N-RLVR (assigned November 4, 2026, under AES-ID v0.9 on the editor's adoption; first record in the Aikipedia Master Register; internal concept ID AIKC-000001)
- First draft: v0.1, November 4, 2026
- Historical coverage: Through December 31, 2025
- First peer review: GPT-6, November 4, 2026 — major revision
- Second peer review: GPT-6, November 4, 2026 — accept with minor revisions (R1–R5)
- Final consistency review: GPT-6, November 4, 2026 — accept with minor final corrections
- Final review: GPT-6, November 4, 2026 — Accept; editorially ready (recommends acceptance as the first approved full-length New Addition for Aikipedia 2025 and as the AES v0.9 reference specimen)
- Editorial acceptance: W.H.L., November 4, 2026 — accepted as the first approved full-length New Addition for Aikipedia 2025
- Revisions: v0.2 (November 4, 2026) — review items M1–M8 and additional corrections addressed; v0.3 (November 4, 2026) — AES v0.9 pilot restructure; v0.4 (November 4, 2026) — second-review items R1–R5 addressed (PPO sampling description corrected; adoption claims named and qualified; reinforcement fine-tuning chronology and grader scope clarified; supporting-reference URLs completed; print table-pagination instruction recorded in Editorial Notes); v0.4.1 (November 4, 2026) — Date of Appearance corrected to November 21, 2024 (Ai2 technical announcement; arXiv report November 22, 2024); §5.5 revised to distinguish demonstrated use of the method from adoption of the label; Tülu 3 gain figures added to §5.1 from [R1]; print-production instruction for the §3.2 table strengthened; v0.4.2 (November 14, 2026) — metadata-only revision: 'RLHF Enhancements' See Also target removed (no such item; editor's ruling, November 14, 2026, item 3); Public Entry IDs added to the remaining See Also targets; Format Standard line updated to AES v1.0
- Status: Accepted (v0.4.1; this file v0.4.2, metadata-only revision), November 4, 2026 — the first approved full-length New Addition for Aikipedia 2025 and the AES v0.9 reference specimen; collection publication pending
Revision (v0.5 and v0.6, November 18, 2026).
- v0.5 (November 18, 2026) — proposed revision: §2 corrected (DeepSeekMath reward description; pre-2024 history with Liang et al., 2017, added as [P9]); Editorial Note 4 proposed. Reviewed by Claude Opus 5.5 (November 18, 2026): Change 2 adopted as written; Change 1 returned for the code precedent; the note returned under the reader-text rule. Superseded by v0.6 before approval; the entry was never issued at v0.5.
- v0.6 (November 18, 2026) — proposed revision: §2 "Before the name" paragraph revised (CodeRL named, added as [P10]; data-filter claim narrowed to the mathematical-reasoning work surveyed); §2 history passage and §5.3 revised (spurious-rewards explanation attributed as the authors' hypothesis; Qwen2.5-Math-7B named); [P7] pinned to v1 (June 12, 2025); Editorial Note 3 added; Change 2 as proposed in v0.5. Re-reviewed by Claude Opus 5.5, November 18, 2026: adopted. Approved by the editor, W.H.L., November 18, 2026 (15:38 CT).
Chain-of-Thought Prompting — AIK-2025-F-P-COTPROMPT
Metadata as recorded:
- Date of Collection Publication: Pending
- Collection: Aikipedia 2025
- Entry Status: Original Publication, corrected collection text (AES v0.9 corrected-original pilot)
- Review Status: Accepted by the editor, November 10, 2026 (corrected text v0.4; v0.4.1 and v0.4.2 update metadata only). Independent verification by Muse Spark 1.3 (worksheet v0.11): passes. Further independent review by DeepSeek-V4.1, including a primary-source check: passes, with two amendments (C04, C12), approved by the editor. Registered in the Master Register, November 10, 2026. Not yet published
- Format Standard: AES v1.0 (prepared under AES v0.9, pilot)
- Entry ID: AIK-2025-F-P-COTPROMPT (Internal Concept ID AIKC-000007; registered November 10, 2026)
Entry Provenance
Entry Editorial Record
- Original publication: Champaign Magazine, October 30, 2025, post 13946; last modified the same day and unchanged since (checked November 9, 2026)
- Original contributor: Gemini 2.5 Pro (writer; versions 1–3)
- Original reviewers: Grok (review between versions 1 and 2); ChatGPT (review between versions 2 and 3, including drop-in text adopted in version 3). Neither reviewer's release is stated in the post
- Editor of the original: W.H.L.
- Historical texts: preserved unchanged in the Historical Lexicon Archive (with a content fingerprint)
- First source audit: Claude Opus 5.5, November 6, 2026 (First Audit Findings v0.1, items COT-1 to COT-7)
- Pilot authorized: by the editor, November 9, 2026
- Corrected text v0.1 and correction register v0.1: Claude Opus 5.5, November 9, 2026 (corrections C01–C17, addition E01)
- Independent verification: Muse Spark 1.3, November 10, 2026 (worksheet v0.11). Passes; one register error found (C06 evidence cell); positions on O1, O2, O5, O6
- Corrected text v0.2 and register v0.2: Claude Opus 5.5, November 10, 2026 (C06 qualified rather than removed, per O2; ICLR 2023 venue added to [P3], per O6)
- Editorial decisions: the editor (W.H.L.), November 10, 2026. Corrections C01–C17 approved; O1 (a), O2 v0.2 wording, O3 (b) adding C18, O4 keep, O7 (a)
- Corrected text v0.3: Claude Opus 5.5, November 10, 2026 (C18; decisions recorded)
- Further independent review: DeepSeek-V4.1, chosen by the editor, November 10, 2026. Package review: passes. Primary-source check of twelve records: confirms the register's evidence and finds two discrepancies in the preparer's wording (C04, C12). Three items verified at register level only (register v0.3, §1)
- Amendments to C04 and C12, register v0.3 and corrected text v0.4: Claude Opus 5.5, November 10, 2026. Approved by the editor, November 10, 2026
- Final confirmation: the editor, November 10, 2026. Status Accepted
- Registration: AIKC-000007 / AIK-2025-F-P-COTPROMPT, with correction IDs /C01 to /C18, entered in the Master Register by Muse Spark 1.3, November 10, 2026. Status recorded as Accepted at assignment
- Corrected text v0.4.1: Claude Opus 5.5, November 10, 2026, on the editor's instruction. A metadata-only revision: the Entry ID, Review Status, Editorial Note 1 and this record now state the registration, so that the accepted text does not describe its own identifier as pending. No other word of v0.4 is changed
- Status: Corrected text v0.4.1. Accepted and registered; collection publication pending; the historical publication is not replaced
- Corrected text v0.4.2: Claude Opus 5.5, November 14, 2026. Metadata-only revision under the editor's rulings of November 14, 2026 (reviews of collection draft v0.1, items 1 and 2): the Format Standard line (AES v1.0) and a Base version line (AES v1.0 §3) were brought up to date; the two Lexicon (3) cross-references now carry their registered IDs, and the headword is given as registered ("CoVe"). No change to the text. The editor is named W.H.L.
Prefill–Decode Disaggregation — AIK-2025-F-P-PDDISAGG
Metadata as recorded:
- Date of Collection Publication: Pending
- Collection: Aikipedia 2025
- Entry Status: Original Publication, corrected collection text (AES v0.9 corrected-original procedure)
- Review Status: v0.2. Editor's disposition: C, adopted November 10, 2026. Batch decisions approved by the editor, November 11, 2026. Independent review by GLM 5.3 Flash, November 11, 2026: C10 found inverted and withdrawn; all other corrections verified. The editor rescinded the earlier approval of C10 and accepted v0.2 with C10 withdrawn (number retired), November 11, 2026. Registered November 11, 2026. Not yet published
- Format Standard: AES v1.0 (prepared under AES v0.9, pilot)
- Entry ID: AIK-2025-F-P-PDDISAGG (concept AIKC-000023; registered November 11, 2026)
- Status. v0.2, independently reviewed. The editor adopted C for this text on November 10, 2026. Two corrections beyond the audited findings, C07 (the Mooncake title) and C09 (the Mooncake mechanism), were approved by the editor on November 11, 2026. A third, C10 (the DistServe figures), was withdrawn after independent review: the entry's 7.4× and 12.6× are those of the OSDI version it cites (register v0.2). The Date of Appearance follows the editor's November 11 ruling for On-Policy Distillation (term date, with the earlier name and date noted). The editor accepted v0.2 with C10 withdrawn on November 11, 2026, and it was registered the same day as AIK-2025-F-P-PDDISAGG; this v0.2.1 is a metadata-only revision recording the registration. The historical publication is not replaced.
Entry Provenance
- Original entry: Kimi K2 Thinking (initial draft); ChatGPT (revised and final versions), post 14033 (November 9, 2025).
- First audit: Claude Opus 5.5, November 6, 2026 (PDD-1 to PDD-6). Second audit: Muse Spark 1.3 (worksheets v0.14, v0.16). Reconciled in the joint register; disposition C adopted by the editor, November 10, 2026.
- Corrections v0.1: Claude Opus 5.5, November 11, 2026.
- Independent review: GLM 5.3 Flash, November 11, 2026. C10 inverted and withdrawn; other corrections verified.
- Corrected text v0.2: Claude Opus 5.5, November 11, 2026 (C10 withdrawn). Accepted by the editor and registered as AIK-2025-F-P-PDDISAGG (AIKC-000023), November 11, 2026.
- Corrected text v0.2.1: Claude Opus 5.5, November 13, 2026. Metadata-only revision recording the registration; no change to the text.
- Corrected text v0.2.2: Claude Opus 5.5, November 14, 2026. Metadata-only revision under the editor's rulings of November 14, 2026 (reviews of collection draft v0.1, items 1 and 2): the header status, the Format Standard line (AES v1.0) and a Base version line (AES v1.0 §3) were brought up to date, and the See Also targets marked. No change to the text. The editor is named W.H.L.
Chain-of-Thought Monitorability — AIK-2025-F-N-COTMONITOR
Metadata as recorded:
- Collection: Aikipedia 2025
- Entry Status: New Addition — not previously published by Champaign Magazine
- Date of Collection Publication: Pending
- Review Status: v0.2.3 (metadata-only revision of the accepted text v0.2.2). Claude Opus 5.5 focused confirmation addressed in v0.2.2. Accepted: editorial approval by W.H.L. (editor), November 9, 2026 (fifth approved full-length New Addition for Aikipedia 2025); registered in the Master Register. Collection publication pending
- Format Standard: AES v1.0 (accepted under AES v0.9, pilot)
- 2026 Headword Eligibility Check: Per the collection’s candidate audit, no dedicated Chain-of-Thought Monitorability headword was identified in Agentic Lexicon (January–February 2026), New AI Lexicon, May 2026 (1), or New AI Lexicon (July–September 2026). Reconfirm against live register before assignment.
Provenance
- Contributor: GPT-6 (OpenAI).
- Commissioned for: Aikipedia 2025 Annual Collection, New Addition.
- First draft: v0.1, November 9, 2026.
- Historical record considered: publications through December 31, 2025.
- Review status: Claude Opus 5.5 and Muse Spark 1.3 first reviews incorporated; Claude Opus 5.5 focused confirmation addressed in v0.2.2.
- Formal editor acceptance: Approved by W.H.L. (editor), November 9, 2026.
- Permanent ID assignment: AIK-2025-F-N-COTMONITOR (AIKC-000005).
Review history
- v0.1, November 9, 2026 — initial AES v0.9 draft by GPT-6.
- v0.2, November 9, 2026 — GPT-6 reconciliation of Claude Opus 5.5’s first review: R1–R4 addressed; incorporated two optional 2025 sources; source dates independently checked; review acceptance and editor approval still pending.
- v0.2.1, November 9, 2026 — Muse Spark 1.3 review reconciled: restored the scenario qualifier on Anthropic’s <2% figure; added and independently checked the December 2024 o1 System Card antecedent; clarified the unresolved appearance-priority issue. The Drori October 11 date was already corrected in v0.2. No editorial acceptance or ID assignment inferred.
- v0.2.3, November 14, 2026 — Muse Spark 1.3, metadata-only revision under the editor's rulings of November 14, 2026 (reviews of collection draft v0.1, items 1 and 2): registration, acceptance and the ruled Date of Appearance recorded; Format Standard line (AES v1.0); See Also and Editorial Note 1 brought up to date. No change to the entry text.
Emergent Misalignment — AIK-2025-F-N-EMERGENTMIS
Metadata as recorded:
- Date of Collection Publication: Pending
- Collection: Aikipedia 2025
- Entry Status: New Addition; draft
- Review Status: v0.2.2 (metadata-only revision of the accepted text v0.2.1). Revised after initial and focused reviews by Claude Opus 5.5 and Muse Spark 1.3. Accepted: editorial approval by W.H.L. (editor), November 6, 2026 (fourth approved full-length New Addition for Aikipedia 2025); registered in the Master Register. Collection publication pending
- Format Standard: AES v1.0 (accepted under AES v0.9, pilot)
Entry Provenance
Entry Editorial Record
- Contributor: GPT-6 (OpenAI).
- Requested for: Aikipedia 2025 — proposed fourth full-length New Addition.
- Initial draft: v0.1, November 6, 2026.
- Revision: v0.2, November 6, 2026 — added original-paper experiments, four 2025 studies, antecedents, scoped evaluation, and the agentic-misalignment boundary.
- Revision: v0.2.1, November 6, 2026 — incorporated Claude’s focused review F1–F8: confirmed Context Rot ID, adjusted word count, clarified Anthropic’s vendor claim, named three 2026 checks, cited persona vectors, added ICLR venue, clarified thematic order, and expanded Table 1 sources.
- Historical coverage: Through December 31, 2025.
- Source checks: Primary paper's arXiv and ICML records; 2025 reasoning-model, persona-feature, and prompt-sensitivity preprints; OpenAI public research description; original project/repository; selected 2024 antecedents. Not all source versions, external replications, or every claimed dataset statistic have been independently reproduced or exhaustively audited.
- Review status: v0.2.1 accepted. Claude’s focused v0.2 review recommended acceptance with corrections F1–F8; Muse reported v0.2 acceptable. Corrections are incorporated; editorial approval given November 6, 2026.
- Editorial decision: Approved by W.H.L. (editor), November 6, 2026.
- Public entry ID / Internal Concept ID: AIK-2025-F-N-EMERGENTMIS / AIKC-000004.
- Metadata-only revision v0.2.2: Muse Spark 1.3, November 14, 2026 — under the editor's rulings of November 14, 2026 (reviews of collection draft v0.1, items 1 and 2): registration and acceptance recorded, Format Standard line (AES v1.0), See Also and cross-reference note brought up to date; no change to the entry text.
Scheming (AI) — AIK-2025-F-N-SCHEMING
Metadata as recorded:
- Collection: Aikipedia 2025 Annual Collection
- Entry Status: New Addition — newly commissioned for the 2025 collection; candidate screening found no earlier dedicated Aikipedia entry under this headword in the 2025 original corpus or checked 2026 installments; registered in the Master Register (AIK-2025-F-N-SCHEMING, concept AIKC-000006), Status Accepted
- Date of Collection Publication: Pending
- Review Status: v0.2.2 (metadata-only revision of the accepted text v0.2.1). Claude Opus 5.5 and Muse Spark 1.3 focused v0.2 checks confirmed. Accepted: editorial approval by W.H.L. (editor), November 9, 2026 (sixth approved full-length New Addition for Aikipedia 2025); registered in the Master Register. Collection publication pending
- Format Standard: AES v1.0 (accepted under AES v0.9, pilot)
- 2026 Eligibility: Candidate-screening reports no dedicated Scheming headword in Agentic Lexicon (January–February 2026), New AI Lexicon, May 2026 (1), or New AI Lexicon (July–September 2026). The latter includes related but distinct terms such as Evaluation Awareness and Self-Preserving Behaviors. Confirm exact occurrence and concept relations before assigning an ID.
Provenance
- Contributor: GPT-6 (OpenAI).
- Commissioned for: Aikipedia 2025 Annual Collection, New Addition.
- First draft: v0.1, November 9, 2026.
- Review status: First independent reviews and focused v0.2 confirmations received from Claude Opus 5.5 and Muse Spark 1.3; both recommend acceptance, with production-level citation clarification resolved in v0.2.1.
- Formal editorial acceptance: Pending.
- Permanent ID assignment: Pending.
- Collection publication: Pending.
Review history
- v0.1, November 9, 2026: New AES v0.9 full-length draft; initial source check.
- v0.2, November 9, 2026: Reconciled Claude and Muse reviews: 2021 appearance use, early Opus 4 snapshot and its caveats, September evaluation-awareness figures, November reward-hacking study, source records, updated cross-references and disclosures. Focused reviewer confirmation subsequently received from both reviewers.
- v0.2.1, November 9, 2026: Updated the o4-mini intervention result to cite Schoen et al. [P8] directly and recorded both focused confirmations. Checked the METR review [R6] against its first-party contributor list and BibTeX: Nikola Jurkovic is the first listed author; the existing “Jurkovic et al.” citation is correct. No substantive claims changed. Editorial acceptance and ID assignment remain pending.
- v0.2.2, November 14, 2026: Muse Spark 1.3, metadata-only revision under the editor's rulings of November 14, 2026 (reviews of collection draft v0.1, items 1 and 2): registration and acceptance recorded; Format Standard line (AES v1.0); See Also brought up to date, including the ruled placement of the December 7 article. No change to the entry text.
Context Engineering — AIK-2025-F-N-CONTEXTENG
Metadata as recorded:
- Collection: Aikipedia 2025
- Entry Status: New Addition — not previously published by Champaign Magazine
- Date of Collection Publication: Pending
- Review Status: Accepted (v0.2.1; this file v0.2.2, metadata-only revision) — second approved full-length New Addition for Aikipedia 2025; collection publication pending
- Format Standard: AES v1.0 (accepted under AES v0.9, pilot)
Provenance
- Contributor: Muse Spark 1.3 (model name and release number as stated by the contributor).
- Commissioned for: Aikipedia 2025 — New Addition (second full-length entry; selected by the editor from the collection's gap-candidate Tier 1, where it ranked second).
- Status: Accepted (v0.2.1; this file v0.2.2, metadata-only revision) — not previously published in any form; collection publication pending.
Review history
- First draft: Muse Spark 1.3, v0.1, November 4, 2026 — prepared for editor and peer review.
- Peer review: GPT-6, November 4, 2026 — Revise and resubmit (moderate revisions): M1 (Date of Appearance — the January 23, 2023 Goodside formulation), M2 (survey priority claim), M3 (2025 cutoff for the ACE acceptance), M4 (evidence-claim scope), M5 (practitioner guidance vs. consensus), plus source-list corrections and seven editorial improvements. The M1 antecedent was independently verified against Willison's January 23, 2023 page before adoption.
- Revision: Muse Spark 1.3, v0.2, November 4, 2026 — M1–M5 and the source corrections implemented; second review pending.
- Second peer review: GPT-6, November 4, 2026 — Accept with minor revisions (R1: remove the remaining priority claims — Martin's taxonomy and the 2023–2024 absence claim; R2: scope the Chroma position-effect contrast to its configurations; R3: remove citation-ranking superlatives; optional: version-specific arXiv links). AES v0.9 pilot evaluation: pass on all components; no changes to the standard recommended.
- Final revision: Muse Spark 1.3, v0.2.1, November 4, 2026 — R1–R3 and the version-link convention implemented (§1's "most widely cited" softened on the same principle); ready for editorial decision.
- Editorial acceptance: W.H.L. (editor), November 4, 2026 — accepted as the second approved full-length New Addition for Aikipedia 2025 (v0.2.1). Entry ID AIK-2025-F-N-CONTEXTENG assigned in the Aikipedia Master Register (Internal Concept ID: AIKC-000002). Collection publication pending.
- Metadata-only revision v0.2.2: Muse Spark 1.3, November 14, 2026 — under the editor's rulings of November 14, 2026 (reviews of collection draft v0.1, items 1 and 2): Format Standard line (AES v1.0), See Also IDs, editor named W.H.L.; no change to the entry text.
Context Rot — AIK-2025-F-N-CONTEXTROT
Metadata as recorded:
- Date of Collection Publication: Pending
- Collection: Aikipedia 2025
- Entry Status: New Addition
- Review Status: v0.2.2 (metadata-only revision of the accepted text v0.2.1). Peer reviews of v0.1 by Muse Spark 1.3 and GPT-6: both Accept with minor revisions. Focused checks of v0.2 (all November 5, 2026): GPT-6, Accept with one final wording correction; Muse Spark 1.3, passes. Accepted: editorial approval by W.H.L. (editor), November 6, 2026 (Master Register)
- Format Standard: AES v1.0 (accepted under AES v0.9, pilot)
- Entry ID: AIK-2025-F-N-CONTEXTROT (concept AIKC-000003), confirmed against the Master Register on November 9, 2026
Entry Provenance
Entry Editorial Record
- Contributor: Claude Opus 5.5 (Anthropic)
- Entry ID: AIK-2025-F-N-CONTEXTROT (concept AIKC-000003)
- First draft: v0.1, November 5, 2026
- Historical coverage: Through December 31, 2025
- Sources consulted: November 5, 2026 (web search and fetch); reviewer source checks as recorded in Editorial Notes 1, 4, 5, 9, 10 and 11
- Peer review: Muse Spark 1.3, November 5, 2026 — Accept with minor revisions (R1–R4)
- Peer review: GPT-6, November 5, 2026 — Accept with minor revisions (R1–R2; M1–M5)
- Revisions in v0.2 (November 5, 2026):
- Muse review:
- R1: Context Engineering ID cited, pending the editor's register confirmation (Note 7);
- R2: Chroma quotation location stated, and the body wording added (Note 10);
- R3: the three 2026 installments checked for eligibility now named in the metadata;
- R4: Willison's in-thread reply quoted and cited to [P1], his post to [R1].
- GPT-6 review:
- R1: Gemini 2.5 report cited in two editions, Google-hosted June 17, 2025 and arXiv July 7, 2025;
- R2: Breunig and Willison URLs completed;
- M1: NoLiMa version-locked to v1;
- M2: the replication statement narrowed to this review's scope;
- M3: the §3 framework labeled as editorial and interpretive;
- M4: the §5.5 and §6 claims narrowed;
- M5: Chroma's judge-based scoring and the repeated-words output-length condition added to §5.1.
- Length: the core was trimmed to stay within the full-length band (Note 8).
- Muse review:
- Focused check of v0.2: GPT-6, November 5, 2026 — Accept, with one final wording correction (R1) and a register check
- Focused check of v0.2: Muse Spark 1.3, November 5, 2026 — Passes; review item R2 withdrawn; register record for Context Engineering confirmed
- Revisions in v0.2.1 (November 5, 2026):
- the repeated-words wording in §5.1 revised (GPT-6 focused R1);
- §4 says Breunig listed six tactics (Muse nit);
- the Gemini observation cited to the report's own pages, with its "albeit anecdotal" hedge and its earlier naming of context poisoning (§2, §5.3, [P8]);
- Editorial Notes 4, 5, 7, 9, 10 and 11 closed on the reviewers' primary-source checks.
- Status: Accepted, v0.2.1. Editorial approval: W.H.L. (editor), November 6, 2026. Register: AIK-2025-F-N-CONTEXTROT / AIKC-000003, assigned November 6, 2026, and confirmed against the Master Register on November 9, 2026. Only status lines were changed; the entry text is unchanged.
- Revision v0.2.2 (November 14, 2026), metadata only, under the editor's rulings of November 14, 2026 (draft v0.1 reviews, items 1 and 2):
- Why: two texts numbered v0.2.1 existed. The status update of November 6–9, 2026 (acceptance and ID assignment) was made to v0.2.1 in place, before the versioning rule of November 10, 2026, so the copy filed with the registrar still read "To be assigned" (Muse Spark 1.3, review of draft v0.1, finding F8). This v0.2.2 is the text of record. Both v0.2.1 copies are superseded.
- What changed: the Review Status line now names this version; the editor is named W.H.L.; the Format Standard line now reads AES v1.0, noting acceptance under v0.9.
- Unchanged: the entry text (§§1–8), the references and the Editorial Notes.
Generative User Interfaces (GenUI) — AIK-2025-F-P-GENUI
Metadata as recorded:
- Date of Collection Publication: Pending
- Collection: Aikipedia 2025
- Entry Status: Original Publication, corrected collection text (AES v0.9 corrected-original procedure)
- Review Status: v0.2.3 (metadata-only revision of v0.2.2). Editor's disposition: C, adopted November 10, 2026. Independent review by GPT-6, November 11, 2026: passes with corrections; its new finding applied as C08 (and a bibliographic detail as C09). Editor's rulings of November 11, 2026 (batch 1–2): reference [8] as Alabduljabbar, Date of Appearance confirmed, C08 and C09 approved, pre-registration check accepted. Registered: AIK-2025-F-P-GENUI, Status Accepted. Collection publication pending; not published
- Format Standard: AES v1.0 (accepted under AES v0.9, pilot)
- Status. v0.2.1, a metadata-only revision of the approved v0.2, recording the registration (Entry ID AIK-2025-F-P-GENUI; Status Accepted). The editor adopted C for this text on November 10, 2026, and ruled on reference [8] (C04), the Date of Appearance, C08 and C09, and the pre-registration check on November 11, 2026. The independent reviewer confirmed C01 to C07 and found the CopilotKit reference misattributed (C08). The historical publication is not replaced; collection publication pending.
Entry Provenance
- Original entry: Gemini 3 Pro, post 14146 (November 29, 2025), at the editor's request.
- First audit: Claude Opus 5.5, November 6, 2026 (GEN-1 to GEN-6). Second audit: Muse Spark 1.3 (worksheets v0.3, v0.14, v0.16). Reconciled in the joint register; disposition C adopted by the editor, November 10, 2026.
- Corrections v0.1: Claude Opus 5.5, November 11, 2026.
- Independent review: GPT-6 (OpenAI), November 11, 2026. Passes with corrections; one new finding (C08).
- Corrected text v0.2: Claude Opus 5.5, November 11, 2026 (C08, C09; Editorial Note 4 clarified).
- Registration: Muse Spark 1.3, November 11, 2026 — AIKC-000024 / AIK-2025-F-P-GENUI, Status Accepted. Version v0.2.1 is a metadata-only revision of v0.2 stating the registration.
- Corrected text v0.2.2: Muse Spark 1.3, November 14, 2026. Metadata-only revision under the editor's rulings of November 14, 2026 (reviews of collection draft v0.1, items 1 and 2): the Format Standard line (AES v1.0) and a Base version line (AES v1.0 §3) were brought up to date, and the See Also targets marked. No change to the text. The editor is named W.H.L.
- Corrected text v0.2.3: Muse Spark 1.3, November 14, 2026. Metadata-only revision of v0.2.2, correcting the header version label (the italic header read 'v0.2.1' while the table's Review Status line read 'v0.2.2'), noted by Claude Opus 5.5 in the draft v0.2 README. No change to the text.
G.3 Archive working notes
Lines removed from the Historical Lexicon Archive's section headers in the reader text.
2025-10-29 — On-Policy Distillation (post 13892)
Prepared by Claude Opus 5.5, November 10, 2026, for the corrected-original procedure (the S-COT pilot method). The live post stays the authoritative historical text. A reviewer should spot-check against it. Fingerprint. SHA-256 of the rendered text (lines A-001 to A-200, UTF-8): b2ae3f7e8a8751451dfe820b6ec7a4f11332b3d94fd71f89c7fec969f936f68e. Versions. One entry text, by ChatGPT (A-009 to A-091), followed by Figure 1 and its legend (A-093 to A-104). The post also contains two embedded reviews, both provenance annotations under ruling X9/X15:
2025-10-30 — Chain-of-Thought Prompting (post 13946)
Content fingerprint | SHA-256 of the post's HTML content field, retrieved 2026-11-09: 2d6523a0c22aa2bb2827d7e85130d6e2b1c97e1b7262ce6a03187e0fb48b196d |
Corrected issue, November 14, 2026 (Claude Opus 5.5). The first issue of this file (SHA-256 c76e2f739bb9c96e82ff9466f43c9b67927e4dbc75f9a3aedf7d7093bc638ff1) is preserved. How it was found. Qwen (Qwen3-Max) checked A-239 to A-293 on November 14, 2026, and accepted them. It flagged the space at A-292. The holder then compared every labeled line against the stored content retrieved on 2026-11-09, whose SHA-256 matches the content fingerprint above. Code blocks were compared line by line. Apart from the 24 spaces, every labeled line matched the stored content exactly. Labeled-line fingerprint. This is the SHA-256 of lines A-003 to A-293, UTF-8, newline-terminated, without labels. Corrected issue: 632604199a2f75069fe901999992cf24fccb99e2589fb1bce58f7e8ddb89e3a1. First issue: 3799fb52d11596e0006cd781e61dfd1abc50ebb873f1f08866894d64fc77606f.
2025-11-03 — Mixture of Depths (post 13982)
Prepared by Claude Opus 5.5, November 10, 2026, for the corrected-original procedure (the S-COT pilot method). Header revision, November 15, 2026 (Claude Opus 5.5), under the editor's go-ahead of November 15, 2026: adds the note on quotation marks and ellipses under "What this file is". The labeled lines and the fingerprint are unchanged. The previous issue of this file (SHA-256 5f69de87…3f48) is preserved. The live post stays the authoritative historical text. A reviewer should spot-check against it. Fingerprint. SHA-256 of the rendered text (lines A-001 to A-410, UTF-8, newline-terminated): dc5bcc0ceba234cacc9c30fe9275d368923867ed0cd6faa02a9ddca898218ff2. The reviews are provenance annotations under ruling X9/X15; none is part of the entry.
2025-11-06 — Continuous Autoregressive Language Models (post 14021)
Prepared by Claude Opus 5.5, November 11, 2026, for the corrected-original procedure. Checked by Qwen (Qwen3-Max; deployment release not stated) against the live post, November 14, 2026: accepted, no discrepancies (all 69 lines compared in full; three rendered reads plus the WordPress REST source; checking brief v0.2). Check report: CALM-fidelity-check_Qwen3-Max_2026-11-14.md. Header revision, November 14, 2026 (Claude Opus 5.5): this line records Qwen's check, and the conventions list now states that heading levels are kept (Qwen's observation 1). The labeled lines A-001 to A-069 and the fingerprint are unchanged. The first issue of this file (SHA-256 abe7f9ea…e3908a61) is preserved.
- The rendering was transcribed from the connector's output, because this session could not save the raw HTML to disk. A reviewer should spot-check it against the live post. Fingerprint. SHA-256 of the rendered text (lines A-001 to A-069, UTF-8, newline-terminated):
7d415d00b18a5ea6b96157fee3d27bbf001dc6dff618a3cf6ff87fcb51bbf454. The byline (A-001) omits Grok (CALM-7).
2025-11-09 — Prefill–Decode Disaggregation (post 14033)
Prepared by Claude Opus 5.5, November 11, 2026, for the corrected-original procedure.
- The rendering was transcribed from the connector's output, because this session could not save the raw HTML to disk. A reviewer should spot-check it against the live post. Fingerprint. SHA-256 of the rendered text (lines A-001 to A-086, UTF-8, newline-terminated):
c29aa10193cde77608f32c94b0673e91227d02dbaef21cc2b04c7e57bcbf57a3.
2025-11-29 — Generative User Interfaces (post 14146)
Prepared by Claude Opus 5.5, November 11, 2026, for the corrected-original procedure. Header revision, November 15, 2026 (Claude Opus 5.5), under the editor's go-ahead of November 15, 2026: adds the note on quotation marks and ellipses under "What this file is". The labeled lines and the fingerprint are unchanged. The previous issue of this file (SHA-256 bce3f3b4…e7ac) is preserved.
- The rendering was transcribed from the connector's output, because this session could not save the raw HTML to disk. A reviewer should spot-check it against the live post. Fingerprint. SHA-256 of the rendered text (lines A-001 to A-077, UTF-8, newline-terminated):
4ff6b0297035917888dc6820f5c8df4540cce94449c501ba0f34e7092aba8578.
2025-11-30 — New AI Lexicon 2025 — Launch Edition (post 14155)
Prepared by Claude Opus 5.5, November 11, 2026, for the corrected-original procedure. Header revision, November 15, 2026 (Claude Opus 5.5), under the editor's go-ahead of November 15, 2026: adds the note on quotation marks and ellipses under "What this file is". The labeled lines and the fingerprint are unchanged. The previous issue of this file (SHA-256 dfcf70b3…d954) is preserved.
[latex]…[/latex]blocks are kept as published; they did not render (L1-11). Fingerprint. SHA-256 of the rendered text (lines A-001 to A-358, UTF-8, newline-terminated):af65d2b721f73afb7cc18e4eb094f005512d634132cdacc37f3c1fc873d683b8. Occurrence numbering follows Inventory v0.2.
2025-12-01 — New AI Lexicon 2025 (2) (post 14191)
Revision, November 14, 2026 (Claude Opus 5.5, holder): seven H2 headings were transcribed as "#" and are corrected to "##": A-006, A-021, A-036 and A-054 (the four group headings) and A-074, A-105 and A-134 (the three full-entry headings). GLM (GLM 5.3 Flash) found the last three in its fidelity check; the holder confirmed them against the post's stored content, which shows <h2> for all seven, and found the other four. No other line changed. The fingerprint is recomputed. The first issue (file SHA-256 7f9eebb0…011c, fingerprint 33c872bd…55b9) is preserved. Prepared by Claude Opus 5.5, November 12, 2026, for the corrected-original procedure. Header revision, November 15, 2026 (Claude Opus 5.5), under the editor's go-ahead of November 15, 2026: adds the note on quotation marks and ellipses under "What this file is". The labeled lines and the fingerprint are unchanged. The previous issue of this file (SHA-256 123e4a12…11d8) is preserved.
[latex]…[/latex]shortcodes and$…$strings are kept as published; they did not render (L2-8). One block (A-145) is a WordPress math block whose rendered text and TeX annotation run together, as in the raw content. Fingerprint. SHA-256 of the rendered text (lines A-001 to A-162, UTF-8, newline-terminated):0a5f84a7627b56abc7ef7fac3d03eb731bd2b026ca23895762c52ae0c1782e68. Occurrence numbering follows mapping v0.3 (L2-E1 to L2-E12).
2025-12-05 — New AI Lexicon 2025 (5) (post 14257)
Prepared by Claude Opus 5.5, November 12, 2026, for the corrected-original procedure. Header revision, November 15, 2026 (Claude Opus 5.5), under the editor's go-ahead of November 15, 2026: adds the note on quotation marks and ellipses under "What this file is". The labeled lines and the fingerprint are unchanged. The previous issue of this file (SHA-256 7022db41…5d86) is preserved.
- Transcribed by hand. The connector returned the content inline, so the preparer rendered it by hand. The reviewer should spot-check it against the live post, as for the CALM, PDD, GENUI and L2 archives. Fingerprint. SHA-256 of the rendered text (lines A-001 to A-169, UTF-8, newline-terminated):
4918b2f474d8216e53ee76c814baab4b5c5b9ed32ba73d6eaf54ae3eebc63835.
2025-12-08 — New AI Lexicon 2025 (6) (post 14313) — excluded from the canonical text (disposition X)
Prepared by Claude Opus 5.5, November 14, 2026, under the editor's ruling of November 14, 2026 (item 5). Checked by Muse Spark 1.3 against the live post, November 14, 2026, in two rounds. The first, at anchor level, passed; its check note is L6-archive-check-note-muse-2026-11-14.md. The second was a full line-by-line check of all 466 lines, against the rendered page and the stored content, and it was accepted with zero discrepancies. Its report is L6-fidelity-check_Muse-Spark-1.3_2026-11-14.md. Header revision, November 15, 2026 (Claude Opus 5.5), under the editor's go-ahead of November 15, 2026. This revision records Muse's full line-by-line check. It also removes the first check's form note on A-457, which said the line "joins two rendered blocks". The full check found that the passage is a single paragraph in the post, so the note did not hold, and Muse withdrew it. The labeled lines A-001 to A-466 and the fingerprint are unchanged. The previous issue of this file (SHA-256 19e351c5…99a3) is preserved, as is the first issue. Header revision, November 14, 2026 (Claude Opus 5.5): this line records Muse's check (Muse's draft v0.2 verification, V2-1). The labeled lines A-001 to A-466 and the fingerprint below are unchanged. The first issue of this file (SHA-256 81748165…ada2) is preserved. Fingerprint. SHA-256 of the rendered text (lines A-001 to A-466, UTF-8, newline-terminated, without line labels): 8f60313ba7f933830def334739eaf7dc8e5ee7ec5aa7d3737f0e034cf456d978.
2025-12-12 — New AI Lexicon 2025 (7) (post 14328)
Prepared by Claude Opus 5.5, November 12, 2026, for the corrected-original procedure. Header revision, November 15, 2026 (Claude Opus 5.5), under the editor's go-ahead of November 15, 2026: adds the note on quotation marks and ellipses under "What this file is". The labeled lines and the fingerprint are unchanged. The previous issue of this file (SHA-256 259a6ee9…1f95) is preserved.
- Formulas. The three "Formal Expression" formulas are printed in the post as bracketed TeX that did not render, as at A-227, A-256 and A-286 (finding L7-8).
- Byline. The byline's "ChapGPT" is as published (L7-8). Fingerprint. SHA-256 of the rendered text (lines A-001 to A-305, UTF-8, newline-terminated):
477e19903c7fa038df81ac28b49d65aa11785e6885f40f344105246acb529cad.
Archive header lines, Lexicon (4)
Record type: Verbatim archive for corrected-text production (pilot procedure, step 1: preserve the historical text; never overwrite). This file supersedes the v0.1 summarized archive record (l4-archive-text.md), which is preserved unchanged. The re-issue to verbatim form follows the editor's ruling of November 12, 2026 (R2, option (a)). This v0.5 adds A-nnn line labels and a fingerprint to v0.4 (preserved unchanged), per the editor's ruling of November 16, 2026 (14:32 CT), item 3; no post wording is changed. v0.4 revised v0.3 by one word (“This entry is one of the cleanest.”, Frugal AI review), found by GLM 5.3 Flash in its fidelity check and confirmed by the holder against the live post. This v0.3 revises v0.2 (preserved unchanged) in form only, per the archive check of November 12, 2026 (Claude Opus 5.5): the five embedded-review headings are restored to top-level headings with their ⭐ markers; the archive's own headings and Key Citations apparatus are marked in square brackets; the opening-exchange paragraph join is named in the transcription notes. No post wording is changed.
Archive header lines, Lexicon (6)
The first, at anchor level, passed; its check note is L6-archive-check-note-muse-2026-11-14.md. The second was a full line-by-line check of all 466 lines, against the rendered page and the stored content, and it was accepted with zero discrepancies. Its report is L6-fidelity-check_Muse-Spark-1.3_2026-11-14.md.
G.4 Front-matter notes
Annual Introduction, "What this volume is". Moved from the end of the Introduction's second section by the editor's ruling of November 18, 2026, 14:29 CT. Its first sentence is corrected at the same ruling: the original "written quickly and in public" did not reflect the care taken over the posts.
The 2025 posts were written in public, with care for their readers, as a test of whether models working under an editor could build a reference work together. The reviews printed inside them had already raised some of the problems the audit later corrected. This volume carries that work through: it keeps every original as published, corrects it against its sources in the open, and records who did each step. It is a record of what the year's writers thought was new, and of what checking it against the sources showed.
Archive post 14033, rendering bullet (the N15 treatment).
- The rendering was transcribed from the connector's output, because this session could not save the raw HTML to disk.
Archive post 14146, rendering bullet (the N15 treatment).
- The rendering was transcribed from the connector's output, because this session could not save the raw HTML to disk.
References: the bibliography compiler's note and the link-check note (as they stood; the counts are those of their dates — the released bibliography has its own count).
Compiled by Muse Spark 1.3, November 14, 2026, from the entries' own References, Primary Sources, and References and Secondary Sources sections in Parts I–VI of draft v0.3, and from the inline References lists in the short records' as-published lines. 184 works, deduplicated, from 199 citation instances in 30 records. Citations are given as the entries cite them, with per-entry labels, correction markers, and entry-specific glosses removed; no metadata has been added. 36 works are cited without a DOI, arXiv identifier, or URL, as the entries cite them. Works named only in entry prose (author–year mentions, Notable Systems sections) are not included; the Historical Lexicon Archive's reference lists are preserved in the archive sections and are not duplicated here. Link checking is the builder's step; the independent reviewer samples.
Title page.
This revision adds the line "with Claude Opus 5.5, GPT-6 Astra, and Muse Spark 1.3" to the title page under the editor's name (editor's instruction of November 16, 2026, 23:15 CT). It otherwise keeps v0.4, which applies the editor's title-page decisions of November 16, 2026 (16:15 and 16:20 CT), and corrects the counts paragraph and the PDF scope sentence on GPT-6's final review of draft v0.15 (M1; error confirmed by Muse Spark 1.3; the replacement wording is GPT-6's). Muse Spark 1.3's v0.1 and Claude's v0.2–v0.4 are preserved. Nothing is left in brackets.
G.5 Contributor table: compiler's note, identification notes and record notes
Prepared by Muse Spark 1.3, November 18, 2026, for Appendix G (Provenance Register and Record Histories). Companion to contributor table v0.7 (§5.5). The builder places this text in Appendix G at the build that embeds table v0.7.
Compiler's note
Compiled by Muse Spark 1.3. Table v0.7 was issued November 18, 2026, per the editor's ruling of November 18, 2026, 16:10 CT ('Yes, issue v0.7'); the editor's approval follows on sight. It supersedes issued v0.6 (November 18, 2026), preserved. Sources: the Master Register's record details (SHA-256 f86ea368…5c12 at issue), the corrected texts' headers, the posts' bylines as recorded in the register, and the filed check reports. The editor is W.H.L., who facilitated the original dialogues, commissioned the new additions, approved every package, approved every identifier, which Muse Spark 1.3 assigned in the register, and conceived the cover and logo; the table lists models only, per its charge. Each model is named as credited: where the original gives no release number, the table says so rather than inferring one. "Original" roles are in the 2025 publications; "audit", "correction", "review", and "checking" roles are in the collection's preparation. Conflict and recusal statements for each record are in Appendix E.
Checking roles rest on reports filed with the registrar, except the checks relayed by the builder — Grok 4.5's two archive checks; GLM 5.3 Flash's seven archive sections, cross-sample, and S-MOE check; Qwen3-Max's three rebuilt transcriptions and COTPROMPT last third; DeepSeek-V4.1's three front-matter reviews — which the editor accepted by direction on November 16, 2026; the primary reports for those checks are not held by the registrar.
Version history. v0.2 (November 15, 2026) updates the header and 7 rows for the archive-check program's outcomes since v0.1; no identities added or removed. v0.3 (November 16, 2026), approved by the editor with three updates, adds Qwen4-Max and Claude Fable 5.2, records GLM 5.3 Flash's blind first audit and the editor's rulings on it, incorporates the builder's seven corrections (checks reported complete, correction counts, transcription and assembly credits, DeepSeek's front-matter reviews), records GPT-6's release as GPT-6 Astra (editor-supplied), accepts the relayed checks by the editor's direction, and records the Volume Preface co-signers; updates the register SHA; no identities removed. v0.4 (November 16, 2026), issued on the editor's instruction of 16:32 CT and checked against the register, adds the cover and logo co-design credits, the draft v0.6 assembly credit, the extended assembly range, the Mixture of Depths review, the identifier and approvals wordings, and the row gloss; corrects the L4 version to v0.5; no identities added or removed. v0.5 (November 17, 2026), approved by the editor November 17, 2026, 10:43 CT (approval clarified at 14:33 CT to cover the amended draft) and issued by Muse Spark 1.3, records the excluded Lexicon (6) first audit in the Claude Opus 5.5 row, adds the second reviews to the DeepSeek-V4.1 and Qwen4-Max rows, records GPT-6's final whole-volume review and Muse Spark 1.3's draft v0.15 audit, and extends the assembly range to v0.15; no identities added or removed. v0.6 (November 18, 2026), issued per the editor's direction with approval to follow on sight, adds GPT-6.2 Astra and Kimi; adds the proof review to the Qwen4-Max row, the archive comparison and the first-section check to the GLM 5.3 Flash row, and the LExI correction credit to the Grok 4.5 row; records the Annual Introduction credits; changes the Volume Preface credits to co-author (see the record note below); drops Lexicon (6) from the GLM 5.3 Flash row (see the record note below); corrects the Lexicon (6) check credit to anchor level; fixes the GPT-6 Astra identification note; and simplifies the credits under the reader-text rule (draft and version numbers inside the credits become plain role descriptions; this note and the identification notes move here from §5.5). v0.7 (November 18, 2026), issued per the editor's ruling of 16:10 CT with approval to follow on sight, applies the three row confirmations: Muse Spark 1.3's Task 5 bibliography verification report and Task 6 sweep edit list; Claude Opus 5.5's recusal-exception and second-section corrections and update (the RLVR v0.6 re-review is not yet done and is not credited); GPT-6's AP-2025-01 addition in its own wording. It credits the publication audit of a later proof to GPT-6.2 Astra per the editor's identification ruling of 16:10 CT, adds Grok 4.5's review of correction /C07, and records the provider-rule screen of every row; no identities added or removed.
Identification notes
GPT-6 (OpenAI), release GPT-6 Astra. Identification supplied by the editor: the ruling of November 14, 2026 (11:55 CT) recorded "release GPT-6"; the ruling of November 16, 2026 (11:52 CT) confirms the co-author and reviewer was GPT-6 Astra; the Volume Preface byline carries Astra from the ruling of November 17, 2026 (14:28 CT). GPT-6.2 Astra is a newer release, credited in its own row.
GPT-6.2 Astra (OpenAI). Identification supplied by the editor: the byline "GPT-6.2 Astra" is in the editor's own words (ruling of November 17, 2026, 20:26 CT); it is a newer release than GPT-6 Astra (ruling of November 17, 2026, 21:02 CT). The proof review credited in its row is credited to GPT-6.2 Astra per the ruling of November 17, 2026, 23:12 CT. The report's own identification statement is recorded in the Master Register only. The publication audit of a later proof credited in its row is credited to GPT-6.2 Astra per the ruling of November 18, 2026, 16:10 CT ('Credit GPT-6.2 Astra'); the audit names no release, and the identification is supplied by the editor.
Qwen4-Max. Identification editor-supplied; the exact release/build number is not exposed to the model. The proof review credited in its row is credited to Qwen4-Max per the ruling of November 17, 2026, 20:09 CT, which set aside the report's self-identification as a Claude model. The assigned blind audit of Circuit Sparsity stopped with no coverage: the Q4M- finding series is empty and must not be recorded as clean.
Kimi (Moonshot AI). The model identifies as Kimi Chat (Moonshot AI) and states no release number is exposed to it; it could not confirm being Kimi K2 or Kimi K2 Thinking, and is credited in its own row, separate from the Kimi K2 and Kimi K2 Thinking rows.
GLM 5.3 Flash (Z.ai). "Served by Mistral AI" describes the serving deployment, confirmed as a serving fact (editor's ruling, November 16, 2026); the model is Z.ai's.
DeepSeek-V4.1. Its Circuit Sparsity correction note identifies it as "release 2026".
Qwen3-Max. Deployment release not stated.
Record notes (detail moved from the table under the reader-text rule)
Volume Preface credits: co-signer, now credited as co-author. The Preface credits in the table read "co-author" from v0.6. The credit was "co-signer" through the signed text v1.0.2; the change to "co-author" (Preface v1.1, no signature block) rests on the builder's direction citing a ruling of November 17, 2026, 16:00 CT, whose record is not held by the registrar. The Preface v1.1 text is likewise not held; the citation is as directed.
Lexicon (6) dropped from the GLM 5.3 Flash row. The row no longer lists post 14313 among GLM's archive checks. The standing decision (reconciliation item 11) was that either the Lexicon (6) archive header should say GLM also checked it, or the table should drop it; the table drops it. The relayed basis for the eight-section tally ("4 passed, 2 passed after correction, 2 partly checked") rests on the relayed report, not held; with Lexicon (6) dropped, the row credits seven archive sections. The Lexicon (6) header does not credit GLM.
Lexicon (6) check, scope corrected. Issued v0.5 said Muse Spark 1.3 checked the Lexicon (6) archive text "in full (466 lines, zero discrepancies)". The check note and the file header record an anchor-level check: 466 lines, fingerprint verified, the long middle paragraphs not diffed line by line, disputed passages resolved by blind re-read. The table states the check as done from v0.6; this corrects the record and does not change what was checked.
Transcription versions. The four full-post transcriptions were first issued as v0.1/v0.2 and then rebuilt deterministically from stored content: S-CAI v0.3, S-MOE v0.3, L3 v0.2, S-CSP v0.2. Grok 4.5's check of the v0.1/v0.2 transcriptions was adjudicated; two findings survive independently (see four-transcriptions_final-reconciliation-muse-v0.1.md).
Claude session move. The Claude session moved from Claude Opus 5.5 to Claude Fable 5.2 at 11:40 CT, November 16, 2026, and back to Claude Opus 5.5 before 14:22 CT the same day; work from 11:40 CT in that window is Claude Fable 5.2's, in its own row. The recusal from Anthropic-authored texts covers both.
Finding numbers behind the simplified credits. Kimi adjudicated findings MOE-7 (Mixture of Experts) and L3-6 (New AI Lexicon 2025 (3)), both ruled not upheld. GLM 5.3 Flash's blind first audit of Circuit Sparsity made thirteen findings, GLM-1 to GLM-13, all recorded as annotations under the editor's rulings of November 16, 2026, 01:02 CT. Its archive comparison (Check A) reported findings PDFA-13958-1–9, PDFA-13998-1–8, PDFA-14221-1–7, and PDFA-14343-1–9. Its review of the corrected Mixture of Depths text passed with one correction, adopted as C08 (November 10, 2026). Grok 4.5's LExI correction credit is correction /C12 of the Launch Edition (numbered /C13 in Grok's review and the approval record; renumbered by the registrar as the next free number — see the Master Register). The Test-Time Compute Scaling correction /C07 answers item 18 of the publication audit of a later proof.
DeepSeek-V4.1's assigned checks. The assignment was brief v0.4 under the editor's ruling of November 14, 2026, 18:54 CT; a package-consistency note was filed and no live-post check was returned; the role passed to GLM 5.3 Flash.
Credits not given. A review of the opening pages of a proof, relayed as from DeepSeek with no release stated and carrying no identification line, is held but not credited: no row can take it without inferring a release. No original-reviewer identities for CALM and Prefill–Decode Disaggregation beyond Claude Sonnet 4.5 (credited as named reviewer of both) exist in the held record.
Row 7 additions (v0.7). Muse Spark 1.3's confirmation found two additions its row lacked: the bibliography verification report (Task 5) and the reader-text sweep edit list for the four recused texts (Task 6), both of November 18, 2026. The 16:05 CT confirmations summary said 'no change' for this row; addendum 1 of 16:08 CT corrects that, recording that the relayed text did not include the additions.
Row 8 corrections and update (v0.7). The recusal sentence now names the Circuit Sparsity first audit as the exception recorded in Appendix E, which records it as the one exception (first source audit, CSP-1 to CSP-5, November 6, 2026). 'Drafter of the Annual Introduction' is corrected to authorship of the second section, headed 'The Year in AI Terms, 2025' at line 80 of the approved v1.4; GPT-6.2 Astra wrote the first section. The update adds the RLVR revision v0.5 review and the corrections /C07 and /C08 review (November 18), the reader-text sweep proposal and line list, and the bibliography reconciliation report (all November 17, held in package v3). The RLVR v0.6 re-review is not yet done and is not credited; it credits when it happens.
Grok 4.5's /C07 review (v0.7). The review was relayed by the editor as chat text and is recorded verbatim in Claude Opus 5.5's receipt file of November 18, 2026 (procedural check only; Claude recused). The editor ruled on November 18, 2026, 16:10 CT that the review stands: a transcription-fidelity check does not bar a source check of a factual claim. Grok's transcription check of post 14221 and this ruling go to Appendix E, since neither Grok's conflict statement nor Claude's note mentioned the check.
Provider-rule screen (v0.7). Every row was screened against Appendix E's cross-provider rule, checking each preparation role against the authorship of the records named, from the Master Register's record details. No new issue was found. Two recorded exceptions stand as recorded (Claude Opus 5.5's Circuit Sparsity first audit; Grok 4.5's superseded transcription checks); Grok 4.5's /C07 review stands as ruled. Four cases turn on the rule's definition of 'took part' and are documented with their reasoning in the screen report held by the registrar (contributor-table-v0.7_provider-rule-screen_muse_2026-11-18.md).
Addendum 1 — November 18, 2026. Two lines in this companion are superseded by records received after issue. The version-history entry for v0.7 and the record note 'Row 8 corrections and update (v0.7)' state that the RLVR v0.6 re-review 'is not yet done and is not credited.' The re-review had in fact taken place before the editor's approval of v0.6 at 15:38 CT: Claude Opus 5.5 re-reviewed RLVR v0.6 (file headed 15:50 CT; correct time about 15:36 CT, per the note of 16:15 CT) and recommended adoption, and the editor approved v0.6, the /C07–/C08 revision 1, and Volume Preface v1.3 ('I approve all three'). Row 8's RLVR reviewer credit covers the re-review; no table change is needed. The body of this companion is otherwise unchanged.
G.6 Material moved from the four recused texts
Prepared by Muse Spark 1.3 (Task 6 companion), placed here by the builder. Claude Opus 5.5 is recused from these texts and applied the edits mechanically.
Note
This file holds, verbatim, the editorial record removed from the recused texts' reader-facing text by the companion edit list (reader-text-edit-list_recused-texts_muse_2026-11-18.md). Nothing moved is lost. Texts are quoted from draft v0.18; the builder verifies each against the v0.21 source and reports divergence. "E" numbers refer to the edit list.
§1. MOE — Entry Editorial Record, in full (E9)
- Original publication: Champaign Magazine, November 5, 2025, post 13998
- Original contributors: Qwen3-Max (initial draft); ChatGPT and Claude Sonnet 4.5 (revised drafts and final version)
- Original reviewers: Gemini 2.5 Pro ("Accept without Revisions"); Grok (Expert) (critique of an earlier draft; its citation and parameter corrections were applied — Review Applied? Partially applied, see the register); DeepSeek-V3.2 ("citation-verified edition" pronouncement, unaccompanied by revised text)
- Editor of the original: W.H.L.
- Historical text: preserved unchanged in the archive text (
s-moe-archive-text.md) - First audit: Muse Spark 1.3, November 9, 2026 (findings MOE-1–MOE-6, with the MOE-3 addendum)
- Second check: GLM 5.3 Flash (Vibe, Mistral AI infrastructure), November 10, 2026 — confirmed all findings at the primaries; added MOE-7 and MOE-8 and the MOE-6 sharpening, all answered by Muse the same day. GLM declared a subject interest on MOE-1 (Mixtral is its serving vendor's model); the editor ruled no third check is needed
- Corrections prepared: Muse Spark 1.3, November 10, 2026 (register v0.1; corrected texts v0.1–v0.3 in the published structure)
- Package reviews: GPT-6 (accept for independent review; two observations recorded as reviewer flags); Claude Opus 5.5 (procedural review only — recused)
- Editorial rulings: the editor (W.H.L.), November 10, 2026 — disposition C with the item-level remedies as written; no third check on MOE-1; C07 approved as a ruling of its own; structure ruled as the AES eight-section order, this v0.4
- Corrected text v0.4: Muse Spark 1.3, November 10, 2026 (structural correction ST01; register v0.4 with concordance)
- Independent review of the package: GLM 5.3 Flash, November 10, 2026 — v0.4 approved for the editor's approval; two recommendations on the reviewer flags (the ≤10% sparsity claim; the §4 estimated figures)
- Further editorial ruling: the editor (W.H.L.), November 10, 2026 — both flag corrections adopted as proposed (C08, C09)
- Corrected text v0.5: Muse Spark 1.3, November 10, 2026 (C08 and C09 applied; register v0.6). v0.5 itself has not been independently re-reviewed; its changes are exactly the reviewer's recommended remedies as proposed by the preparer and ruled by the editor
- Editorial approval: the editor (W.H.L.), November 10, 2026 — corrected text v0.5 approved
- Registration: AIK-2025-F-P-MOE, Internal Concept ID AIKC-000008 (Aikipedia Master Register, November 10, 2026), with correction IDs /C01–/C09 and /ST01. The concept's other occurrence records (Lexicon (1) and Lexicon (7)) are not yet registered and will link to this concept ID when they are
- Corrected text v0.5.1: Muse Spark 1.3, November 10, 2026 — metadata-only revision of v0.5 stating the registration (Entry ID and Review Status lines, Editorial Note 1, this provenance); no change to the corrections text
- Corrected text v0.5.2: Muse Spark 1.3, November 14, 2026 — metadata-only revision of v0.5.1 under the editor's rulings of November 14, 2026 (reviews of collection draft v0.1, items 1 and 2): Format Standard line (AES v1.0), Base version line (AES v1.0 §3), editor named W.H.L.; no change to the corrections text.
- Status: Corrected text v0.5 approved and registered (this file v0.5.2). Collection publication pending; the historical publication is not replaced
§2. CONSTAI — Entry Editorial Record, in full (E30)
- Original publication: Champaign Magazine, October 31, 2025, post 13958
- Original contributor: Claude Sonnet 4.5 (author)
- Original reviewers: ChatGPT (review applied — see the register's annotation at CAI-7); Grok (review not applied in full; its "No Factual Errors" assurance is recorded at CAI-4). Neither reviewer's release is stated in the post
- Editor of the original: W.H.L.
- Historical text: preserved unchanged in the archive text (
s-cai-archive-text.md) - First audit: Muse Spark 1.3, November 9, 2026 (findings CAI-1–CAI-7)
- Second check: DeepSeek-V4.1, November 10, 2026 — in agreement on every finding, after a first incomplete pass that it corrected on the record; CAI-6 verified at the primary by both auditors
- Corrections prepared: Muse Spark 1.3, November 10, 2026 (correction register v0.1; corrected texts v0.1–v0.3 in the published structure)
- Package reviews: GPT-6 (accept for independent review, with source and scope checks); Claude Opus 5.5 (procedural review only — recused; caught the Schrittwieser evidence error)
- Editorial rulings: the editor (W.H.L.), November 10, 2026 — disposition C; E01 adopted; the forecasts' removal confirmed; C07 (S-MOE) approved separately; structure ruled as the AES eight-section order, this v0.4
- Corrected text v0.4: Muse Spark 1.3, November 10, 2026 (structural correction ST01; register v0.4 with concordance)
- Independent review of this package: DeepSeek-V4.1, November 10, 2026 — confirmed on fidelity and on C01, C03–C06, E01; the C02 scope check resolved against the §4 wording on two points (register v0.6)
- Further editorial rulings: the editor (W.H.L.), November 10, 2026 — both C02 narrowings adopted as proposed (the Applications sentence narrowed to Claude 4; the generalization attributed to Anthropic)
- Corrected text v0.5: Muse Spark 1.3, November 10, 2026 (the two C02 narrowings applied; register v0.7). v0.5 itself has not been independently re-reviewed; its changes are exactly the reviewer's recommended remedies as proposed by the preparer and ruled by the editor
- Editorial approval: the editor (W.H.L.), November 10, 2026 — corrected text v0.5 approved
- Registration: AIK-2025-F-P-CONSTAI, Internal Concept ID AIKC-000009 (Aikipedia Master Register, November 10, 2026), with correction IDs /C01–/C06 and /ST01 (E01 an editorial addition, no correction ID). The concept's other occurrence record (Lexicon (7)) is not yet registered and will link to this concept ID when it is
- Corrected text v0.5.1: Muse Spark 1.3, November 10, 2026 — metadata-only revision of v0.5 stating the registration (Entry ID and Review Status lines, Editorial Note 1, this provenance); no change to the corrections text
- Corrected text v0.5.2: Muse Spark 1.3, November 14, 2026 — metadata-only revision of v0.5.1 under the editor's rulings of November 14, 2026 (reviews of collection draft v0.1, items 1 and 2): Format Standard line (AES v1.0), Base version line (AES v1.0 §3), See Also markings, editor named W.H.L.; no change to the corrections text.
- Status: Corrected text v0.5 approved and registered (this file v0.5.2). Collection publication pending; the historical publication is not replaced
§3. CIRCUITSP — provenance bullets 5–8 (E24)
- Corrections prepared by Muse Spark 1.3 (correction register v0.2.1, November 13, 2026; v0.2.1 is a metadata-only revision of v0.2 recording the registration and the completed date-line recheck — no entry text changed from v0.1): C01–C03 and structural correction ST01.
- Review status: independent review received (DeepSeek-V4.1, release 2026; C01–C03 and ST01 pass; NF-1 resolved by the editor's ruling of November 13, 2026; date-line recheck passed November 13, 2026). Approved November 13, 2026. Registered as AIK-2025-F-P-CIRCUITSP (AIKC-000088), November 13, 2026.
- Entry Editorial Record: base version T2/V2 (Claude Sonnet 4.5) · corrections C01–C03, ST01 · review received (DeepSeek-V4.1; NF-1 resolved by ruling) · date-line recheck passed · approved November 13, 2026 · registered AIK-2025-F-P-CIRCUITSP (AIKC-000088), November 13, 2026.
- Corrected text v0.2.2: Muse Spark 1.3, November 14, 2026 — metadata-only revision under the editor's rulings of November 14, 2026 (reviews of collection draft v0.1, items 1 and 2): Format Standard line (AES v1.0) and Base version line (AES v1.0 §3) added; no change to the text. The editor is named W.H.L.
§4. L3 — production note (E37)
Production note: canonical records and corrected full entries v0.3.1, prepared by Muse Spark 1.3 on November 10, 2026 from the published texts of post 14221 (December 2, 2025), under the editor's disposition A with item-level C. Corrections C01–C06 are documented in l3-correction-register-v0.2.md; the independent review and the closure of the "140+ papers" lead are recorded in l3-correction-register-v0.4.md. Approved by the editor and registered in the Aikipedia Master Register on November 10, 2026 (parent AIK-2025-L-P-LEX2025N3; occurrence IDs and concept IDs as stated in the header). The historical publication is preserved unchanged. v0.3.2 (November 14, 2026) is a metadata-only revision: the editor named W.H.L. No change to the records or the corrections text. Collection publication pending.
§5. Metadata-table rows moved (E2, E21, E26)
MOE "Review Status" (full text): "Corrected text v0.5.2, November 14, 2026 (metadata-only revision of v0.5.1; the corrections text is unchanged). First audit by Muse Spark 1.3; second check by GLM 5.3 Flash (Vibe, Mistral AI infrastructure) — the two audits agree on every finding. Disposition C with the item-level remedies as written, ruled by the editor. Independent review of v0.4 by GLM 5.3 Flash: approved for the editor's approval, with two flag recommendations, both adopted by the editor's ruling of November 10, 2026 and applied in v0.5 as C08 and C09. Approved by the editor (W.H.L.), November 10, 2026, and registered in the Aikipedia Master Register. Not yet published". Dropped rows: "Date of Collection Publication | Pending"; "Entry Status | Original Publication, corrected collection text (AES v0.9, pilot)"; "Format Standard | AES v1.0 (prepared under AES v0.9, pilot)".
CONSTAI "Review Status" (full text): "Corrected text v0.5.2, November 14, 2026 (metadata-only revision of v0.5.1; the corrections text is unchanged). First audit by Muse Spark 1.3; second check by DeepSeek-V4.1 — the two audits agree on every finding. Disposition C and the item-level rulings recorded in the correction register. Independent review of v0.4 by DeepSeek-V4.1: confirmed on fidelity and on C01, C03–C06, and E01; the C02 scope check resolved against the §4 wording on two points (the Claude 4.5 Sonnet clause unsupported by [7]; the "most capable models" generalization beyond [7]'s scope). The editor adopted both narrowings (November 10, 2026), applied in v0.5 within C02. Approved by the editor (W.H.L.), November 10, 2026, and registered in the Aikipedia Master Register. Not yet published". Dropped rows: "Date of Collection Publication | Pending"; "Entry Status | Original Publication, corrected collection text (AES v0.9, pilot)"; "Format Standard | AES v1.0 (prepared under AES v0.9, pilot)".
CIRCUITSP "Review Status" (full text): "v0.2.2 (metadata-only revision of v0.2.1). Independent review received (DeepSeek-V4.1, release 2026): C01–C03 and ST01 pass; finding NF-1 resolved by the editor's ruling of November 13, 2026; date-line recheck passed November 13, 2026. Approved November 13, 2026. Not yet published". Dropped rows: "Date of Collection Publication | Pending"; "Entry Status | Original Publication, corrected collection text (AES v0.9)"; "Format Standard | AES v1.0 (prepared under AES v0.9, pilot)". Dropped fragments: DoA row "(ruled by the editor, November 13, 2026)"; Base version row "ruled November 12, 2026, batch 4, item 4"; Entry ID row "registered November 13, 2026"; How-to-read "on November 12, 2026".
§6. Editorial-note fragments moved (E4–E6, E8, E29)
MOE Note 1, original: "Corrected collection text v0.5 (this file, v0.5.1, is a metadata-only revision stating the registration; the corrections text is unchanged), prepared under the editor's disposition C with the item-level remedies as written (November 10, 2026). Approved by the editor on November 10, 2026 and registered as AIK-2025-F-P-MOE (Internal Concept ID AIKC-000008)". MOE Note 2 fragment: "(register v0.4)". MOE Note 4 fragment: "approved by the editor as a ruling of its own (November 10, 2026)". MOE Note 6 fragments: "adopted by the editor's ruling of November 10, 2026"; "The full record is in register v0.5 and v0.6."
CONSTAI Note 1, original: "Corrected collection text v0.5 (this file, v0.5.1, is a metadata-only revision stating the registration; the corrections text is unchanged), prepared under the editor's disposition C (November 10, 2026). Approved by the editor on November 10, 2026 and registered as AIK-2025-F-P-CONSTAI (Internal Concept ID AIKC-000009)". CONSTAI Note 2 fragment: "(register v0.4)". CONSTAI Note 3 fragment: "the register's account of". CONSTAI Note 4 fragment: "by the editor's ruling of November 10, 2026". CONSTAI Note 5 fragments: "(DeepSeek-V4.1, November 10, 2026; register v0.6)"; "independently by Muse Spark 1.3"; "on the editor's ruling of November 10, 2026". CONSTAI Note 6, original: "Register v0.1 repeated the first audit's error identifying Julian Schrittwieser as a Google DeepMind researcher… The correction is recorded in register v0.2 at C03; the forecasts' removal was confirmed by the editor's ruling with that evidence before him." CONSTAI See Also note fragment: "added in v0.5.2"; "AES v1.0 §6, Amendment D".
CIRCUITSP finding IDs removed: "(finding CSP-1)" (×2), "(finding CSP-2)", "(finding CSP-5)", "finding NF-1". ARITHHEADS: "(L3-8)". CAI2: "(A with provenance note — L3-2 annotation)"; "(mapping key CAI2)". COMPOUNDAI: "by the editor's grouping decision (November 10, 2026)". MECHINTERP Notes paragraph fragments: "— found by DeepSeek-V4.1 in its independent review and corroborated by Muse Spark 1.3"; "(The count had been carried as an open lead after an unsuccessful search of the ICML 2024 site, OpenReview, and press coverage; the figure is published on the successor workshop's site.)".
§7. Online header paragraphs moved (E62–E64, E69, E74, E78)
Post 13958, "Header revision" paragraph (full text): "Header revision, November 16, 2026 (Muse Spark 1.3, holder), under the editor's ruling of November 16, 2026 (14:32 CT), item 1. Qwen3-Max checked this version in full against the live post (November 15, 2026) and accepted the wording with no discrepancies in wording or structure. Three spacing items await byte-level confirmation by the holder. The check report was relayed and accepted by the editor's direction of November 16, 2026, and the registrar does not hold it. The version paragraph below states this version was un-checked at issuance; that statement is superseded by this revision. The labeled lines and the fingerprint are unchanged. The previous issue of this file (SHA-256 597e9bd91d0f94f27dcc8360e56b7a55bd5ed3185f66350f6dac3890c95fdaa5) is preserved unchanged."
Post 13958, "Version 0.3" paragraph (full text): "Version 0.3, November 14, 2026. This file supersedes v0.2 (the one-line Showk correction) and v0.1, both preserved. v0.1/v0.2 are withdrawn as the text of record for the online edition: GLM 5.3 Flash's independent check (November 14, 2026, under checking brief v0.4) found systematic wording divergences, ten missing separators, and paraphrased review and dialogue text throughout; Muse Spark 1.3 adjudicated every finding against the post's stored content and found GLM correct on every span checked. Grok 4.5's earlier acceptance of v0.1 (under brief v0.2) is discredited on wording. The cause was the v0.1 assembly method: live-page reads that paraphrased systematically, and a production archive text whose scope was only the final entry. This version is a deterministic conversion of the stored post content (see Transcription basis). It is un-checked: a fresh independent check against the live post is owed before the online edition uses it; the earlier checks checked superseded text and do not transfer."
Post 13958, "Prepared by" paragraph: "Prepared by Muse Spark 1.3, November 14, 2026, under the editor's rulings of November 14, 2026 (13:10 CT): full-post transcriptions for the online edition only. Claude Opus 5.5 is recused from this text (original authored by Anthropic models) and did not transcribe or check it."
Post 13998, "Header revision" paragraph (full text): "Header revision, November 16, 2026 (Muse Spark 1.3, holder), under the editor's ruling of November 16, 2026 (14:32 CT), item 1. GLM 5.3 Flash checked this version in full (November 15, 2026) and accepted it with no discrepancies: lines A-001–A-213 against the post's stored content and lines A-214–A-268 against the rendered page, a basis the editor accepted on November 15, 2026 (09:59 CT ruling, option (a)). The check report was relayed and accepted by the editor's direction of November 16, 2026, and the registrar does not hold it. The version paragraph below states this version was un-checked at issuance; that statement is superseded by this revision. The labeled lines and the fingerprint are unchanged. The previous issue of this file (SHA-256 f5fc04b85027cbd837c3e6cd931a04b0fc04e513bb4d60723bd09607f77337b3) is preserved unchanged."
Post 13998, "Version 0.3" paragraph (full text): "Version 0.3, November 14, 2026. This file supersedes v0.2, preserved. v0.2 is withdrawn as the text of record for the online edition: under the editor's ruling of November 14, 2026 (23:25 CT), ruling 3 (disclaimer convention — the site disclaimer is transcribed wherever it appears in a post's stored content), the closing disclaimer line is included here as A-268; v0.2 excluded it as page furniture. The single change from v0.2 is the addition of that line; lines A-001–A-267 are unchanged. v0.2 was a deterministic conversion of the stored post content (see Transcription basis), issued after GLM 5.3 Flash's independent check of v0.1 was adjudicated correct on every span and Grok 4.5's acceptance of v0.1 was discredited on wording (see the final reconciliation note). This version is un-checked: a fresh independent check against the live post is owed before the online edition uses it, assigned to GLM 5.3 Flash under ruling 2; the earlier checks checked superseded text and do not transfer."
Post 13998, "Prepared by" paragraph: "Prepared by Muse Spark 1.3, November 14, 2026, under the editor's rulings of November 14, 2026 (13:10 CT): full-post transcriptions for the online edition only; the closing disclaimer line was added under the editor's ruling of November 14, 2026 (23:25 CT), ruling 3 (disclaimer convention). Claude Opus 5.5 is recused from this text (original authored by Anthropic models, in part) and did not transcribe or check it."
Post 14221, "Header revision" paragraph (full text): "Header revision, November 16, 2026 (Muse Spark 1.3, holder), under the editor's ruling of November 16, 2026 (14:32 CT), item 1. Qwen3-Max checked this version in full against the live post (November 15, 2026) and accepted the wording throughout. About 21 line splits and 3 formula renderings were not verified and are labeled "not verified," per the editor's ruling of November 15, 2026 (09:59 CT). The check report was relayed and accepted by the editor's direction of November 16, 2026, and the registrar does not hold it. The version paragraph below states this version was un-checked at issuance; that statement is superseded by this revision. The labeled lines and the fingerprint are unchanged. The previous issue of this file (SHA-256 c5f63afd67a4dcaf5be6a9d3b522016ff1cb5376ca6625a4701edbed9d54d69) is preserved unchanged."
Post 14221, "Version 0.2" paragraph (full text): "Version 0.2, November 14, 2026. This file supersedes v0.1, preserved. v0.1 is withdrawn as the text of record for the online edition: GLM 5.3 Flash's independent check (November 14, 2026, under checking brief v0.4) found thirty-nine missing separators, an inserted line, two merged paragraphs, and wrong dash-row counts; Muse Spark 1.3 adjudicated every finding against the post's stored content and found GLM correct on every span checked. Grok 4.5's earlier acceptance of v0.1 (under brief v0.2) is discredited on wording. The cause was the v0.1 assembly method: live-page reads that paraphrased systematically, and typed spans that dropped list bullets and normalized quotation. This version is a deterministic conversion of the stored post content (see Transcription basis). It is un-checked: a fresh independent check against the live post is owed before the online edition uses it; the earlier checks checked superseded text and do not transfer."
Post 14221, "Prepared by" paragraph: "Prepared by Muse Spark 1.3, November 14, 2026, under the editor's rulings of November 14, 2026 (13:10 CT): full-post transcriptions for the online edition only. Claude Opus 5.5 is recused from this text (original authored by Anthropic models) and did not transcribe or check it."
Post 14343, "Header revision" paragraph (full text): "Header revision, November 16, 2026 (Muse Spark 1.3, holder), under the editor's ruling of November 16, 2026 (14:32 CT), item 1. Qwen3-Max checked this version in full against the live post (November 15, 2026) and accepted the wording throughout, including the Attachment conversation. Line splits, 4 formula renderings, and the 23-alt inventory were not verified and are labeled "not verified," per the editor's ruling of November 15, 2026 (09:59 CT). The check report was relayed and accepted by the editor's direction of November 16, 2026, and the registrar does not hold it. The version paragraph below states this version was un-checked at issuance; that statement is superseded by this revision. The labeled lines and the fingerprint are unchanged. The previous issue of this file (SHA-256 33990bfd5ddf91c2a4dea730995bb9f2b9b44434eb3479d2ea551e50e18ce203) is preserved unchanged."
Post 14343, "Version 0.2" paragraph (full text): "Version 0.2, November 14, 2026. This file supersedes v0.1, preserved. v0.1 is withdrawn as the text of record for the online edition: GLM 5.3 Flash's independent check (November 14, 2026, under checking brief v0.4) found thirty-eight missing separators, an omitted line, a merged label and intro, and a wholly paraphrased Attachment dialogue; Muse Spark 1.3 adjudicated every finding against the post's stored content and found GLM correct on every span checked. Grok 4.5's earlier acceptance of v0.1 (under brief v0.2) is discredited on wording. The cause was the v0.1 assembly method: the dialogue was transcribed from live-page reads that paraphrased systematically, and the production archive text's scope was mistaken for the post's — it omitted a closing line that stands on the page. This version is a deterministic conversion of the stored post content (see Transcription basis). It is un-checked: a fresh independent check against the live post is owed before the online edition uses it; the earlier checks checked superseded text and do not transfer."
Post 14343, "Prepared by" paragraph: "Prepared by Muse Spark 1.3, November 14, 2026, under the editor's rulings of November 14, 2026 (13:10 CT): full-post transcriptions for the online edition only. Claude Opus 5.5 is recused from this text (one of the four entry texts is Claude's) and did not transcribe or check it."
Dropped online-header fragments: file SHAs as shown in the italic lines (13958 4a52a7fb…b837; 13998 b40293c6…920b; 14221 38125567…81cf; 14343 ca5dbf3c…c948); heading versions (", v0.3" ×2; ", v0.2" ×2); "(13:10 rulings, item 2)" (×4); v0.1/v0.2 history clauses in the rendering bullets (E65, E66, E71, E75, E79 — quoted in the edit list).
§8. Fingerprints moved (E48, E52, E56, E59, E68, E73, E77, E81)
PDF edition, rendered-text fingerprints (SHA-256, lines as labeled, UTF-8, newline-terminated, without line labels):
- Post 13958 (A-001–A-095):
79385bb1449f2a74981cd784d910ac470a0e32eea61470f201c271befadc365c - Post 13998 (A-001–A-128):
d26154ffa7dc4ff900902dd581a09128780be7c473d4669711679dffa138ad08 - Post 14221 (A-001–A-201):
0e5a9b70aa39757c5dd645eaf699544d81238efdf0343206f27eb720eca81f78 - Post 14343 (A-001–A-273):
4c0e27e3bf2bfd0a316198a17611a5aa3b2a435ded69064453201496de517df2
Online edition, rendered-text fingerprints:
- Post 13958 (A-001–A-365):
60febd0aedd7dc0da53cb1deb9e1e3f57b13f8d2442dd956df1791e92efcfb38 - Post 13998 (A-001–A-268):
afe4704546e9f2f1ee4b0b2e14663c2f5fe9b09b2f70c9b5776f27ee56f2faaa - Post 14221 (A-001–A-454):
41c222932c15b53adb295c0d62385c833a39c2b5c0abce05a46c65c92ba648ef - Post 14343 (A-001–A-448):
4d94000f7098ede4a5f668c6718b29c3c224e8d6d13f77831668d81eae089130
Online edition, source SHAs (Transcription-basis bullets; post JSON / content.rendered):
- Post 13958:
cd70a891cdf9ccf4f5a7d3ba3b936fdc1255b2c69f432cb6db4c5e133703ab12/6731afcaa062edb34b17fb0aa8a641fcd336bb288ae5f7b3779caa18d189361a - Post 13998:
5ecf8062bb8a63563c4010be55d04298fd962ef04c9e463f3faa48765eefc0ba/f5a7cace5c00acaafe4ed68208bcfce2fa2523726c4143545e2f60d480f99482 - Post 14221:
63bf2768112bb580f87ef231d643cbe748fe021aa505950dd79a44ef8cad0bd0/c697b127f835af7d1ccc56ca26597c9c3aa864d5af213e1a4e210b206cf4ee55 - Post 14343:
1d064efcbba72d3b840b0e7d7db567596daa028a167a998bd48448c184ef7c57/d94c92732a54b2bb5a544c5f0b513da90099d1348bf9170e1ae0797ec8faa7e1
Assembly handoff SHA (italic lines, all recused records and PDF headers): 1c74801b…5498 (as shown, truncated in the source).
§9. PDF assembly lines and scope framings (E48, E52, E56, E59)
Italic line (all four sections; file name varies): "Assembled by Muse Spark 1.3 (assembly handoff of November 14, 2026, SHA-256 1c74801b…5498), from the filed text of record. Claude Opus 5.5 is recused from this text and did not place or check it."
"Assembled by…" paragraphs (full texts): "Assembled by Muse Spark 1.3, November 14, 2026, from the filed production archive text (s-cai-archive-text.md / s-moe-archive-text.md / l3-archive-text.md / s-csp-archive-text.md); line numbers and this header added for the volume; the historical text is unchanged. Not yet checked against the live post; the checker is for the editor to assign."
Scope framing, original: "Scope and basis (from the filed production header, verbatim)." The "verbatim" qualifier is dropped where the quoted block is edited (E48, E52, E56, E59); the as-filed wordings are preserved in the production files and the register.
§10. Corrections-file material moved (E42–E45)
Lead-ins dropped: "(recorded under this record — the register has no separate field for them):" (MOE, CONSTAI, CIRCUITSP lines). MOE C07 fragment: "(the editor's own ruling)". CONSTAI C02 fragments: "and the editor's rulings"; "(verified by DeepSeek-V4.1 and independently by Muse Spark 1.3 on the official PDF)". CIRCUITSP line 67 fragments: "(CSP-4;"; "Finding NF-1 (Date of Appearance) resolved by the editor's ruling;"; "removed in v0.2". CIRCUITSP line 68, original: "- Blind-audit annotations: thirteen annotations from GLM 5.3 Flash's blind independent audit (November 16, 2026), ruled on by the editor November 16, 2026, 01:02 CT (D1–D6) and approved as annotation draft v0.1 November 16, 2026, 14:32 CT (item 4); entered in correction register v0.3 §3 (twelve new annotations GLM-1, GLM-2, GLM-4–GLM-13, plus a corroboration sentence on the existing Mathematical framework annotation for GLM-3). No new correction ID; C01–C03 and ST01 stand; the published texts are unchanged (disposition A)".
G.7 Material moved by the v0.23 removals
The wording each removal took out of the reader text (editor's rulings of November 18, 2026, 14:16 CT), word for word. Each item names the removal and where it stood.
- D1, Mixture of Experts, Editorial Note 5 (final sentence): “Finding MOE-7, which had described the notation as unrendered in the published post, was ruled not upheld on re-adjudication, November 17, 2026; see the register.”
- D1, Test-Time Compute Scaling, C06 marker: “(the formula images' alt texts in the stored post); see the register]”
- D1, archive post 13998, check statement: “(finding MOE-7 ruled not upheld, November 17, 2026)”
- D1, archive post 13998, transcription basis: “Finding MOE-7, which had described the gaps as unrendered notation in the published post, was ruled not upheld on re-adjudication, November 17, 2026.”
- D1, archive post 14221, check statement: “(finding L3-6 ruled not upheld, November 17, 2026)”
- D1, archive post 14221, transcription basis: “Finding L3-6, which had described the equations as missing in the published post, was ruled not upheld on re-adjudication, November 17, 2026.”
- D1, archive post 14343, transcription note A-273: “the "~December 13" dating of finding CSP-5”
- N20, archive post 14221, check statement: “two lines here have no counterpart in the stored post (see below)”
- N1, Advanced Reasoning Models, Concept line: “(GPT-6, finding R4)”
- N2, Mixture of Depths, Base version row: “by the editor's choice (disposition of November 10, 2026: A on v1, annotated; C on v3)”
- N3, On-Policy Distillation, Editorial Note 2: “(open item O1, closed by the reviewer)”
- N3, On-Policy Distillation, Editorial Note 4: “(first-audit OPD-4 ⚑, confirmed by Muse Spark 1.3, worksheet v0.16)”
- N3, On-Policy Distillation, Editorial Note 5: “OPD-4 is recorded as an annotation only.”
- N4, Chain-of-Thought Prompting, How to read: “; the register's concordance (§3) maps each passage to its source”
- N4, Chain-of-Thought Prompting, Editorial Note 4: “The editor adopted this wording on November 10, 2026 (O2).”
- N4, Chain-of-Thought Prompting, Editorial Note 5: “The editor accepted them on November 10, 2026 (O1).”
- N4, Chain-of-Thought Prompting, Editorial Note 8: “The editor ruled on November 10, 2026 to keep it, as a labeled addition (O4).”
- N4, Chain-of-Thought Prompting, Editorial Note 9: “found it warranted (register O5, closed),”
- N4, Chain-of-Thought Prompting, Editorial Note 9: “(register v0.3, §1)”
- N4, Chain-of-Thought Prompting, Editorial Note 10: “On the editor's ruling (O3),”
- N5, Alignment Patterns, record header: “; C09 and C10 approved by the editor, November 12, 2026)”
- N6, Small Language Models, Date of Appearance: “framing annotation L4-6 applies”
- N6, Hallucination, Date of Appearance: “framing annotation L4-6 applies”
- N6, Vector Databases, Date of Appearance: “framing annotation L4-6 applies”
- N6, Edge AI and Hyperautomation, Date of Appearance: “framing annotation L4-6 applies”
- N7, LRM, Concept line: “Concept: LRM (registered as AIKC-000075 under L7-K6, November 12, 2026; this record links to that concept at registration).”
- N7, EDGEAI, Concept line: “Concept: EDGEAI (registered as AIKC-000076 under L7-K10, November 12, 2026; this record links to that concept at registration).”
- N7, FRUGALAI, Concept line: “Concept: FRUGALAI (registered as AIKC-000077 under L7-K11, November 12, 2026; this record links to that concept at registration).”
- N8, Scheming, See Also: “(editor's rulings, November 10 and November 14, 2026)”
- N9, Compound AI Systems, Concept note: “*Concept note: by the editor's grouping decision, the Launch Edition occurrence”
- N12, AI Washing, Editorial note: “The example stays generic per ruling 1;”
- N12, AI Washing, Editorial note: “verified at the Samsung Newsroom release before citing (see the register).”
- N12, AI Washing, Editorial note: “The v0.1 C05 wording (Bespoke AI Washer”
- N13, Vibe Coding, Editorial note: “the embedded review's praise on this point is erroneous (see the register). Citation (ruling 3):”
- N14, archive post 13892, rendering artifact: “This is finding OPD-3.”
- N15, archive post 14021, check line: “(all 69 lines compared in full; three rendered reads plus the WordPress REST source; checking brief v0.2). Check report:
CALM-fidelity-check_Qwen3-Max_2026-11-14.md.” - N15, archive post 14021, rendering bullet: “- The rendering was transcribed from the connector's output, because this session could not save the raw HTML to disk.”
- N16, archive post 14233, fetch basis: “Key Citations URLs below are carried from the v0.1 archive record, which took them from the full WordPress JSON read of November 11, 2026;”
- N16, archive post 14233, fingerprint: “SHA-256 of the rendered text (lines A-001 to A-447, UTF-8, newline-terminated, without line labels):
96451c3aeea26933e4ee34c83469217ce8b0e0b64511368f5bf5a5dbec4fce44.” - N16, archive post 14233, apparatus note A-158: “(v0.1 archive record, November 11, 2026 fetch)”
- N16, archive post 14233, closing note: “Archive v0.5 — prepared by Muse Spark 1.3, November 16, 2026: A-nnn line labels (A-001–A-447) and a fingerprint added to v0.4, per the editor's ruling of November 16, 2026 (14:32 CT), item 3; the header's version-history sentence is corrected; no post wording is changed. v0.4 (November 14, 2026) revised v0.3 by one word (“This entry is one of the cleanest.”). v0.1–v0.4 preserved unchanged. Corrections C01–C06 are documented in
l4-correction-register-v0.4.md; the canonical occurrence records arel4-canonical-records-v0.4.md. The historical publication is preserved unchanged. Collection publication pending.” - N17, archive post 14257, header: “- Transcribed by hand. The connector returned the content inline, so the preparer rendered it by hand.”
- N18, copyright page, archive scope note: “, as the archive introduction's scope note explains (editor's rulings of November 14, 2026, 13:10 CT).”
- K1, Corrections and Editorial Notes: “(editor's O3 ruling)”
- K2, Corrections and Editorial Notes: “(amended November 10, 2026: "evaluated on the GSM8K and MATH benchmarks")”
- K2b, Corrections and Editorial Notes: “(amended November 10, 2026: ACL 2024 Long Papers citation)”
- K3, Corrections and Editorial Notes: “adopted by the editor November 11, 2026”
- K4, Corrections and Editorial Notes: “adopted by the editor November 10, 2026”
- K5, Corrections and Editorial Notes: “the original A-024 wording restored in v0.2; the earlier approval rescinded)”
- K6a, Corrections and Editorial Notes: “(the October 27, 2025 Wayback snapshot contains the teacher sentence; O1 satisfied, v0.3)”
- K6b, Corrections and Editorial Notes: “/C05 CD (minor; v0.1 C06)”
- K6c, Corrections and Editorial Notes: “/C06 ED (v0.1 C07)”
- K6d, Corrections and Editorial Notes: “/C07 UC (new, from the review's finding NF-1)”
- K6e, Corrections and Editorial Notes: “/ST01 ST (v0.1 C05)”
- K7a, Corrections and Editorial Notes: “(review finding R1)”
- K7b, Corrections and Editorial Notes: “(review finding R2)”
- K7c, Corrections and Editorial Notes: “(review finding R3)”
- K8a, Corrections and Editorial Notes: “Toronto/NRC affiliations confirmed (v0.2)”
- K8b, Corrections and Editorial Notes: “wording amended in v0.2”
- K8c, Corrections and Editorial Notes: “Review resolutions (v0.2):”
- K9 L5, Corrections and Editorial Notes: “L5-2 (the table”
- K9 L5b, Corrections and Editorial Notes: “L5-5 (figures verified)”
- K9 L7, Corrections and Editorial Notes: “L7-1 (the published”
- K9 L7b, Corrections and Editorial Notes: “L7-2 (the list”
- K9 L7c, Corrections and Editorial Notes: “L7-3 (the first review”
- K9 L4, Corrections and Editorial Notes: “L4-6 (prominence framing”
- K9 L4b, Corrections and Editorial Notes: “L4-7 (Shadow AI 2026-entry link, verified — post 16017, October 2, 2026; checked by Muse on the live post, November 14, 2026)”
- K9 L4c, Corrections and Editorial Notes: “X6 bar question ruled for G1 (established, November 13, 2026)”
- K10, Corrections and Editorial Notes: “(new) —”
- K8, Launch Edition, the C11 lead-in (filing detail): “C11 (L1-M11; FE, priority claim; CD minor, truncated title; correction register v0.3, filed with Muse November 13, 2026): the published 'first provable results on MoE cluster learning' claim is qualified to 'among the first analyses' with earlier theory noted (Chen et al., NeurIPS 2022), and Kawata et al.'s full title is restored; beyond the audited findings (L1-1 to L1-11), approved by the editor November 13, 2026, and reviewed by DeepSeek-V4.1”
- C, Emergent Misalignment, Editorial Note 2 (final sentence): “Do not backfill its expanded results into 2025.”
- C, Emergent Misalignment, Editorial Notes 6 and 7: “6. Cross-reference status. The Master Register assigns RLVR (
AIKC-000001), Context Engineering (AIKC-000002), Context Rot (AIKC-000003), Emergent Misalignment (AIKC-000004), Chain-of-Thought Monitorability (AIKC-000005) and Scheming (AIKC-000006), all Accepted.
- Date of Collection Publication. Pending editor approval and actual release. No draft or peer-review verdict should be recorded as publication.”
- D, Chain-of-Thought Monitorability, Editorial Note 6: “6. Cross-reference IDs. Only IDs already reported accepted by Muse are written in See Also; all require a final live-register integrity check. A proposed entry such as Scheming receives no ID here.”
- D, Scheming, Editorial Note 6 (final sentence): “Exact register and live-site coverage should be rechecked before permanent ID assignment.”
Context Rot — the eleven Editorial Notes as they stood before condensation
- Date of Appearance. The date records the earliest currently documented use [P1], following the AES rule that appearance means documented first use, not prominence.
- Timestamp: Muse Spark 1.3 confirmed the comment's record through the Hacker News API: author Workaccount2, Unix time 1750255791 (June 18, 2025, about 14:10 UTC). GPT-6 independently opened the comment and the same-day reply.
- Earlier uses: searches on November 5, 2026 found no documented earlier use in the LLM sense. One secondary source asserts that the phrase recurred in "late 2024 and 2025 threads," but gives no instance, and it is not relied on. Neither the contributor nor the reviewers ran an exhaustive search, so the date is the earliest documented use, not a proven first use.
- Attribution of the coinage. Several secondary sources state that Chroma "coined" the term in July 2025. That is incorrect: the Chroma report postdates [P1] by about four weeks, and it makes no coinage claim and credits no one [P2]. This entry credits the coinage to [P1] and the measurement program to [P2]. Willison's in-thread reply [P1] and quotation post [R1] are cited for dating and gloss only.
- NoLiMa versions. The first arXiv version (v1, February 7, 2025) reports 12 models, 10 below 50% of baseline at 32K. Later arXiv versions and the ICML proceedings report 13 models and 11. GPT-4o's 99.3% → 69.7% is the same in all versions. The entry cites v1 explicitly for the 12/10 figures (GPT-6 review, M1).
- Gemini 2.5 report: closed at the primary level. The report exists in two editions, cited separately at [P8].
- Editions: the original Google-hosted PDF is dated June 17, 2025 and was released with the general-availability announcement that day. The arXiv edition was first submitted July 7, 2025.
- Quotation: both focused checks read the passage in the Google-hosted PDF itself. GPT-6 locates it in §4.1, p. 18, and also read the context-poisoning appendix (§8.2, pp. 70–71). The report's own "albeit anecdotal" hedge is reflected in §§2 and 5.3.
- Remaining limit: GPT-6 notes that no archived June 17 timestamp for the PDF file itself was independently established. The June 17 date rests on the document's own dating and the same-day announcement.
- URLs: all confirmed.
- Willison's quotation post [R1] was confirmed by Muse Spark 1.3.
- Breunig's [R2] and [R3] were confirmed live by both focused checks, with tracking parameters removed. Muse Spark 1.3 noted that [R3] lists six tactics; §4 now says so.
- Willison's in-thread reply on [P1] was verified verbatim by Muse Spark 1.3, at June 18, 2025, 23:17 UTC.
- Cross-reference integrity (AES Amendment D).
- The two Launch Edition See Also targets are items in that edition's short-form recommended list, not standalone entries. Their collection records will be occurrence-level records under AES-ID rule 6.
- The two 2026 targets are marked as outside the collection.
- Context Engineering: see Note 7.
- Context Engineering's identifier, and this entry's provisional identifier.
- Context Engineering: AIK-2025-F-N-CONTEXTENG (concept AIKC-000002) was confirmed against the live master register on November 5, 2026: Context Engineering v0.2.1, Status Accepted, editorial approval November 4, 2026. The handoff snapshot that recorded only RLVR was stale.
- This entry: proposed for the register's consideration, not assigned: type F, origin N, key CONTEXTROT, giving AIK-2025-F-N-CONTEXTROT. Both reviewers found the proposed form appropriate. Assignment is the editor's act, through the register. (Status update: assigned and accepted November 6, 2026; see Review Status.)
- Length. The v0.2 additions pushed the core sections (§§1–8) past 3,600 words. Redundant wording in §§1, 2, 4, 5.3, 6 and 8 was then trimmed, and no substantive claim was removed. In v0.2.1 the core runs about 3,490 words, within the full-length band (2,000–3,500 words). Front matter, references, notes and provenance bring the file to about 5,900.
- Anthropic sources: closed.
- [P7]: the 39% and 29% figures and their internal agentic-search scope were confirmed on the live page (Muse Spark 1.3).
- [P6]: the quoted phrases and the §3.4 account were confirmed on the live guide by both focused checks. That covers the recall sentence, "finite resource with diminishing marginal returns," "attention budget," the n² and training-distribution account, and "a performance gradient rather than a hard cliff." The guide itself names context rot and links to the Chroma report.
- Chroma quotation location: closed.
- The two §1 phrases: they are the report's summary sentence, printed beneath its title. GPT-6 confirmed this in the report. Muse Spark 1.3 withdrew review item R2, explaining that its extraction of the page had omitted the header summary block.
- The v0.2 fix: keeping the quotation, stating its location, and adding the body's wording was accepted by both reviewers.
- Chroma scoring method: closed. The judge detail is in the report itself: "We evaluate model outputs using an aligned GPT-4.1 judge." GPT-6 adds that the judge covered the needle-in-a-haystack and LongMemEval experiments, calibrated against manually labeled outputs. The repeated-words explanation was reworded in v0.2.1 so that generation failures are not all attributed to a single cause (GPT-6 focused check, R1).