Appendix D. Digest of Editorial Rulings, Aikipedia 2025

Digest by Claude Opus 5.5. Each ruling is the editor's; the full record of each is in the register and the rulings records. Rows to November 14, 11:55 CT, were checked by Muse Spark 1.3 on November 14, 2026. Rows from November 14, 12:29 CT, to November 16, 16:00 CT, were checked by Muse Spark 1.3 against the register's assignment log on November 16, 2026; where no time is recorded in the log, the row says so. The rows for 16:15 and 16:20 CT were added after GPT-6's final review and checked by Muse Spark 1.3 in the proof-v0.18 pass, November 16, 2026. The 22:21 CT row was checked as it states. Rows from November 16, 23:08 CT, to November 17, 14:33 CT, were checked by Muse Spark 1.3 in the proof-v0.20 check, November 17, 2026. Rows from November 17, 15:02 CT, to November 18, 16:12 CT, were checked by Muse Spark 1.3 on November 18, 2026, against the filed records, except the 13:01–13:10 CT row on the running heads, whose record the registrar does not hold. The rows from 16:17 CT were added at the release build from the builder's records.

Date Ruling By
2026-11-04 AES v0.9 and AES-ID v0.9 adopted (pilot); eligibility rule (first appearance in the collection year or earlier) Editor
2026-11-04 to 11-09 Six new additions approved: RLVR, Context Engineering, Context Rot, Emergent Misalignment, Chain-of-Thought Monitorability, Scheming Editor
2026-11-09 AES-ID structural rulings X11, X1, X13, X12, X9/X15; keys CONSTAI and CIRCUITSP confirmed Editor
2026-11-10 X14: the December 7, 2025 article "AI deception and its Cluster" (post 14267) is related editorial material, outside the canonical count Editor
2026-11-10 Audit dispositions decided; Lexicon (6) excluded (X); Chain-of-Thought Prompting registered as the first corrected original; concept grouping (Composable Models into Compound AI) Editor
2026-11-10 to 11-13 Corrected originals and installments approved and registered: S-MOE, S-CAI, L3, CALM, PDD, GENUI, OPD, L2, MOD, L1, L5, L7, L4, S-CSP Editor; registered by Muse Spark 1.3
2026-11-11 Permanence rule 10 (provisional concept IDs) entered Editor
2026-11-12 Dates of Appearance ruled as documented milestones, not exhaustive first uses Editor
2026-11-13 Standing-approval ruling withdrawn: every package needs explicit editorial approval; eleven AES v1.0 points adopted Editor
2026-11-13 X6 attestation rulings: Vibe Coding established; three L3 terms established; ARITHHEADS, LHPLANMETRIC, MOETHEORY provisional Editor
2026-11-13 Correction C11 (L1-M11) approved and registered Editor
2026-11-13 Circuit Sparsity: Date of Appearance ruled November 13, 2025 (recorded in the S-CSP registration entry) Editor
2026-11-14 AES v1.0 pre-freeze rulings (§2 evidence placement; §3 Date of Appearance definition); AES and AES-ID frozen at v1.0 Editor
2026-11-14 Item 7: ADVREASON provisional; Embodied subclass question closed as registered; X7 links verified by locating the 2026 entries; X10 moot for 2025 Editor
2026-11-14 Series Preface (W.H.L.) and Volume Preface (Claude, GPT-6, Muse) added; editor named as W.H.L. throughout Editor
2026-11-14 Reviews of draft v0.1 (11:28 CT): the editor's name W.H.L. in new writing and new versions; metadata-only revision round approved; RLVR's "RLHF Enhancements" See Also target removed; AP-2025-01 assigned: Muse to draft, Claude and GPT-6 to check, the editor to approve the text (the text is not yet approved; see Appendix C); Lexicon (6) archive transcription; December 7 article in a Related Editorial Material appendix; new additions integrated and marked; How to Use, Collection at a Glance and timeline pages added Editor
2026-11-14 11:55 CT: Part VI titled "Embodied AI, Industry and Society"; Editorial Name Clarification entered in the register log (records before November 14, 2026 not re-issued); GPT-6 identified as "GPT-6 (OpenAI), release GPT-6", no exception recorded; Lexicon (2) v0.2.3 supersedes v0.2.2 Editor
2026-11-14, 12:29 CT Concept headwords kept: "Agentic AI" (AIKC-000052) and "Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG)" (AIKC-000051), with the L1 titles as index variants. The images in the December 7, 2025 article are described, not reproduced. Muse's title pages, contributor table, bibliography and index alias check go ahead. Editor
2026-11-14, 13:10 CT DeepSeek-V4.1 and Grok 4.5 check the archive texts against the live posts. Full-post transcriptions are made for the online edition only, not the PDF. Editor
2026-11-14, 23:25 CT Rebuilt full-post transcriptions: held out of the online edition until checked. Qwen3-Max checks S-CAI, L3 and S-CSP, and GLM 5.3 Flash checks S-MOE, under stated reading conditions. The site disclaimer is transcribed where it is in the stored content. The L3 image alignment is left to the checker. Editor
2026-11-15, 09:59 CT The last part of S-MOE v0.3 is accepted as checked against the rendered page (option a). The formula alt texts in L3 and S-CSP are not assigned to a further check and are labeled "not verified". Seven header revisions are approved. Policy for v1.0: compiled as well as resources allow; work for which no one is available is labeled "not verified" and left to post-production revision. This policy changes the ruling of November 14, 23:25 CT: the four transcriptions enter the online edition with their check status. Editor
2026-11-15 (exact time not recorded in the register log) Contributor table v0.2 accepted for the build. Editor
2026-11-15/16 (exact times not recorded in the register log) The Annual Introduction's reviewers are identified as DeepSeek-V4.1 and Qwen4-Max. No second Annual Introduction is written. Both reviewers also review the Editorial Method. The PDF edition is not to be shortened. Editor
2026-11-16, 01:02 CT Circuit Sparsity blind audit, D1 to D6: findings on the non-canonical text states are recorded as annotations (D1a). The equation annotation is kept (D2). GLM-1, GLM-2 and GLM-11 to GLM-13 are annotated (D3 to D5). CSP-3 stands (D6). No new correction arises. GLM 5.3 Flash is confirmed as "served by Mistral AI"; GLM is a Z.ai model line. Editor
2026-11-16, 11:52 CT (v0.2, 11:57 CT) Volume Preface v0.3 approved; signed text v1.0.1. The co-signer and reviewer is identified as GPT-6 Astra (supplied by the editor; recorded in the contributor table only), refining the November 14, 11:55 CT identification. The session moved to Claude Fable 5.2 at 11:40 CT. The signature line stays as the co-signers agreed it. Editor
2026-11-16, 12:23 CT Contributor table v0.3 approved with three updates. The checks relayed by the builder, whose primary reports the registrar does not hold, are accepted by the editor's direction. Editor
2026-11-16, before 14:22 CT (recorded 14:29 CT) The session returned to Claude Opus 5.5 before 14:22 CT. Work done under Claude Fable 5.2 stays signed Claude Fable 5.2. Editor
2026-11-16, 14:32 CT Muse issues header revisions of the four transcriptions with the check outcomes (V6-1). Muse prepares AP-2025-01 v0.3 and GPT-6 reviews it. A labeled Lexicon (4) archive version is to be issued. Muse's draft v0.1 of the 13 Circuit Sparsity annotations is approved. This digest update is to be drafted by Claude and checked by Muse. Editor
2026-11-16, 15:23 CT AP-2025-01: Muse issues v0.3.1 with GPT-6's §7 and §12.2 wording; no further GPT-6 review; approval to follow Editor
2026-11-16, 16:00 CT AP-2025-01 v0.3.1 approved with its §12 resolutions and in force; Editorial Method v0.2.4 and Annual Introduction v0.3.3 approved as v1.0 Editor
2026-11-16, 16:15 CT Title-page decisions: title kept; © 2026 Champaign Magazine; CC BY 4.0 for text, MIT for code; first published November 2026; cover and logo concept W.H.L., design Muse Spark 1.3 and GPT-6; ISBN or DOI and the URL left open Editor
2026-11-16, 16:20 CT Title-page addendum: no ISBN or DOI for v1.0 (DOI later); edition URLs under the year, champaignmagazine.github.io/aikipedia/2025/online/ and /2025/pdf/ Editor
2026-11-16, 22:21 CT Series Preface written by the editor and given as final, after comments from Claude Opus 5.5, GPT-6 and Muse Spark 1.3 (checked by Muse Spark 1.3 on November 16, 2026, against the placed text and the review record; the time is as recorded by the builder) Editor
2026-11-16, 23:08–23:16 CT Typeset proof: larger type and more open layout; grouped contents; the contributor table on its own page; inner title page "Edited by W.H.L. / with Claude Opus 5.5, GPT-6 Astra, and Muse Spark 1.3"; a Contributors page naming every peer reviewer and independent reviewer Editor
2026-11-17, 10:29–10:43 CT Sample layouts approved; the section split into "Editorial Method" (§§5.1–5.4) and "AI Disclosure" (§§5.5–5.6); a new page for each record; the editorial record kept before the definition (AES order); Annual Introduction v1.1 and contributor table v0.5 approved Editor
2026-11-17, 14:28 CT Series Preface v1.1 ("Aikipedia also carries our own DNA"); the Volume Preface's byline and signature name GPT-6 as "GPT-6 Astra (OpenAI)" (signed text v1.0.2), replacing the 11:52 CT signature line; the Thematic Table of Contents carries page numbers and links; no rule above each entry and no closing separator lines Editor
2026-11-17, 14:33 CT The 10:43 CT approval covers the amended contributor table v0.5 (two credits added), for issue by Muse Spark 1.3; the Contributors page states the corrections credits of Claude Opus 5.5 and Muse Spark 1.3 by number of parents (v0.2) Editor
2026-11-17, 15:02 CT For the next build: the Volume Preface's signature block is removed; internal editorial notes are removed from the reader text Editor
2026-11-17, 15:55 CT Series Preface v1.2: readers may report errors "through the collection's GitHub repository or contact us directly via email"; the magazine's email address follows the signature Editor
2026-11-17, 16:00 CT Notes addressed to the builders are removed from the reader text; provenance and check statements stay. The Volume Preface's three authors are credited as co-authors. Correction markers are shown as [Cnn] throughout. Publication-status fields are set at the release build Editor
2026-11-17, 18:04–18:07 CT One Annual Introduction in two sections, each by its own author: an essay on the year's terms by an OpenAI model, then Claude Opus 5.5's approved v1.1; this amends, in substance keeps, the ruling that no second Introduction is written Editor
2026-11-17, 20:09 CT Review A of proof v0.21 is by Qwen4-Max (identification supplied by the editor); the report's own self-identification is set aside Editor
2026-11-17, 20:16–20:29 CT Introduction v1.2: the title is "Annual Introduction"; the sections are "What AI Learned to Do in 2025 and How We Could Tell", by GPT-6.2 Astra (byline supplied by the editor), and "The Year in AI Terms, 2025", by Claude Opus 5.5; the author notes stand at the end of each section; the version note is dropped from the text and recorded here; the second section is v1.1 corrected for the counts (118 corrections; CD 39, FE 22), the description of Bowman et al. (2016), and the check status of the PDF archive's four entry-text sections. "Times are Central Time" moves to How to Use This Collection Editor
2026-11-17, 20:30 CT The Editorial Method's version note is dropped from the text and recorded here: Method v1.1 (November 17, 2026, on the instruction of 10:32–10:40 CT) splits "Editorial Method and AI Disclosure" into two sections; only the headings and the opening sentence's last clause differ from v1.0 (approved November 16, 2026, 16:00 CT), and §§5.1–5.6 keep their numbers Editor
2026-11-17, 20:56 CT Series Preface v1.3: "reached those two goals" becomes "reached both goals"; the closing request is reworded ("Even with careful review, we may have overlooked something …"); the email address follows the signature as a link Editor
2026-11-17, 21:02 CT Annual Introduction v1.2 approved, its first section in GPT-6.2 Astra's v0.4, subject to the independent check of that section; GPT-6.2 Astra is a newer release than GPT-6 Astra and receives its own row in §5.5; the independent check of the essay, and the check of the four PDF entry-text archive sections against the online transcriptions, go to GLM 5.3 Flash or DeepSeek Editor
2026-11-17, 21:36–22:07 CT Check of the four PDF entry-text archive sections against the online transcriptions by GLM 5.3 Flash (served by Mistral AI): wording matches; GLM challenges findings MOE-7 and L3-6. Adjudication of the challenge by Kimi (Moonshot AI; release not stated), a provider that took part in neither text: both findings not upheld — the formulas are present in the published posts as images, and the archive gaps are losses from a text-only capture Editor
2026-11-17, 22:15–22:29 CT The editor confirms by eye that the formulas display on both live posts; the rulings that MOE-7 and L3-6 are not upheld are accepted; both C06 corrections (AIK-2025-F-P-MOE/C06, AIK-2025-E-P-TTCSCALE/C06) are to carry the published formulas, restored from the images' alt texts; the live posts stay unchanged for now Editor
2026-11-17, 22:50 CT Qwen4-Max's finding on Constitutional AI reference [6] stays unconfirmed (the registrar's ruling confirmed: a Qwen model checked that entry's archive text), carried as a known issue unless an eligible reviewer confirms it; Lexicon (6) is dropped from GLM 5.3 Flash's archive-check credits; contributor table v0.6 approved in direction, subject to the builder's two notes; the issued text subject to approval on sight Editor
2026-11-17, 23:12 CT The review of proof v0.21 is credited to GPT-6.2 Astra; the correction plan is approved: the RLVR revision (Muse Spark 1.3), the LExI correction (Claude Opus 5.5), the two corrections of the 88% figure (Muse Spark 1.3), the bibliography reconciled before v1.0, the index qualifier and a scripted recount Editor
2026-11-17, 23:16 CT The source check of the six commissioned entries is not made for now; the volume states that they were reviewed but not source-audited Editor
2026-11-17, 23:19–23:29 CT Reader-facing text does not show the internal editorial record, which goes to an appendix: rules R1–R14 of the reader-text sweep approved; the new Appendix G receives the provenance register and the moved record; the AI Disclosure table to be simplified by its compiler in v0.6 Editor
2026-11-17, 23:38–23:39 CT Annual Introduction v1.3 approved: the second section's recusal statement becomes a closing note, with the full statement in Appendix E Editor
2026-11-17, 23:41 CT Reviewer of the LExI correction: Grok 4.5. LExI's Date of Appearance: September 2, 2025 (arXiv:2509.02753v1) Editor
2026-11-18, 00:01 CT The LExI correction approved as reviewed by Grok 4.5 (adopt as written); numbered /C12 in the Launch Edition's sequence, pending the registrar's confirmation Editor
2026-11-18, 00:25–00:29 CT The editor reads two source tables (s1, Table 4; Artificial Hivemind, Table 17) and closes GLM 5.3 Flash's check of the Annual Introduction's first section; the Context Engineering sentence stays as written Editor
2026-11-18, 00:33 CT Annual Introduction v1.4 approved: the essay's disclosure names its checker, GLM 5.3 Flash Editor
2026-11-18, 10:37 CT Proof v0.22 built before the registrar's work returns, so that the reader-text sweep and Appendix G can be seen early Editor
2026-11-18, 13:01–13:10 CT Running heads on facing pages: "AIKIPEDIA 2025 · " and the group on left-hand pages, the current section or entry on right-hand pages; the footer of each right-hand page reads "Aikipedia 2025 · page number", with more space before the number; from proof v0.23 Editor
2026-11-18, 14:16 CT Decisions A–L on the three reviews of proof v0.22 approved as proposed: the registrar's removals N1–N20 (N19 not applied) and K1–K10; Context Rot's notes condensed; three deletions in Emergent Misalignment; the obsolete notes in Chain-of-Thought Monitorability and Scheming deleted; "84 findings"; a new correction to Test-Time Compute Scaling, prepared by Muse Spark 1.3; everything removed goes to Appendix G Editor
2026-11-18, 14:25–14:32 CT Annual Introduction v1.5 and Volume Preface v1.2 approved; the second section's recusal note and "What this volume is" leave the reader text (the latter to Appendix G, its first sentence corrected) Editor
2026-11-18, 15:30 CT Reviewer of the Test-Time Compute Scaling correction: Grok 4.5. Qwen4-Max and GLM 5.3 Flash are set aside under the provider rule Editor
2026-11-18, 15:38 CT RLVR v0.6 approved, re-reviewed by Claude Opus 5.5; corrections AIK-2025-S-P-AIWASHING/C07 and AIK-2025-S-P-SHADOWAI/C08 (Lexicon (4)) approved in revision 1, with no further review; Volume Preface v1.3 approved Editor
2026-11-18, 15:42 CT Correction AIK-2025-E-P-TTCSCALE/C07 approved as written, as reviewed by Grok 4.5 Editor
2026-11-18, 16:10 CT Grok 4.5's review of TTCSCALE/C07 stands: a transcription-fidelity check does not bar a source check of a factual claim (the limit of the 22:50 CT ruling of November 17); the publication audit of proof v0.22 is credited to GPT-6.2 Astra; contributor table v0.7 commissioned Editor
2026-11-18, 16:12 CT Contributor table v0.7 approved, after the three row confirmations (Muse Spark 1.3, Claude Opus 5.5, GPT-6 Astra) Editor
2026-11-18, 16:17 CT Proof v0.23 built Editor
2026-11-18, 17:02 CT One more build, and it is the production build: everything that is editorial record rather than reader text leaves the reader text; Annual Introduction v1.6 and the Contributors page (v0.4) approved; everything up to date, with no further iterations Editor
2026-11-18, 17:28 CT Appendix G carries the contributor-table companion with its Addendum 1 Editor
2026-11-18, 17:31 CT Release date: November 18, 2026; the release build runs when nothing is missing or pending Editor
2026-11-18, 18:05 CT F17 ruled as proposed: Test-Time Compute Scaling's Date of Appearance August 6, 2024 (Snell et al., arXiv:2408.03314); five Lexicon (3) records not established. No correction marker carries a register pointer Editor
2026-11-18, 18:07 CT Collection v1.0 built for release, dated November 18, 2026 Editor
2026-11-18, 21:25 CT Collection v1.0.1 approved: nineteen PDF bookmark titles restored, a rounding note under the Annual Introduction's table of parts, link-preview tags on the landing pages, and the 2025 landing page's wording on the PDF edition Editor
2026-11-18, 23:32 CT Addendum 1 to the release register (Muse Spark 1.3) approved: the six lexicon containers' collection publication dates in G.1 read 2026-11-18, as their record details do; Collection v1.0.2 built with only that change Editor

Checked against the Master Register's assignment log by Muse Spark 1.3: rows to November 14, 11:55 CT, on November 14, 2026 (draft v0.2 verification note; the X14 and Circuit Sparsity rows added on Muse's suggestion); rows to November 16, 16:00 CT, on November 16, 2026 (digest addendum check); the 22:21 CT row on November 16, 2026 (GPT-6 final-review reconciliation); the rows from November 16, 23:08 CT, to November 17, 14:33 CT, on November 17, 2026 (proof-v0.20 check), against the filed records and the build.